* [Bloat] Fwd: Open Source Needs You to Act - Help Fight Proposed Patent Rules
[not found] <1685538041767.34e911eb-3b5c-4a42-b5b0-89ccfd0f8008@bf01.hubspotstarter.net>
@ 2023-05-31 13:07 ` Dave Taht
2023-05-31 13:14 ` Dave Collier-Brown
0 siblings, 1 reply; 3+ messages in thread
From: Dave Taht @ 2023-05-31 13:07 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: bloat, libreqos
[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 7768 bytes --]
just when I thought it was safe to stop worrying about patents
---------- Forwarded message ---------
From: Open Invention Network <emeintzer@openinventionnetwork.com>
Date: Wed, May 31, 2023 at 7:03 AM
Subject: Open Source Needs You to Act - Help Fight Proposed Patent Rules
To: <dave.taht@gmail.com>
Proposed USPTO proposed rules will make it harder to defend OSS against bad
patents in the hands of PAEs. Fight back by June 20th.
[image: OIN-NoBkgrd-1]
[image: together-difference-2]
<https://cfT5B04.na1.hubspotlinksstarter.com/Ctc/I2+113/cfT5B04/VVN7d58C75qbW2rDHF57vsP7zVhPn1w4_cKf1N65wGVh3lSbNV1-WJV7CgPpZW8_WQmN2dk-3JW86QrVj5FcwgjVm4MSZ2LD5QlN616MK51BSg5W58KQkv3FFX59W6H8PwP73X90MW60PR_N1r9mjgW84GMXw8bXK6HW6vx-Hc3gjL9tW3nSvPG5Hn1hRW5BLSzn583kWtW737M2W5L3GFzW94HJXp6fkZFsW3CzgPT1N94n9W4S0gK781F-R2W8qQVJD6WZ46lW5fmx258zF-NbW2jVmV331_nQ7W3G_8r21Gt7DLVjWY3c4kk2mTW19vcHw2d34LPN8NVYLSF8RQ03ckF1>
Hi Dave!
* Open Source Needs You to Act - *
Help Fight Proposed Patent Rules
*ISSUE*
The U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) has issued a set of proposed
rules
<https://cfT5B04.na1.hubspotlinksstarter.com/Ctc/I2+113/cfT5B04/VVN7d58C75qbW2rDHF57vsP7zVhPn1w4_cKf1N65wGVh5knJZV3Zsc37CgPXMW62WJCb6ydvJtW3jylL55llyjhVY3PjB21W9RZW4TkVpR7cz_z2W6Cnnfs7L7gHCW8_wFkP6Jn49kW4D5fNX1GqM15W61CS3C4XsBs6W38tJ7y6k40_-W3Sm14N5fPkJ5W8bxpSK4MlZFGW6rHq8-205vQQW65D3482jyDzMW6cMzp54x-CBVW1qWdTn2PXjvNW5sw4gp5pZnccW5KmNs02C2lH7W3S-WSq7L8C07W8d4xPD2jGQb4W46dlDj79VD-hW4Q-z6J3FtykWW6YV2Mb3xCcpnW5DzW6W7JCXmsW4GSFl64nnHgnW50jd942hSWs8N9dDsvbHP8Q8W8tk8TX2ny-t_W2pcZy12DJTrVW1yt3-H1LkrdCW88P9zg3VCS7dW5JCNpz3kPWZDW47KwLd8LRdt1W13zK_x67VvP4W3MQGrC8F_Y_bN4rBYLJ27rHlW3mzxST2-8rR8W84S6Tv9cCmqyW6QDLqD9dPTps36yJ1>,
nearly all of which will make it harder to challenge poor-quality patents.
If implemented, these rules will make it harder to defend open source
software (OSS) against bad patents in the hands of patent trolls.
*BACKGROUND & IMPACT*
OIN & other open source supporters — IBM, Microsoft & The Linux Foundation
— funded Unified Patents’ Open Source Zone in 2019. Since then, this
program has challenged dozens of poor-quality, open-source related patents
with excellent success. The newly-proposed USPTO rules will negatively
affect the Open Source Zone’s ability to challenge patents, even though
many of the rules are apparently outside of the USPTO's authority
<https://cfT5B04.na1.hubspotlinksstarter.com/Ctc/I2+113/cfT5B04/VVN7d58C75qbW2rDHF57vsP7zVhPn1w4_cKf1N65wGTp5knJ3V3Zsc37CgTbLW4rwkT95P5114W7Fk50R6sXBj0W43dQ8V6fR3X6W9cwNjD1Wmp6mW1LnVhP2X7JXNN8p1y4N6w2CwN6sknN32WBRLW88fzK96xpBVKW1tZZ5f8Tkt2LW5jJKdj1VR3D9W353xnN95LnvvW6lzGc-1ybtrYW5MkNsT14svwJW7H5xmK5hLZ9FW8NHK4_7DW5_GW6mXX9964pCX8W7_BSkB6fyqGpW4jHLnB8rWT27VRp2wM27WmlxW2NwQ6Q99-D5vW2qBpg43YS3wLW2g-rZv39gCKfN889GZB_1s89W8bN0nN7Hp9d7Vh3S_18DGslLW8qwXhX6fXRhlW2QBJxq8zYFF7W80tQgH4B3PPcN3hJFWyFkTMtW1053Lp6dpfWFW6F_bHd15cs9CW1P-J256s9m433p1T1>
and plainly inconsistent with the intentions of the legislators that passed
the America Invents Act. They may also prevent organizations like OIN and
others from seeking patent reviews.
