From mboxrd@z Thu Jan 1 00:00:00 1970 Authentication-Results: mail.toke.dk; spf=pass smtp.mailfrom=; dkim=pass header.d=gmx.de header.i=moeller0@gmx.de; arc=none (Message is not ARC signed); dmarc=pass (Used From Domain Record) header.from=gmx.de policy.dmarc=quarantine Received: from mout.gmx.net (mout.gmx.net [212.227.17.20]) by mail.toke.dk (Postfix) with ESMTPS id 769E970E592 for ; Tue, 30 Sep 2025 11:01:10 +0200 (CEST) DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=gmx.de; s=s31663417; t=1759222869; x=1759827669; i=moeller0@gmx.de; bh=NXK8+l5H0LdnLUo0p6EXnH7+4M0oz6nhOmagzpWyKYY=; h=X-UI-Sender-Class:Content-Type:Mime-Version:Subject:From: In-Reply-To:Date:Cc:Content-Transfer-Encoding:Message-Id: References:To:cc:content-transfer-encoding:content-type:date:from: message-id:mime-version:reply-to:subject:to; b=tNZPJTL7RJUYjFqTaxuhniFEoWjK48HwrUSyyG5YIr22Df+/KnCVhxkuyGSAA/se cISdF6aOPS1pY/n3Qd1gm63+B5cD2Qo6kddXIppDxmjkKvhwY8PvWuR++5ZLQbi/R HSomk5tLB2paqHQuUjbeqTdw8fH5s/1qPmz2uMxbgO/TgUFjDcRpTdroXmJCbHoE8 hisU5t8D2wJCcIRk65h1yD3dn9PQapW0iUHsEeLgyCutLLP2hEiBIV8r6h44Op9s/ rQ5SCFAernKxNVkQ8XkY0UoOsTlORWXAMaondpcnzEn46xYxAyOMtANid22sEwNx6 VCylcnsDUQP9DmDEEw== X-UI-Sender-Class: 724b4f7f-cbec-4199-ad4e-598c01a50d3a Received: from smtpclient.apple ([134.76.241.253]) by mail.gmx.net (mrgmx105 [212.227.17.168]) with ESMTPSA (Nemesis) id 1M26r3-1v12KK2841-0032L0; Tue, 30 Sep 2025 11:01:09 +0200 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii Mime-Version: 1.0 (Mac OS X Mail 16.0 \(3826.700.81\)) From: Sebastian Moeller In-Reply-To: Date: Tue, 30 Sep 2025 11:00:58 +0200 Cc: dave seddon , David Lang , m@jaap.pro, "cake@lists.bufferbloat.net" , Frantisek Borsik Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable Message-Id: <68948D96-1D53-47DE-BE1C-DADB70FC6D7A@gmx.de> References: <2064666241.42029.1759061544846@app.mailbox.org> <962896BA-6EE5-4815-B6F9-AC50B7252642@gmail.com> To: Jonathan Morton X-Mailer: Apple Mail (2.3826.700.81) X-Provags-ID: V03:K1:j5cum7EgZY5ITaAizCB80oFF7D40JaK8wUBuGkGpNZqcZgq7OBJ ifvRWOxV1lzU9S2+AhhMUFk9Eie8zYMicWSVuX5iZIYmGg9ROV/RFVb+02kgM5Vns7zm+4R CzEvHkWqYviyf9AjT4dYvvcYiE1I3TeJpcGUou7GKvE49puon+F9dYwHcrS5GtWJ6ATiY5q