* [Starlink] Re: The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering)
[not found] <179507172508.1293.11534238119359794018@gauss>
@ 2026-11-19 16:08 ` Colin_Higbie
2026-11-19 16:11 ` Colin_Higbie
0 siblings, 1 reply; 3+ messages in thread
From: Colin_Higbie @ 2026-11-19 16:08 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: starlink@lists.bufferbloat.net, Juliusz Chroboczek
Julius,
This is not an engineering problem (except to the extent that implementation may or may not require parsing the sources of the data), but an economic policy one. When adding a tax, that punishes and diminishes the activity (if not familiar with this law of economics, the underlying cause and effect driving it is: any tax is added to the price paid by consumers, and at a higher price, there will be a lower quantity demanded by customers). That either affects everyone, or through some financial redistribution, the wealthier French take on all of that cost and poorer French are insulated from it, but either way, when price goes up nationally, quantity demanded drops, regardless who pays for it.
Now, if the French government can limit the tax to only American companies (not sure how that's possible with VPNs without setting up something like China's Great Firewall, which gives the government total control and ability to monitor all traffic in and out of the country), and if French ISPs want to deal with adding that complexity to their billing so that customers pay more for watching Netflix than for browsing French websites, then, yes, you could technically make French people pay more for American services and thereby incent them toward French alternatives.
Also note that implementing this segregated model would add substantial cost, with the primary user-perceived effects being higher prices, more complicated billing, and loss of privacy. There would also be more tax revenue to the French government, which you could argue has a benefit to the French people (especially if they cut other taxes as a result), but that's not a direct benefit to the ISP customers paying for their Internet.
And if you don't segregate and just tax all traffic equally, which seems the more likely scenario given the technical challenges (but I'd yield to the many expert network engineers in this group for that part), then you're reducing access for everyone who uses the Internet to either send or receive data.
And back to the starting point: the effect of these taxes and increased prices is to reduce the quantity demanded, reducing overall revenue and profitability to suppliers. That in turn reduces the incentive to suppliers (ISPs) to invest in building out more infrastructure (the same problem Net Neutrality advocates ignore in the U.S.), which is the ONLY thing that can, over time, drive down costs of delivering Internet to end users (not the price paid, which could be offset with government subsidies, but the actual cost that somebody, whether the Internet users or the taxpayers, must pay). This means any such tax ultimately INCREASES the overall costs and REDUCES the quality of the service available over the long term (years to decades). It is possible that these effects are small, possibly even small enough to be considered de minimis, but directionally, that is absolutely what must happen, per the basic laws of economics.
The piece that most non-economists miss in reviewing how incentives affect supply, meaning pricing and availability, over the long term is the importance of growth and how incentives can affect it. Growth CREATES NEW SUPPLY, which ALWAYS results in effectively reduced cost and prices over time (due to economies of scale and because innovation only moves costs in one direction – down). Engineers tend to think of everything as a zero-sum game, which is typically fair in engineering problems. However, that is NEVER the case in economics in the long run (it is correct in the short run, where there is no time to innovate and improve, but presumably any tax policy should have a perspective longer than the current fiscal year). Given time, people and businesses innovate to cut costs and create new, better solutions to sell more because that enables them to earn more. That ALWAYS creates new wealth and capabilities that didn't exist before. Hence, NOT a zero-sum game. Devising those innovations and then implementing them takes time, so this is only a long-run effect, but in your policy considerations, please be careful not to neglect those benefits, and, conversely, the costs of reducing their efficacy through disincentivizing taxes.
Cheers,
Colin
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 3+ messages in thread* [Starlink] Re: The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering)
2026-11-19 16:08 ` [Starlink] Re: The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering) Colin_Higbie
@ 2026-11-19 16:11 ` Colin_Higbie
0 siblings, 0 replies; 3+ messages in thread
From: Colin_Higbie @ 2026-11-19 16:11 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: starlink@lists.bufferbloat.net, Juliusz Chroboczek
Juliusz, sincere apologies for misspelling your name. I saw that just as I hit send.
Julius,
This is not an engineering problem (except to the extent that implementation may or may not require parsing the sources of the data), but an economic policy one. When adding a tax, that punishes and diminishes the activity (if not familiar with this law of economics, the underlying cause and effect driving it is: any tax is added to the price paid by consumers, and at a higher price, there will be a lower quantity demanded by customers). That either affects everyone, or through some financial redistribution, the wealthier French take on all of that cost and poorer French are insulated from it, but either way, when price goes up nationally, quantity demanded drops, regardless who pays for it.