If these rules are enacted, patents that slipped through the system and
should have never been issued in the first place will:
- Be increasingly litigated against developers and users of OSS,
including businesses that rely on open source
- Raise the already high cost of patent litigation and cost
hundreds-of-millions of dollars, according to an economic impact study
<https://cfT5B04.na1.hubspotlinksstarter.com/Ctc/I2+113/cfT5B04/VVN7d58C75qbW2rDHF57vsP7zVhPn1w4_cKf1N65wGVB3lSc3V1-WJV7CgJ6kVDLjdm15bnPcVYMFWX7qNKF6W6g4SFk59pdMNW70Zb1c6bxxh8W7BcZrr2KtBLTW8BNQQ51XcXVCW91ycZr7S5wTlW3_xGQp9hM1TWW6D0ym31z8Yd0N54Smc1p-NgZW3_08zt7n1CRpW6KFD_T24CHQHW5cMx6j75td3GW47z6t527tkV3VXMltY5697NCN1F2tSgJggr2W6yxyrR3tNtYbW9fwjh61KjNK3W5RwxNk3jm_FzW6CpSYD8wvl8xN6yPLZY4xqjYW7YcZSN3z62S2W5R1GQM5Y4_lkW8JSnlP8XzXq837d31>
- Impact all open source organizations worldwide that have a developer,
supplier or customer in the United States
- Make business more difficult in the United States, and slow innovation
globally
As it is critical to OSS that we help stop this proposal, The Linux
Foundation is hosting a free webinar entitled "Stopping Patent Trolls: Why
Open Source Urgently Needs Your Help, Now!", on June 7, 2023 10:30 AM PDT
(GMT - 7). To join the webinar and learn more, please register here
<https://cfT5B04.na1.hubspotlinksstarter.com/Ctc/I2+113/cfT5B04/VVN7d58C75qbW2rDHF57vsP7zVhPn1w4_cKf1N65wGWt3lScZV1-WJV7CgXZzVxj2JC2q8JbDW3cCdYs7mYrzhW2Djs5k387GVXVTnr__5P9xGgW5Rlt2Z7x7GmqW9csYrP2VGPhCW1TtDfY1LqWM6W1W3_Pf8XbDlHW2Tz7FR7TFpPFW58f67_2pkl7nW3D6s0M8cwVh6W5rcNrl4fwkvJW5qFY401jZJyrV7s-WC8MvwsxW2BTjwX1ldTNTW2pgkRq9hQZ7lW5CtlLG2HBx7KVGxZj72fSp-2W6BsPlG77G_f3W7-qV271mzb4kW2XGKwh7jPt05W44xHmp5R83BZW5dr0pB7X1xynW6yWX_l7lyQj0W5p8XRV4h-Tl-W13-R0P1qyWK-W8-C-JK3xXDsbW3mcwQQ6yh2xYW4-Wcyp6cJ9K2W4tpysY7wm7qk3jP-1>
.
*ACTION*
Please take a few minutes to share your thoughts, however brief, by selecting
the green box
<https://cfT5B04.na1.hubspotlinksstarter.com/Ctc/I2+113/cfT5B04/VVN7d58C75qbW2rDHF57vsP7zVhPn1w4_cKf1N65wGVh5knJZV3Zsc37CgG9vW5-JJs04KKwfNW6yszb21GG8SzW1shmvT3T3RnYW6TFhZ77cLqJLW3k4bJs8sJpFtW3nCQjm3xfS9-W8KKcG08xXlHvW2sNgsf3-zkPCW77GGLp6Sq1zbW3W9h_X1TYKVFW6SlWgl5Qt4nRW50xq111zkDpPW87bqMK263J1PW7hQf4j19XSMBV6tTWP1LnbrDW3rZt3x6Pcq_HW2DvWhH4Q6-42W6THFM52LbWhNN8vXc8XYBfH2W300jMZ7Lyh7-W3CNw2Q177NNDW80dh_T3Zwq6dW3zmsgN1TtSf1N6vZq82hZ0lfW4WWf0B20gfffW3lGgTz7QKqR4W3K5gxY7LSd0GW64T9T22TL7P3VKrb0628yz_rW12C8cG3G-Y2rVqbmkT63BwGYW1tNvVP492yJqW8dDZ6K5__dg9W27Lhzv5VK2Y5W1QM76h8WrJxkN5jdzKNbXVR0MHjL8Bn1Dh1W8XzfZY3kyh1m3h151>
titled “Submit a formal comment.” If you want to submit more detailed
comments, or have any questions or concerns about what is at stake,
please contact
Jonathan Stroud <jonathan@unifiedpatents.com> at Unified Patents.