dPmTpFI33Zu9abRpBgcPA== X-Spam-Flag: NO UI-OutboundReport: notjunk:1;M01:P0:SOtx79NHKVk=;r+q6XRjU6JZXA/0Xw1wqT85dEW0 nPjnPpJ/awzwCvlHAbe/3bQYlVlRJf6T3fFxLsN2yPZdVUqpArLn8Bu0OMn2EgUC3FBRDJCzN J4sZKmgbUoodO/Wk92sFEuMEo95LaXYHh+jLgYFhx9CL/NehFDclVe+TMVBmNbB3oYB3VFMd3 3ucH4TKB/VFTilMS9ad9zq9XjzInzLfiMCtzmpfv2U+cLLyDlyENP51A+xCU/ZqubrHlPk8DV bwuCciD8l/nQ5Ia4sn/DuvKc9LWAmOHMjZHhHLeHkJWw/ys+ZYov8jG3dhKXqDseaAs9LiQJF HA+LgxgOsOS9FL1JzqVid6xU4OSF6/itMkOhdgCYUhikAT2vFPUmiV1BzPRhCSBPDPKDG/Iwe dWJXAB9+IJh7qxkHlOTugNExGRsI20yGum4RK6MhKatcQnQvgHSF3b05jk8OCEuUK3HhxSI+C WkzGBnUwpKktZ9xLM4+lxZ7umWx3p69gQYhjHjjqF1vLSo53lr9Mk84voSzPPcKexhZo50J7Q VPUljBLv9dX7xWvq0I0e2KrRm42Ua5W8EOcDonFaGfRRASvrWkW9ejeoxOOlDfq/TRvqKGCqw JAXBx8zWRRyNcMRIjjZ9snIFoce/79Vn6SmqoJnr4bJLczjYbzpwDqGnNqSTnC5n6EjjY/Y4I rRTg1eqFEVyx9d4q0lG9dt/ImBHDofKjrC2R4nddt/p5AjMAl/DsBMl1fvJgkBiYx+aqHQY+p sz2c1p1wtvgoDn8pnBMhNdijj44CodFIdH1siv6ZWw7E6FBOoO6GJlFF4Y1W+v/3nvJvA1L7y qxIqhwBMH1sbECGNH3fe9UcnwO6NSrajSt8EzgNtIN9nkbfQtXHKo8wvHlyqVFb/twupJvh46 1xtlQYAFxVytvCpPYtVCS9oYut7uqKRNZcx/AVL68Iby5NPfHNUi6kJm9ue5CQcdpctnIpTER IkAh/V8sJsKBbzHOyn+upCwHNF58xNRpUpDhRg4s3zD4Q0RqxVHh0b4GDoD61btshnsWZX3pU 4cpa1IPnO0KAFu1xqZqEkxr/HRA63l0i9Hks9dp1E4pKU6fpQAKOh2wVdILCNd7eSK6DGKiDD Cu0hzLDXMXR43vvuC1BJs4jKox4Ucesrhu/4OhtzrVXZ1JjgoJdenQEr4fmF+Mcf8aqsG1TrO 1sKuNOc5ctgTkD1JU7bifyXN+/8a/IbPELmr48L3/OJ9GNtTO+psBq5TdT3GDm38wkLI0o3C/ HB+ni8v5CK1h7OrQCjyUTKPh5uZqe4tujcRa2WPPw4IBUOSel+pgIfbSN4/vstcofXyaCyGh9 ho1+Zo5O27VG3cX1TdtTzleqB9efeRinLHg0twodO6lOTWcVWcx/IvHTzwPTe3NG4JJkRvdJ4 9MZVvTAvQ1BJPn2VTrhcd3WacQamTTLjcLPOQENw0t3myWqMXKJjyJLB2oyITm8VVJlEeoJBO G1G4nCFQpvdOEo14780RW0fX73GTOCxstE/qNShWrUfrkIUvHEZetuW9stODO5S6bPELe/6/2 HYfJOpqsMT2PpRU3F2K0hdYhee4e64qvL4SQKzr941WQmlgWMCK121ycO4DFzNlrF5i8bCJ1s HeVW90bnh5NudVBhE0bYBD6NyOLLq3hnXZmWBoDS3Y4E2WyeqTQrZLwfoT1icuwy6v466VW5e L0NjktHSwnGye0U7FaN9SI+pcOSZjFYJ7esAjEGUiGhzxK74mNlh3B+/T3gE1AD0Mr6zRp73h Uk9nJKxNATlENHgEUoHYUtyiFAwUlsH9FWQMhwJDSwBpo0ognnJ1M3e/+HM6o3Nsy/tyvQe4n KP3RFVWKrJhJqP2tsPNa4oXRWJgOlvI6s0oSZYSHklZqcBO6P+xs1u2Jf7Qik2ClmBvEM7XO/ FkPmaEN88JGIiGx7v0P8MgzSYH4zqnWbS7EIisVMyzYQnWE5RFl9Bx5zX4jAfYc5fKgCCAF0l 6bqVBo1mZXgs7nug68tjbg6PnNc31FkqtVXkjbEtmR4NTVoam+Ih+k6aLSK+EKEBvq4+7dIbL