Dave had asked about results from .32-12 on DSL, and in particular how pie was fairing on dsl. I finally was able to setup a clean test env yesterday, and ran a bunch of tests.
Results:
Takeaways:
- I'm still dropping a lot of "small-flow" packets when heavily loaded, I'm not sure why. Free.fr's freebox doesn't do this, it's definitely in cero.
- pie still sucks on dsl (or on my dsl). latency with rrul was up over 1sec (and continually growing over the course of the test)
I feel like _something_ is misconfigured, and that's why I'm dropping packets the way that I am. I really would like to solve that. Free.fr's sfq implementation behaves quite nicely, and by comparison, doesn't drop UDP packets under load.
This was all ipv4-only (I haven't asked the apartment owner to turn on ipv6 with Free.fr).
In about 2 months, I'll be back in the Bay Area. With either
sonic.net DSL (bonded channels for 30/2 service), or with Comcast. Comcast most likely. It would be nice to have 3-5Mb upload again.
Any other tests/questions, feel free to ask. I can perform tests in the morning and early afternoon when things are quiet around here.
-Aaron