*DEADLINE*
*Your comments must be received by June 20, 2023* *11:59 PM EDT (GMT - 4).*
Sincerely,
[image: Keith-Signature]
Keith Bergelt *Chief Executive Officer*
[image: OIN_logo_300dpi]
<https://cfT5B04.na1.hubspotlinksstarter.com/Ctc/I2+113/cfT5B04/VVN7d58C75qbW2rDHF57vsP7zVhPn1w4_cKf1N65wGVh3lSbNV1-WJV7CgYtSW13QxpQ4_VcBzW5ZSG-z10b8X-N548Gxd1780GW7JD4665vNDZLW4W6kvH4gqxKkW4G2XwB21tCsbW4tQpqT69WDzWW6yYNTW6V0nPJW4G9sFN2Bt4xVVszf4b4CW_fhN1wd8hLVQMjPN6GyYSdrZZ9TW7hYknF7txR_CV4h8DS5QXNn4W3Vq3v-29N5KMW7sbMGL3Ps7M-W95vfG63bNJG1N760kJZD3_ffW2pbWT94hFjBwW337cQd4sP-LkW3XJVvL3PGLtdW54v9c16q41Yn38kp1>
Open Invention Network, 4819 Emperor Blvd., Suite 400, Durham, NC 27703,
USA, +1 (919) 313-4902
Unsubscribe
<https://hs-2181469.s.hubspotstarter.net/email-unsubscribe/email?product=emailStarter&checkSubscriptions=all&d=VnchdX5m56KTVKg8Bx3JFwWpW3R5c3D3_R592N1JxwY5WJtm6N1fk4d_jS9VsW8wmcll7XBlM0W75X_7H6zFP5TW1WPHjB5t57MyMGKd_P20N6HVGCW5S24by21VmqcCR5YxlTl4-BSH1&v=2&email=dave.taht%40gmail.com&utm_source=hs_email&utm_medium=email&utm_content=260354620&_hsenc=p2ANqtz-985rfD7hQmyXnFP9Y5wXAcZtXuGAc29_HtkaL8Dz7gObekn7pPiCruAtRXa8l1LsLT3bpaDXmCDeVSZ-t2acYf7h_Vuw&_hsmi=260354620>
Manage
preferences
<https://hs-2181469.s.hubspotstarter.net/email-unsubscribe/email?product=emailStarter&d=VnchdX5m56KTVKg8Bx3JFwWpW3R5c3D3_R592N1JxwY5WJtm6N1fk4d_jS9VsW8wmcll7XBlM0W75X_7H6zFP5TW1WPHjB5t57MyMGKd_P20N6HVGCW5S24by21VmqcCR5YxlTl4-BSH1&v=2&email=dave.taht%40gmail.com&utm_source=hs_email&utm_medium=email&utm_content=260354620&_hsenc=p2ANqtz-985rfD7hQmyXnFP9Y5wXAcZtXuGAc29_HtkaL8Dz7gObekn7pPiCruAtRXa8l1LsLT3bpaDXmCDeVSZ-t2acYf7h_Vuw&_hsmi=260354620>
--
Podcast:
https://www.linkedin.com/feed/update/urn:li:activity:7058793910227111937/
Dave Täht CSO, LibreQos
[-- Attachment #2: Type: text/html, Size: 23172 bytes --]
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 3+ messages in thread
* Re: [Bloat] Fwd: Open Source Needs You to Act - Help Fight Proposed Patent Rules
2023-05-31 13:07 ` [Bloat] Fwd: Open Source Needs You to Act - Help Fight Proposed Patent Rules Dave Taht
@ 2023-05-31 13:14 ` Dave Collier-Brown
2023-06-01 1:59 ` Dave Taht
0 siblings, 1 reply; 3+ messages in thread
From: Dave Collier-Brown @ 2023-05-31 13:14 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: bloat
[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 9300 bytes --]
Does the community wish to make a submission to the commission, and if so, to which aspects of the issue?
--dave
On 5/31/23 09:07, Dave Taht via Bloat wrote:
just when I thought it was safe to stop worrying about patents
---------- Forwarded message ---------
From: Open Invention Network <emeintzer@openinventionnetwork.com<mailto:emeintzer@openinventionnetwork.com>>
Date: Wed, May 31, 2023 at 7:03 AM
Subject: Open Source Needs You to Act - Help Fight Proposed Patent Rules
To: <dave.taht@gmail.com<mailto:dave.taht@gmail.com>>
Proposed USPTO proposed rules will make it harder to defend OSS against bad patents in the hands of PAEs. Fight back by June 20th.
[OIN-NoBkgrd-1]
[together-difference-2] <https://cfT5B04.na1.hubspotlinksstarter.com/Ctc/I2+113/cfT5B04/VVN7d58C75qbW2rDHF57vsP7zVhPn1w4_cKf1N65wGVh3lSbNV1-WJV7CgPpZW8_WQmN2dk-3JW86QrVj5FcwgjVm4MSZ2LD5QlN616MK51BSg5W58KQkv3FFX59W6H8PwP73X90MW60PR_N1r9mjgW84GMXw8bXK6HW6vx-Hc3gjL9tW3nSvPG5Hn1hRW5BLSzn583kWtW737M2W5L3GFzW94HJXp6fkZFsW3CzgPT1N94n9W4S0gK781F-R2W8qQVJD6WZ46lW5fmx258zF-NbW2jVmV331_nQ7W3G_8r21Gt7DLVjWY3c4kk2mTW19vcHw2d34LPN8NVYLSF8RQ03ckF1>
Hi Dave!