d39eKdMK6DUll2TnEsd/2fEABRVdrSWujd7xqkHzK0LwkD7HOvh60yVlh/mYMAR6X9p9Y/NV+ hopVeI5NpOyTEJkmZCMQlshhfhOBnYNh1h/n4AUxd/QHVDi8zObJm6dU0XYCb1UV0PXnAdKiB +utDWCO+bTXV08zyBw29Q198iey8FfinhDhjYGIBK3OQMnJmyNo2uUuksyNef7rg+HK+ZXbgm pL4HhahgRP8pRh26HbkBcanGCGXHCSpUDiXxbd++wWnVwomBmgNbzwlqiEgCU1j5ZT3sXqD1u ELXlh9TGTLQoW0PPR8t+CVQWPmnJbASPrFC4prMAhjxA2Fw9mY+U8qsRTfh7uDlBbSLshfe7U fY00r8LdJaCqnKyecaSV9g6yaSToH4W+m+BOXiQPSaTipTbWcl2DIlHL+XUQ6tAgYLdXwXqiA EumatSSLVCdFWr0dl7VgLDMa8VaUUHvT+kz+3SPIKCP+Nvpq3WzOILiEueIqNYBcZj6z7fTq4 aZQvqfJtLf+EeJz7w3z+TCOSuy3Xv0idgQNT26Fn1B+ayJOmR7ByqH+swYn+tDZYnb+TfRGCN Rwhx2u51uCSIM9/Ikj/huf+6QKU24OOUgDcsIC8kR20pK4iIEupDqljNoyEB8xWWC7fj47j2I uIfFaLOBw0U7xISMDVh2YswzknMzUqA0q0Kj8oxDWsQEe31jgBB+kIW/jMmwX0LGad9xydO0L uJzKxU3sc5jr9lWtp8YXEpCyLwRSgvp8HA0Eiu+mK4kjyapV4K8Y/Y/eRZuKzD7z7odcqhXI4 EV1x2PP6uc9pocPCJbqPzwyJSLMcqPlbRHljkqcBeMEG2zDcfftKYQRGm+d4XIMIbevlypNcx J2E/yYtNJkHEgF7+xhBBzDTQDAv7b+SwL4/ZuupNBVxLpclp17JIj+KXr19MGe3WsRt2z4NEI Lqu/ezVWNxNU84ebUf8bAA2YVlRJP1SUCm7pU2dHZCMYFyOyiOBOD70ZdfZ5/h7TB2RXoRi1n ILR6TinfNWVVDY6EhJgO2vQBICwjpKBSD5eCrT5jzmkInsvzk/ohhrsIyeXpvGktu+DaKAmDN lTRLb1BoD5GSxkZXpSa0IB9EvDfdeQMnw8FXP+wiayR035/gduh/PVCN4oQP5pK8Ph6ACNAmP MaZRfBVHzdRGJSDgXYS5aORB411IgIJNSSAJiHg45uy4KZKHLVtXzobW9CW1i1HnqBG+nYWty pC+fE0KorahsOOOISg89S4ZEhIC2vQf4IVSvbQcVj17rvC3ndkYYLtGuMTHonocLKCKoWqaXm lVvdnCYiNESDBim4z7bQm8Iu1BFdTN+UmaHnGexws3Q0XVvcRzjiNkWxVrhEWu048pq21B7F+ 4A8BC4gFZh04XguTk3NvA5MW1yk6l3SVgrCQI3qcDgLR5G3Z61CYvfpWP2ZEtzDuN52BcUcj6 JvLAphOptWA09BEPwrPjI2AggLIGAgEnB2ggjc4w2NSs1HDnZEee+kP+7i72l/5Bz5v4UqXc8 RhNuEJ1aaelLbI03B1/0Ky/Cwu5rwL1szdiWJqYxKkYjQJQXTfwEVPJeaYDFlmQYiyWX+yd3p Vu3cb9r6eT/vbUpPQiE+suVLrDfk19r7P75lJZegfIgow+aVakoopszcFIdxM+rqZ2ST2sKW7 KYDhdRCjARHWmL8oOxIJ2+Rdg4DZifqZW7noSAv2WUcMQ7m49klDLlKaZfuNbYBH8eBl26KAL ItuMeT+nmHhGV7DUC4nJbsuZsg7AzptP5pAQJ5BgSKS/A7LWMx08g6K4tLQRCU19M+sOCBUWd DAVutBUsdxZ1WyhPGvl7N13OfNGmtbYyShNssp4lCIfjDcyrd1JRgEKuzcMeIDO+bePuhAazj LIDNxoesZFDOt0aJAkCK3AY3go05OgcAYuX3fGYLHqo5nB6b1/i6Nh6zzl8hZP4OS4DDO9y3B L9paIeZN849n3O90xvr+ANVB8QVTnfclLnjP1mkcj4oJFVRG4fkBpmVv03ZyUNJ6VDY+vdD97 nHskXZNqzIQclZhmU8MVddebsYBdVbkEU0Naxa9alT1aR52YV4mBMet79JvpH8dWqMl+mCG78 S0sqaIfIXB98cVzaMmUwPf8ETpmZrQI9Gz4uxXQ34PM78hOVuy5LRTDvLYApGD/SULngHDrNK 