Now, if the French government can limit the tax to only American companies (not sure how that's possible with VPNs without setting up something like China's Great Firewall, which gives the government total control and ability to monitor all traffic in and out of the country), and if French ISPs want to deal with adding that complexity to their billing so that customers pay more for watching Netflix than for browsing French websites, then, yes, you could technically make French people pay more for American services and thereby incent them toward French alternatives.
Also note that implementing this segregated model would add substantial cost, with the primary user-perceived effects being higher prices, more complicated billing, and loss of privacy. There would also be more tax revenue to the French government, which you could argue has a benefit to the French people (especially if they cut other taxes as a result), but that's not a direct benefit to the ISP customers paying for their Internet.
And if you don't segregate and just tax all traffic equally, which seems the more likely scenario given the technical challenges (but I'd yield to the many expert network engineers in this group for that part), then you're reducing access for everyone who uses the Internet to either send or receive data.
And back to the starting point: the effect of these taxes and increased prices is to reduce the quantity demanded, reducing overall revenue and profitability to suppliers. That in turn reduces the incentive to suppliers (ISPs) to invest in building out more infrastructure (the same problem Net Neutrality advocates ignore in the U.S.), which is the ONLY thing that can, over time, drive down costs of delivering Internet to end users (not the price paid, which could be offset with government subsidies, but the actual cost that somebody, whether the Internet users or the taxpayers, must pay). This means any such tax ultimately INCREASES the overall costs and REDUCES the quality of the service available over the long term (years to decades). It is possible that these effects are small, possibly even small enough to be considered de minimis, but directionally, that is absolutely what must happen, per the basic laws of economics.
The piece that most non-economists miss in reviewing how incentives affect supply, meaning pricing and availability, over the long term is the importance of growth and how incentives can affect it. Growth CREATES NEW SUPPLY, which ALWAYS results in effectively reduced cost and prices over time (due to economies of scale and because innovation only moves costs in one direction – down). Engineers tend to think of everything as a zero-sum game, which is typically fair in engineering problems. However, that is NEVER the case in economics in the long run (it is correct in the short run, where there is no time to innovate and improve, but presumably any tax policy should have a perspective longer than the current fiscal year). Given time, people and businesses innovate to cut costs and create new, better solutions to sell more because that enables them to earn more. That ALWAYS creates new wealth and capabilities that didn't exist before. Hence, NOT a zero-sum game. Devising those innovations and then implementing them takes time, so this is only a long-run effect, but in your policy considerations, please be careful not to neglect those benefits, and, conversely, the costs of reducing their efficacy through disincentivizing taxes.
Cheers,
Colin
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 3+ messages in thread
* [Starlink] The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering)
@ 2026-10-31 12:56 Frantisek Borsik
2026-10-31 18:05 ` [Starlink] " Daniel AJ Sokolov
0 siblings, 1 reply; 3+ messages in thread
From: Frantisek Borsik @ 2026-10-31 12:56 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: Network Neutrality is back! Let´s make the technical aspects heard this time!,
Dave Taht via Starlink, bloat, Cake List, libreqos,
Jeremy Austin via Rpm
Crossposting, because this garbage idea might "inspire" more countries and
have a horrible impact also on bufferbloat everywhere.
*Original post by Dr. Peering:*
*"The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country
by taxing Gigabits. Here’s Octave Klaba's excellent analysis [in French,
link below] showing just how insane the finance bill actually is. The IXP
taxation amount is, just for starters, ridiculous!"*
https://x.com/drpeering/status/2116468659392807
<https://x.com/drpeering/status/2116468659392807381?a=E-elnbppn-MAi-LNIrU&s=46>
*Octave's post:*
https://fr.linkedin.com/posts/octave-klaba-3a0b3632_jai-lu-lamendement-i-1358-au-plf-2027-activity-7522219045576888320-uqkw
*Copy+paste:*
J'ai lu l'amendement I-1358 au PLF 2027, adopté ce vendredi à l'Assemblée :
une taxe de 0,055 € par Go envoyé vers les abonnés des FAI français. Le
chiffre est abstrait, alors comparons-le. Corrigez-moi si vous voyez des
erreurs.
Deux comparaisons et un cas concret :
1. Le transit et le peering. Un port 100 Gbps coûte environ 6 300 € par
mois chez un fournisseur de transit mondial. En interconnexion directe avec
un FAI européen, compter 3 à 5 fois plus, soit 20 à 30 k€ par mois. Sur ce
port (a), la taxe atteint 1,02 M€ par mois, soit environ 3400 % à 16300 %
du prix d'une interconnexion vers les FAI français. On change donc
profondément le modèle économique de la bande passante en France.