Open Source Needs You to Act -
Help Fight Proposed Patent Rules
ISSUE
The U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) has issued a set of proposed rules<https://cfT5B04.na1.hubspotlinksstarter.com/Ctc/I2+113/cfT5B04/VVN7d58C75qbW2rDHF57vsP7zVhPn1w4_cKf1N65wGVh5knJZV3Zsc37CgPXMW62WJCb6ydvJtW3jylL55llyjhVY3PjB21W9RZW4TkVpR7cz_z2W6Cnnfs7L7gHCW8_wFkP6Jn49kW4D5fNX1GqM15W61CS3C4XsBs6W38tJ7y6k40_-W3Sm14N5fPkJ5W8bxpSK4MlZFGW6rHq8-205vQQW65D3482jyDzMW6cMzp54x-CBVW1qWdTn2PXjvNW5sw4gp5pZnccW5KmNs02C2lH7W3S-WSq7L8C07W8d4xPD2jGQb4W46dlDj79VD-hW4Q-z6J3FtykWW6YV2Mb3xCcpnW5DzW6W7JCXmsW4GSFl64nnHgnW50jd942hSWs8N9dDsvbHP8Q8W8tk8TX2ny-t_W2pcZy12DJTrVW1yt3-H1LkrdCW88P9zg3VCS7dW5JCNpz3kPWZDW47KwLd8LRdt1W13zK_x67VvP4W3MQGrC8F_Y_bN4rBYLJ27rHlW3mzxST2-8rR8W84S6Tv9cCmqyW6QDLqD9dPTps36yJ1>, nearly all of which will make it harder to challenge poor-quality patents. If implemented, these rules will make it harder to defend open source software (OSS) against bad patents in the hands of patent trolls.
BACKGROUND & IMPACT
OIN & other open source supporters — IBM, Microsoft & The Linux Foundation — funded Unified Patents’ Open Source Zone in 2019. Since then, this program has challenged dozens of poor-quality, open-source related patents with excellent success. The newly-proposed USPTO rules will negatively affect the Open Source Zone’s ability to challenge patents, even though many of the rules are apparently outside of the USPTO's authority<https://cfT5B04.na1.hubspotlinksstarter.com/Ctc/I2+113/cfT5B04/VVN7d58C75qbW2rDHF57vsP7zVhPn1w4_cKf1N65wGTp5knJ3V3Zsc37CgTbLW4rwkT95P5114W7Fk50R6sXBj0W43dQ8V6fR3X6W9cwNjD1Wmp6mW1LnVhP2X7JXNN8p1y4N6w2CwN6sknN32WBRLW88fzK96xpBVKW1tZZ5f8Tkt2LW5jJKdj1VR3D9W353xnN95LnvvW6lzGc-1ybtrYW5MkNsT14svwJW7H5xmK5hLZ9FW8NHK4_7DW5_GW6mXX9964pCX8W7_BSkB6fyqGpW4jHLnB8rWT27VRp2wM27WmlxW2NwQ6Q99-D5vW2qBpg43YS3wLW2g-rZv39gCKfN889GZB_1s89W8bN0nN7Hp9d7Vh3S_18DGslLW8qwXhX6fXRhlW2QBJxq8zYFF7W80tQgH4B3PPcN3hJFWyFkTMtW1053Lp6dpfWFW6F_bHd15cs9CW1P-J256s9m433p1T1> and plainly inconsistent with the intentions of the legislators that passed the America Invents Act. They may also prevent organizations like OIN and others from seeking patent reviews.
If these rules are enacted, patents that slipped through the system and should have never been issued in the first place will:
* Be increasingly litigated against developers and users of OSS, including businesses that rely on open source
* Raise the already high cost of patent litigation and cost hundreds-of-millions of dollars, according to an economic impact study<https://cfT5B04.na1.hubspotlinksstarter.com/Ctc/I2+113/cfT5B04/VVN7d58C75qbW2rDHF57vsP7zVhPn1w4_cKf1N65wGVB3lSc3V1-WJV7CgJ6kVDLjdm15bnPcVYMFWX7qNKF6W6g4SFk59pdMNW70Zb1c6bxxh8W7BcZrr2KtBLTW8BNQQ51XcXVCW91ycZr7S5wTlW3_xGQp9hM1TWW6D0ym31z8Yd0N54Smc1p-NgZW3_08zt7n1CRpW6KFD_T24CHQHW5cMx6j75td3GW47z6t527tkV3VXMltY5697NCN1F2tSgJggr2W6yxyrR3tNtYbW9fwjh61KjNK3W5RwxNk3jm_FzW6CpSYD8wvl8xN6yPLZY4xqjYW7YcZSN3z62S2W5R1GQM5Y4_lkW8JSnlP8XzXq837d31>
* Impact all open source organizations worldwide that have a developer, supplier or customer in the United States
* Make business more difficult in the United States, and slow innovation globally
As it is critical to OSS that we help stop this proposal, The Linux Foundation is hosting a free webinar entitled "Stopping Patent Trolls: Why Open Source Urgently Needs Your Help, Now!", on June 7, 2023 10:30 AM PDT (GMT - 7). To join the webinar and learn more, please register here<https://cfT5B04.na1.hubspotlinksstarter.com/Ctc/I2+113/cfT5B04/VVN7d58C75qbW2rDHF57vsP7zVhPn1w4_cKf1N65wGWt3lScZV1-WJV7CgXZzVxj2JC2q8JbDW3cCdYs7mYrzhW2Djs5k387GVXVTnr__5P9xGgW5Rlt2Z7x7GmqW9csYrP2VGPhCW1TtDfY1LqWM6W1W3_Pf8XbDlHW2Tz7FR7TFpPFW58f67_2pkl7nW3D6s0M8cwVh6W5rcNrl4fwkvJW5qFY401jZJyrV7s-WC8MvwsxW2BTjwX1ldTNTW2pgkRq9hQZ7lW5CtlLG2HBx7KVGxZj72fSp-2W6BsPlG77G_f3W7-qV271mzb4kW2XGKwh7jPt05W44xHmp5R83BZW5dr0pB7X1xynW6yWX_l7lyQj0W5p8XRV4h-Tl-W13-R0P1qyWK-W8-C-JK3xXDsbW3mcwQQ6yh2xYW4-Wcyp6cJ9K2W4tpysY7wm7qk3jP-1>.