9DNjZgdBdm6gWlpi2j/aBAZmrGb52Ya0S5GXz1u+jYxLiZdCZlfI17i9XWEFzjuBtpl1TO2vt YNzMWXegqiVRStw3jOsMg4oOUwBd7AIRRPoCTzhdIvazFPuvneatCLBLUjjrx/+ZP36Hey/zf yJU0dWlvaCzFBL0F2PiIQh8Alg3KKWnursRnNPRfCk9wUjZ5hpBRlTmdYCqQSCC00u5jkBS/O ZCJ+1RQ8JH+kpTEkkL1MtZW3hRnCFlMJPC3IGgIb/xg60mZUh6/Z1PviGNIhfRGUBdlleeJ29 Y6CdStCwrZqPauMRu9NknunNmkU3i9B1ai6asbw5C+e04+UEVOeSY1wObdDDyA2udClNSs5P7 Z6ZJ9QAiO4jnXzhjdJ98uykAgA5/hytHtjFrrrKumXqIeehBCNAH4bTzU6FHH6v8aMWhKcroi uZNy1Rw26JDyL65Xjv2pUzvsDri0FzqM5hz+aiRzmVE85OCSk6Q60/tgDkpdWqvfs5ZWCkErH 9xQm1FWcXVFefcvJ8nfm0O1Wfe6fJSdT2P/xz+NvX29c/eK/O3GsNE04vPyHt+gQptC81/qkf MRXydQz5cp83wM8H4N6Aovo7XKRC3O1mPeUH+OEYYCb8a8UL3mmyyx32ubPyHRp2eBNpbItyW 3nULo5Jj2WzJWnRkCnew8APNPnVUPpnGA0lUo/g+9Z1rdVshxuat9UwekUZhRZ7Krv2tF+8ZV uKVWDmdX6RggrlbloEkmUJwtL+hlOi3MjtZ2qhTPOs3Ug6uoFdTjigXEJ5kh/iyBueyVhp3zt 4r0za1GRwwOP2nkzaXwl3ztCab5MhgqTNO+L164C6ghkpY4+BbyR+vFMZ2B4LOtk3vqvmv+gS O+mP6E66Q+2wg0u3Xng5K2vzTk= Message-ID-Hash: CYZ6LHZXMFEQJ64MCVZ4QF3O3INHYSRG X-Message-ID-Hash: CYZ6LHZXMFEQJ64MCVZ4QF3O3INHYSRG X-MailFrom: moeller0@gmx.de X-Mailman-Rule-Misses: dmarc-mitigation; no-senders; approved; loop; banned-address; emergency; member-moderation; nonmember-moderation; administrivia; implicit-dest; max-recipients; max-size; news-moderation; no-subject; digests; suspicious-header X-Mailman-Version: 3.3.10 Precedence: list Subject: [Cake] Re: help request for cake on a large network List-Id: Cake - FQ_codel the next generation Archived-At: List-Archive: List-Help: List-Owner: List-Post: List-Subscribe: List-Unsubscribe: Hi Jonathan, > On 30. Sep 2025, at 10:59, Jonathan Morton = wrote: >=20 >> On 30 Sep, 2025, at 9:09 am, Sebastian Moeller = wrote: >>=20 >> I would really like to see some tc -s qdisc output from this network = under load, as that should be informative if any twaeks are necessary at = all. >=20 > I think the point is that this is a conference/event network that will = be set up transiently. By the time you get a realistic workload to = measure the behaviour of, you're in production. Indeed, this approach would do little for the up-coming SCALE N, but it = should be instructive for SCALA N+1. Regards Sebastian >=20 > - Jonathan Morton