2. Les hyperscalers sont critiqués pour le prix de leur trafic sortant, qui
va d'environ 0,08€ à 0,045€ par Go selon le volume. La taxe, 0,055 € par
Go, représente 68 % à 123 % de ce prix. On parle donc de doubler, pour le
trafic vers la France, un prix déjà jugé trop élevé !
3. Le cas d'OVHcloud. Nous envoyons de l'ordre de 500 Gbps au 95e
percentile vers les FAI français, soit environ 324 Gbps en moyenne. Sur un
an, la taxe brute atteindrait 70 M€. Le texte la plafonne à 15 % du CA
réalisé en France ou à 2 % du CA mondial, soit entre environ 23 et 70 M€
par an que nous devrions collecter pour l'État, et donc répercuter sur nos
clients.
Conclusions :
1. Une taxe porte en général sur une petite fraction de son assiette.
Celle-ci vaut plus de 3000 % du coût du transit, et environ 100 % du prix
public des hyperscalers. Rappelez-vous la loi SREN, votée pour supprimer
les frais de transfert qui empêchaient les clients de quitter un
fournisseur cloud. Ici, on parle de doubler le prix du trafic sortant vers
les internautes français, un prix déjà très problématique.
2. Le garde-fou, un plafond calculé sur le chiffre d'affaires, est
incohérent. Ce chiffre d'affaires couvre des serveurs, du stockage, des
datacenters et des équipes sans rapport avec la bande passante. C'est comme
créer une taxe calculée sur la consommation électrique des usines
automobiles en France, plafonnée à 15 % du chiffre d'affaires des
constructeurs. Quel rapport entre les deux ?
3. Une taxe nationale de ce type frappe à coup sûr les entreprises établies
en France, alors que leurs concurrents mondiaux sans présence en France
livrent le même trafic aux mêmes FAI français sans payer cette taxe en
pratique. Cela crée une distorsion de concurrence au détriment des acteurs
nationaux et déclasse les entreprises qui embauchent en France. Une taxe
qui produit l'effet inverse serait une meilleure approche.
(a) Facturé au 95e percentile, ce port n'est pas plein en permanence : avec
un profil journalier type (22 % vers 4 h, 90 % vers 21 h), il transporte en
moyenne 57 % de sa capacité, soit 18,6 millions de Go par mois.
All the best,
Frank
Frantisek (Frank) Borsik
In loving memory of Dave Täht: 1965-2025
https://libreqos.io/2025/04/01/in-loving-memory-of-dave/
https://www.linkedin.com/in/frantisekborsik
Signal, Telegram, WhatsApp: +421919416714 <+421%20919%20416%20714>
iMessage, mobile: +420775230885 <775%20230%20885>
Skype: casioa5302ca
frantisek.borsik@gmail.com
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 3+ messages in thread
* [Starlink] Re: The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering)
2026-10-31 12:56 [Starlink] " Frantisek Borsik
@ 2026-10-31 18:05 ` Daniel AJ Sokolov
0 siblings, 0 replies; 3+ messages in thread
From: Daniel AJ Sokolov @ 2026-10-31 18:05 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: Frantisek Borsik via Starlink
It is not a final decision.
I understand it was a first reading with just 35 members of Parliament present, of whom 11 voted Oui and 10 voted Non.
BR
Daniel
On October 31, 2026 5:56:18 a.m. MST, Frantisek Borsik via Starlink <starlink@lists.bufferbloat.net> wrote:
>Crossposting, because this garbage idea might "inspire" more countries and
>have a horrible impact also on bufferbloat everywhere.
>
>*Original post by Dr. Peering:*
>
>*"The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country
>by taxing Gigabits. Here’s Octave Klaba's excellent analysis [in French,
>link below] showing just how insane the finance bill actually is. The IXP
>taxation amount is, just for starters, ridiculous!"*
>
>https://x.com/drpeering/status/2116468659392807
><https://x.com/drpeering/status/2116468659392807381?a=E-elnbppn-MAi-LNIrU&s=46>
>
>*Octave's post:*
>
>https://fr.linkedin.com/posts/octave-klaba-3a0b3632_jai-lu-lamendement-i-1358-au-plf-2027-activity-7522219045576888320-uqkw
>
>*Copy+paste:*
>
>J'ai lu l'amendement I-1358 au PLF 2027, adopté ce vendredi à l'Assemblée :
>une taxe de 0,055 € par Go envoyé vers les abonnés des FAI français. Le
>chiffre est abstrait, alors comparons-le. Corrigez-moi si vous voyez des
>erreurs.