ACTION
Please take a few minutes to share your thoughts, however brief, by selecting the green box<https://cfT5B04.na1.hubspotlinksstarter.com/Ctc/I2+113/cfT5B04/VVN7d58C75qbW2rDHF57vsP7zVhPn1w4_cKf1N65wGVh5knJZV3Zsc37CgG9vW5-JJs04KKwfNW6yszb21GG8SzW1shmvT3T3RnYW6TFhZ77cLqJLW3k4bJs8sJpFtW3nCQjm3xfS9-W8KKcG08xXlHvW2sNgsf3-zkPCW77GGLp6Sq1zbW3W9h_X1TYKVFW6SlWgl5Qt4nRW50xq111zkDpPW87bqMK263J1PW7hQf4j19XSMBV6tTWP1LnbrDW3rZt3x6Pcq_HW2DvWhH4Q6-42W6THFM52LbWhNN8vXc8XYBfH2W300jMZ7Lyh7-W3CNw2Q177NNDW80dh_T3Zwq6dW3zmsgN1TtSf1N6vZq82hZ0lfW4WWf0B20gfffW3lGgTz7QKqR4W3K5gxY7LSd0GW64T9T22TL7P3VKrb0628yz_rW12C8cG3G-Y2rVqbmkT63BwGYW1tNvVP492yJqW8dDZ6K5__dg9W27Lhzv5VK2Y5W1QM76h8WrJxkN5jdzKNbXVR0MHjL8Bn1Dh1W8XzfZY3kyh1m3h151> titled “Submit a formal comment.” If you want to submit more detailed comments, or have any questions or concerns about what is at stake, please contact Jonathan Stroud<mailto:jonathan@unifiedpatents.com> at Unified Patents.
DEADLINE
Your comments must be received by June 20, 2023 11:59 PM EDT (GMT - 4).
Sincerely,
[Keith-Signature]
Keith Bergelt
Chief Executive Officer
[OIN_logo_300dpi] <https://cfT5B04.na1.hubspotlinksstarter.com/Ctc/I2+113/cfT5B04/VVN7d58C75qbW2rDHF57vsP7zVhPn1w4_cKf1N65wGVh3lSbNV1-WJV7CgYtSW13QxpQ4_VcBzW5ZSG-z10b8X-N548Gxd1780GW7JD4665vNDZLW4W6kvH4gqxKkW4G2XwB21tCsbW4tQpqT69WDzWW6yYNTW6V0nPJW4G9sFN2Bt4xVVszf4b4CW_fhN1wd8hLVQMjPN6GyYSdrZZ9TW7hYknF7txR_CV4h8DS5QXNn4W3Vq3v-29N5KMW7sbMGL3Ps7M-W95vfG63bNJG1N760kJZD3_ffW2pbWT94hFjBwW337cQd4sP-LkW3XJVvL3PGLtdW54v9c16q41Yn38kp1>
Open Invention Network, 4819 Emperor Blvd., Suite 400, Durham, NC 27703, USA, +1 (919) 313-4902
Unsubscribe<https://hs-2181469.s.hubspotstarter.net/email-unsubscribe/email?product=emailStarter&checkSubscriptions=all&d=VnchdX5m56KTVKg8Bx3JFwWpW3R5c3D3_R592N1JxwY5WJtm6N1fk4d_jS9VsW8wmcll7XBlM0W75X_7H6zFP5TW1WPHjB5t57MyMGKd_P20N6HVGCW5S24by21VmqcCR5YxlTl4-BSH1&v=2&email=dave.taht%40gmail.com&utm_source=hs_email&utm_medium=email&utm_content=260354620&_hsenc=p2ANqtz-985rfD7hQmyXnFP9Y5wXAcZtXuGAc29_HtkaL8Dz7gObekn7pPiCruAtRXa8l1LsLT3bpaDXmCDeVSZ-t2acYf7h_Vuw&_hsmi=260354620> Manage preferences<https://hs-2181469.s.hubspotstarter.net/email-unsubscribe/email?product=emailStarter&d=VnchdX5m56KTVKg8Bx3JFwWpW3R5c3D3_R592N1JxwY5WJtm6N1fk4d_jS9VsW8wmcll7XBlM0W75X_7H6zFP5TW1WPHjB5t57MyMGKd_P20N6HVGCW5S24by21VmqcCR5YxlTl4-BSH1&v=2&email=dave.taht%40gmail.com&utm_source=hs_email&utm_medium=email&utm_content=260354620&_hsenc=p2ANqtz-985rfD7hQmyXnFP9Y5wXAcZtXuGAc29_HtkaL8Dz7gObekn7pPiCruAtRXa8l1LsLT3bpaDXmCDeVSZ-t2acYf7h_Vuw&_hsmi=260354620>
--
Podcast: https://www.linkedin.com/feed/update/urn:li:activity:7058793910227111937/
Dave Täht CSO, LibreQos
_______________________________________________
Bloat mailing list
Bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net<mailto:Bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net>
https://lists.bufferbloat.net/listinfo/bloat
--
David Collier-Brown, | Always do right. This will gratify
System Programmer and Author | some people and astonish the rest
dave.collier-brown@indexexchange.com<mailto:dave.collier-brown@indexexchange.com> | -- Mark Twain
CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE AND DISCLAIMER : This telecommunication, including any and all attachments, contains confidential information intended only for the person(s) to whom it is addressed. Any dissemination, distribution, copying or disclosure is strictly prohibited and is not a waiver of confidentiality. If you have received this telecommunication in error, please notify the sender immediately by return electronic mail and delete the message from your inbox and deleted items folders. This telecommunication does not constitute an express or implied agreement to conduct transactions by electronic means, nor does it constitute a contract offer, a contract amendment or an acceptance of a contract offer. Contract terms contained in this telecommunication are subject to legal review and the completion of formal documentation and are not binding until same is confirmed in writing and has been signed by an authorized signatory.
[-- Attachment #2: Type: text/html, Size: 25501 bytes --]
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 3+ messages in thread
* Re: [Bloat] Fwd: Open Source Needs You to Act - Help Fight Proposed Patent Rules
2023-05-31 13:14 ` Dave Collier-Brown
@ 2023-06-01 1:59 ` Dave Taht
0 siblings, 0 replies; 3+ messages in thread
From: Dave Taht @ 2023-06-01 1:59 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: Dave Collier-Brown; +Cc: bloat
[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 10016 bytes --]
If it were not for OIN fq codel or cake could have been sued out of
existence. And so much more in Linux. I slept a lot better knowing that
they were at the communities' backs.
I am in general into co signing a document if one exists, and not into
originating one.
On Wed, May 31, 2023, 7:14 AM Dave Collier-Brown via Bloat <
bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net> wrote:
> Does the community wish to make a submission to the commission, and if so,
> to which aspects of the issue?
>
> --dave
> On 5/31/23 09:07, Dave Taht via Bloat wrote:
>
> just when I thought it was safe to stop worrying about patents
>
> ---------- Forwarded message ---------
> From: Open Invention Network <emeintzer@openinventionnetwork.com>
> Date: Wed, May 31, 2023 at 7:03 AM
> Subject: Open Source Needs You to Act - Help Fight Proposed Patent Rules
> To: <dave.taht@gmail.com>
>
>
> Proposed USPTO proposed rules will make it harder to defend OSS against
> bad patents in the hands of PAEs. Fight back by June 20th.
> [image: OIN-NoBkgrd-1]
> [image: together-difference-2]
> <https://cfT5B04.na1.hubspotlinksstarter.com/Ctc/I2+113/cfT5B04/VVN7d58C75qbW2rDHF57vsP7zVhPn1w4_cKf1N65wGVh3lSbNV1-WJV7CgPpZW8_WQmN2dk-3JW86QrVj5FcwgjVm4MSZ2LD5QlN616MK51BSg5W58KQkv3FFX59W6H8PwP73X90MW60PR_N1r9mjgW84GMXw8bXK6HW6vx-Hc3gjL9tW3nSvPG5Hn1hRW5BLSzn583kWtW737M2W5L3GFzW94HJXp6fkZFsW3CzgPT1N94n9W4S0gK781F-R2W8qQVJD6WZ46lW5fmx258zF-NbW2jVmV331_nQ7W3G_8r21Gt7DLVjWY3c4kk2mTW19vcHw2d34LPN8NVYLSF8RQ03ckF1>
>
> Hi Dave!
>
>
>
> * Open Source Needs You to Act - *
>
> Help Fight Proposed Patent Rules
>
>
>
> *ISSUE*
>
> The U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) has issued a set of proposed
> rules
> <https://cfT5B04.na1.hubspotlinksstarter.com/Ctc/I2+113/cfT5B04/VVN7d58C75qbW2rDHF57vsP7zVhPn1w4_cKf1N65wGVh5knJZV3Zsc37CgPXMW62WJCb6ydvJtW3jylL55llyjhVY3PjB21W9RZW4TkVpR7cz_z2W6Cnnfs7L7gHCW8_wFkP6Jn49kW4D5fNX1GqM15W61CS3C4XsBs6W38tJ7y6k40_-W3Sm14N5fPkJ5W8bxpSK4MlZFGW6rHq8-205vQQW65D3482jyDzMW6cMzp54x-CBVW1qWdTn2PXjvNW5sw4gp5pZnccW5KmNs02C2lH7W3S-WSq7L8C07W8d4xPD2jGQb4W46dlDj79VD-hW4Q-z6J3FtykWW6YV2Mb3xCcpnW5DzW6W7JCXmsW4GSFl64nnHgnW50jd942hSWs8N9dDsvbHP8Q8W8tk8TX2ny-t_W2pcZy12DJTrVW1yt3-H1LkrdCW88P9zg3VCS7dW5JCNpz3kPWZDW47KwLd8LRdt1W13zK_x67VvP4W3MQGrC8F_Y_bN4rBYLJ27rHlW3mzxST2-8rR8W84S6Tv9cCmqyW6QDLqD9dPTps36yJ1>,
> nearly all of which will make it harder to challenge poor-quality patents.
> If implemented, these rules will make it harder to defend open source
> software (OSS) against bad patents in the hands of patent trolls.