>
>Deux comparaisons et un cas concret :
>
>1. Le transit et le peering. Un port 100 Gbps coûte environ 6 300 € par
>mois chez un fournisseur de transit mondial. En interconnexion directe avec
>un FAI européen, compter 3 à 5 fois plus, soit 20 à 30 k€ par mois. Sur ce
>port (a), la taxe atteint 1,02 M€ par mois, soit environ 3400 % à 16300 %
>du prix d'une interconnexion vers les FAI français. On change donc
>profondément le modèle économique de la bande passante en France.
>
>2. Les hyperscalers sont critiqués pour le prix de leur trafic sortant, qui
>va d'environ 0,08€ à 0,045€ par Go selon le volume. La taxe, 0,055 € par
>Go, représente 68 % à 123 % de ce prix. On parle donc de doubler, pour le
>trafic vers la France, un prix déjà jugé trop élevé !
>
>3. Le cas d'OVHcloud. Nous envoyons de l'ordre de 500 Gbps au 95e
>percentile vers les FAI français, soit environ 324 Gbps en moyenne. Sur un
>an, la taxe brute atteindrait 70 M€. Le texte la plafonne à 15 % du CA
>réalisé en France ou à 2 % du CA mondial, soit entre environ 23 et 70 M€
>par an que nous devrions collecter pour l'État, et donc répercuter sur nos
>clients.
>
>Conclusions :
>
>1. Une taxe porte en général sur une petite fraction de son assiette.
>Celle-ci vaut plus de 3000 % du coût du transit, et environ 100 % du prix
>public des hyperscalers. Rappelez-vous la loi SREN, votée pour supprimer
>les frais de transfert qui empêchaient les clients de quitter un
>fournisseur cloud. Ici, on parle de doubler le prix du trafic sortant vers
>les internautes français, un prix déjà très problématique.
>
>2. Le garde-fou, un plafond calculé sur le chiffre d'affaires, est
>incohérent. Ce chiffre d'affaires couvre des serveurs, du stockage, des
>datacenters et des équipes sans rapport avec la bande passante. C'est comme
>créer une taxe calculée sur la consommation électrique des usines
>automobiles en France, plafonnée à 15 % du chiffre d'affaires des
>constructeurs. Quel rapport entre les deux ?
>
>3. Une taxe nationale de ce type frappe à coup sûr les entreprises établies
>en France, alors que leurs concurrents mondiaux sans présence en France
>livrent le même trafic aux mêmes FAI français sans payer cette taxe en
>pratique. Cela crée une distorsion de concurrence au détriment des acteurs
>nationaux et déclasse les entreprises qui embauchent en France. Une taxe
>qui produit l'effet inverse serait une meilleure approche.
>
>(a) Facturé au 95e percentile, ce port n'est pas plein en permanence : avec
>un profil journalier type (22 % vers 4 h, 90 % vers 21 h), il transporte en
>moyenne 57 % de sa capacité, soit 18,6 millions de Go par mois.
>
>
>All the best,
>
>Frank
>Frantisek (Frank) Borsik
>
>In loving memory of Dave Täht: 1965-2025
>https://libreqos.io/2025/04/01/in-loving-memory-of-dave/
>
>
>https://www.linkedin.com/in/frantisekborsik
>Signal, Telegram, WhatsApp: +421919416714 <+421%20919%20416%20714>
>iMessage, mobile: +420775230885 <775%20230%20885>
>Skype: casioa5302ca
>frantisek.borsik@gmail.com
>_______________________________________________
>Starlink mailing list -- starlink@lists.bufferbloat.net
>To unsubscribe send an email to starlink-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 3+ messages in thread
end of thread, other threads:[~2026-11-19 16:11 UTC | newest]
Thread overview: 3+ messages (download: mbox.gz follow: Atom feed
-- links below jump to the message on this page --
[not found] <179507172508.1293.11534238119359794018@gauss>
2026-11-19 16:08 ` [Starlink] Re: The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering) Colin_Higbie
2026-11-19 16:11 ` Colin_Higbie
2026-10-31 12:56 [Starlink] " Frantisek Borsik
2026-10-31 18:05 ` [Starlink] " Daniel AJ Sokolov
This is a public inbox, see mirroring instructions
for how to clone and mirror all data and code used for this inbox