>
>
>
> *BACKGROUND & IMPACT*
>
> OIN & other open source supporters — IBM, Microsoft & The Linux Foundation
> — funded Unified Patents’ Open Source Zone in 2019. Since then, this
> program has challenged dozens of poor-quality, open-source related patents
> with excellent success. The newly-proposed USPTO rules will negatively
> affect the Open Source Zone’s ability to challenge patents, even though
> many of the rules are apparently outside of the USPTO's authority
> <https://cfT5B04.na1.hubspotlinksstarter.com/Ctc/I2+113/cfT5B04/VVN7d58C75qbW2rDHF57vsP7zVhPn1w4_cKf1N65wGTp5knJ3V3Zsc37CgTbLW4rwkT95P5114W7Fk50R6sXBj0W43dQ8V6fR3X6W9cwNjD1Wmp6mW1LnVhP2X7JXNN8p1y4N6w2CwN6sknN32WBRLW88fzK96xpBVKW1tZZ5f8Tkt2LW5jJKdj1VR3D9W353xnN95LnvvW6lzGc-1ybtrYW5MkNsT14svwJW7H5xmK5hLZ9FW8NHK4_7DW5_GW6mXX9964pCX8W7_BSkB6fyqGpW4jHLnB8rWT27VRp2wM27WmlxW2NwQ6Q99-D5vW2qBpg43YS3wLW2g-rZv39gCKfN889GZB_1s89W8bN0nN7Hp9d7Vh3S_18DGslLW8qwXhX6fXRhlW2QBJxq8zYFF7W80tQgH4B3PPcN3hJFWyFkTMtW1053Lp6dpfWFW6F_bHd15cs9CW1P-J256s9m433p1T1>
> and plainly inconsistent with the intentions of the legislators that passed
> the America Invents Act. They may also prevent organizations like OIN and
> others from seeking patent reviews.
>
>
>
> If these rules are enacted, patents that slipped through the system and
> should have never been issued in the first place will:
>
> - Be increasingly litigated against developers and users of OSS,
> including businesses that rely on open source
>
> - Raise the already high cost of patent litigation and cost
> hundreds-of-millions of dollars, according to an economic impact study
> <https://cfT5B04.na1.hubspotlinksstarter.com/Ctc/I2+113/cfT5B04/VVN7d58C75qbW2rDHF57vsP7zVhPn1w4_cKf1N65wGVB3lSc3V1-WJV7CgJ6kVDLjdm15bnPcVYMFWX7qNKF6W6g4SFk59pdMNW70Zb1c6bxxh8W7BcZrr2KtBLTW8BNQQ51XcXVCW91ycZr7S5wTlW3_xGQp9hM1TWW6D0ym31z8Yd0N54Smc1p-NgZW3_08zt7n1CRpW6KFD_T24CHQHW5cMx6j75td3GW47z6t527tkV3VXMltY5697NCN1F2tSgJggr2W6yxyrR3tNtYbW9fwjh61KjNK3W5RwxNk3jm_FzW6CpSYD8wvl8xN6yPLZY4xqjYW7YcZSN3z62S2W5R1GQM5Y4_lkW8JSnlP8XzXq837d31>
>
> - Impact all open source organizations worldwide that have a
> developer, supplier or customer in the United States
>
> - Make business more difficult in the United States, and slow
> innovation globally
>
> As it is critical to OSS that we help stop this proposal, The Linux
> Foundation is hosting a free webinar entitled "Stopping Patent Trolls: Why
> Open Source Urgently Needs Your Help, Now!", on June 7, 2023 10:30 AM PDT
> (GMT - 7). To join the webinar and learn more, please register here
> <https://cfT5B04.na1.hubspotlinksstarter.com/Ctc/I2+113/cfT5B04/VVN7d58C75qbW2rDHF57vsP7zVhPn1w4_cKf1N65wGWt3lScZV1-WJV7CgXZzVxj2JC2q8JbDW3cCdYs7mYrzhW2Djs5k387GVXVTnr__5P9xGgW5Rlt2Z7x7GmqW9csYrP2VGPhCW1TtDfY1LqWM6W1W3_Pf8XbDlHW2Tz7FR7TFpPFW58f67_2pkl7nW3D6s0M8cwVh6W5rcNrl4fwkvJW5qFY401jZJyrV7s-WC8MvwsxW2BTjwX1ldTNTW2pgkRq9hQZ7lW5CtlLG2HBx7KVGxZj72fSp-2W6BsPlG77G_f3W7-qV271mzb4kW2XGKwh7jPt05W44xHmp5R83BZW5dr0pB7X1xynW6yWX_l7lyQj0W5p8XRV4h-Tl-W13-R0P1qyWK-W8-C-JK3xXDsbW3mcwQQ6yh2xYW4-Wcyp6cJ9K2W4tpysY7wm7qk3jP-1>
> .
>
>
>
> *ACTION*
>
> Please take a few minutes to share your thoughts, however brief, by selecting
> the green box
> <https://cfT5B04.na1.hubspotlinksstarter.com/Ctc/I2+113/cfT5B04/VVN7d58C75qbW2rDHF57vsP7zVhPn1w4_cKf1N65wGVh5knJZV3Zsc37CgG9vW5-JJs04KKwfNW6yszb21GG8SzW1shmvT3T3RnYW6TFhZ77cLqJLW3k4bJs8sJpFtW3nCQjm3xfS9-W8KKcG08xXlHvW2sNgsf3-zkPCW77GGLp6Sq1zbW3W9h_X1TYKVFW6SlWgl5Qt4nRW50xq111zkDpPW87bqMK263J1PW7hQf4j19XSMBV6tTWP1LnbrDW3rZt3x6Pcq_HW2DvWhH4Q6-42W6THFM52LbWhNN8vXc8XYBfH2W300jMZ7Lyh7-W3CNw2Q177NNDW80dh_T3Zwq6dW3zmsgN1TtSf1N6vZq82hZ0lfW4WWf0B20gfffW3lGgTz7QKqR4W3K5gxY7LSd0GW64T9T22TL7P3VKrb0628yz_rW12C8cG3G-Y2rVqbmkT63BwGYW1tNvVP492yJqW8dDZ6K5__dg9W27Lhzv5VK2Y5W1QM76h8WrJxkN5jdzKNbXVR0MHjL8Bn1Dh1W8XzfZY3kyh1m3h151>
> titled “Submit a formal comment.” If you want to submit more detailed
> comments, or have any questions or concerns about what is at stake, please contact
> Jonathan Stroud <jonathan@unifiedpatents.com> at Unified Patents.
>
>
>
> *DEADLINE*
>
> *Your comments must be received by June 20, 2023* *11:59 PM EDT (GMT -
> 4).*
> Sincerely,
> [image: Keith-Signature]
> Keith Bergelt *Chief Executive Officer*
> [image: OIN_logo_300dpi]
> <https://cfT5B04.na1.hubspotlinksstarter.com/Ctc/I2+113/cfT5B04/VVN7d58C75qbW2rDHF57vsP7zVhPn1w4_cKf1N65wGVh3lSbNV1-WJV7CgYtSW13QxpQ4_VcBzW5ZSG-z10b8X-N548Gxd1780GW7JD4665vNDZLW4W6kvH4gqxKkW4G2XwB21tCsbW4tQpqT69WDzWW6yYNTW6V0nPJW4G9sFN2Bt4xVVszf4b4CW_fhN1wd8hLVQMjPN6GyYSdrZZ9TW7hYknF7txR_CV4h8DS5QXNn4W3Vq3v-29N5KMW7sbMGL3Ps7M-W95vfG63bNJG1N760kJZD3_ffW2pbWT94hFjBwW337cQd4sP-LkW3XJVvL3PGLtdW54v9c16q41Yn38kp1>
>
>
>
>
> Open Invention Network, 4819 Emperor Blvd., Suite 400, Durham, NC 27703,
> USA, +1 (919) 313-4902
>
> Unsubscribe
> <https://hs-2181469.s.hubspotstarter.net/email-unsubscribe/email?product=emailStarter&checkSubscriptions=all&d=VnchdX5m56KTVKg8Bx3JFwWpW3R5c3D3_R592N1JxwY5WJtm6N1fk4d_jS9VsW8wmcll7XBlM0W75X_7H6zFP5TW1WPHjB5t57MyMGKd_P20N6HVGCW5S24by21VmqcCR5YxlTl4-BSH1&v=2&email=dave.taht%40gmail.com&utm_source=hs_email&utm_medium=email&utm_content=260354620&_hsenc=p2ANqtz-985rfD7hQmyXnFP9Y5wXAcZtXuGAc29_HtkaL8Dz7gObekn7pPiCruAtRXa8l1LsLT3bpaDXmCDeVSZ-t2acYf7h_Vuw&_hsmi=260354620> Manage
> preferences
> <https://hs-2181469.s.hubspotstarter.net/email-unsubscribe/email?product=emailStarter&d=VnchdX5m56KTVKg8Bx3JFwWpW3R5c3D3_R592N1JxwY5WJtm6N1fk4d_jS9VsW8wmcll7XBlM0W75X_7H6zFP5TW1WPHjB5t57MyMGKd_P20N6HVGCW5S24by21VmqcCR5YxlTl4-BSH1&v=2&email=dave.taht%40gmail.com&utm_source=hs_email&utm_medium=email&utm_content=260354620&_hsenc=p2ANqtz-985rfD7hQmyXnFP9Y5wXAcZtXuGAc29_HtkaL8Dz7gObekn7pPiCruAtRXa8l1LsLT3bpaDXmCDeVSZ-t2acYf7h_Vuw&_hsmi=260354620>
>
>
> --
> Podcast:
> https://www.linkedin.com/feed/update/urn:li:activity:7058793910227111937/
> Dave Täht CSO, LibreQos
>
> _______________________________________________
> Bloat mailing listBloat@lists.bufferbloat.nethttps://lists.bufferbloat.net/listinfo/bloat
>
> --
> David Collier-Brown, | Always do right. This will gratify
> System Programmer and Author | some people and astonish the restdave.collier-brown@indexexchange.com | -- Mark Twain
>
>
> *CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE AND DISCLAIMER** : This telecommunication,
> including any and all attachments, contains confidential information
> intended only for the person(s) to whom it is addressed. Any dissemination,
> distribution, copying or disclosure is strictly prohibited and is not a
> waiver of confidentiality. If you have received this telecommunication in
> error, please notify the sender immediately by return electronic mail and
> delete the message from your inbox and deleted items folders. This
> telecommunication does not constitute an express or implied agreement to
> conduct transactions by electronic means, nor does it constitute a contract
> offer, a contract amendment or an acceptance of a contract offer. Contract
> terms contained in this telecommunication are subject to legal review and
> the completion of formal documentation and are not binding until same is
> confirmed in writing and has been signed by an authorized signatory.*
> _______________________________________________
> Bloat mailing list
> Bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net
> https://lists.bufferbloat.net/listinfo/bloat
>
[-- Attachment #2: Type: text/html, Size: 25219 bytes --]
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 3+ messages in thread
end of thread, other threads:[~2023-06-01 3:45 UTC | newest]
Thread overview: 3+ messages (download: mbox.gz / follow: Atom feed)
-- links below jump to the message on this page --
[not found] <1685538041767.34e911eb-3b5c-4a42-b5b0-89ccfd0f8008@bf01.hubspotstarter.net>
2023-05-31 13:07 ` [Bloat] Fwd: Open Source Needs You to Act - Help Fight Proposed Patent Rules Dave Taht
2023-05-31 13:14 ` Dave Collier-Brown
2023-06-01 1:59 ` Dave Taht
This is a public inbox, see mirroring instructions
for how to clone and mirror all data and code used for this inbox