* [Starlink] The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering)
@ 2026-10-31 12:56 Frantisek Borsik
2026-10-31 14:51 ` [Starlink] Re: [Bloat] " Sophie
` (4 more replies)
0 siblings, 5 replies; 40+ messages in thread
From: Frantisek Borsik @ 2026-10-31 12:56 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: Network Neutrality is back! Let´s make the technical aspects heard this time!,
Dave Taht via Starlink, bloat, Cake List, libreqos,
Jeremy Austin via Rpm
Crossposting, because this garbage idea might "inspire" more countries and
have a horrible impact also on bufferbloat everywhere.
*Original post by Dr. Peering:*
*"The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country
by taxing Gigabits. Here’s Octave Klaba's excellent analysis [in French,
link below] showing just how insane the finance bill actually is. The IXP
taxation amount is, just for starters, ridiculous!"*
https://x.com/drpeering/status/2116468659392807
<https://x.com/drpeering/status/2116468659392807381?a=E-elnbppn-MAi-LNIrU&s=46>
*Octave's post:*
https://fr.linkedin.com/posts/octave-klaba-3a0b3632_jai-lu-lamendement-i-1358-au-plf-2027-activity-7522219045576888320-uqkw
*Copy+paste:*
J'ai lu l'amendement I-1358 au PLF 2027, adopté ce vendredi à l'Assemblée :
une taxe de 0,055 € par Go envoyé vers les abonnés des FAI français. Le
chiffre est abstrait, alors comparons-le. Corrigez-moi si vous voyez des
erreurs.
Deux comparaisons et un cas concret :
1. Le transit et le peering. Un port 100 Gbps coûte environ 6 300 € par
mois chez un fournisseur de transit mondial. En interconnexion directe avec
un FAI européen, compter 3 à 5 fois plus, soit 20 à 30 k€ par mois. Sur ce
port (a), la taxe atteint 1,02 M€ par mois, soit environ 3400 % à 16300 %
du prix d'une interconnexion vers les FAI français. On change donc
profondément le modèle économique de la bande passante en France.
2. Les hyperscalers sont critiqués pour le prix de leur trafic sortant, qui
va d'environ 0,08€ à 0,045€ par Go selon le volume. La taxe, 0,055 € par
Go, représente 68 % à 123 % de ce prix. On parle donc de doubler, pour le
trafic vers la France, un prix déjà jugé trop élevé !
3. Le cas d'OVHcloud. Nous envoyons de l'ordre de 500 Gbps au 95e
percentile vers les FAI français, soit environ 324 Gbps en moyenne. Sur un
an, la taxe brute atteindrait 70 M€. Le texte la plafonne à 15 % du CA
réalisé en France ou à 2 % du CA mondial, soit entre environ 23 et 70 M€
par an que nous devrions collecter pour l'État, et donc répercuter sur nos
clients.
Conclusions :
1. Une taxe porte en général sur une petite fraction de son assiette.
Celle-ci vaut plus de 3000 % du coût du transit, et environ 100 % du prix
public des hyperscalers. Rappelez-vous la loi SREN, votée pour supprimer
les frais de transfert qui empêchaient les clients de quitter un
fournisseur cloud. Ici, on parle de doubler le prix du trafic sortant vers
les internautes français, un prix déjà très problématique.
2. Le garde-fou, un plafond calculé sur le chiffre d'affaires, est
incohérent. Ce chiffre d'affaires couvre des serveurs, du stockage, des
datacenters et des équipes sans rapport avec la bande passante. C'est comme
créer une taxe calculée sur la consommation électrique des usines
automobiles en France, plafonnée à 15 % du chiffre d'affaires des
constructeurs. Quel rapport entre les deux ?
3. Une taxe nationale de ce type frappe à coup sûr les entreprises établies
en France, alors que leurs concurrents mondiaux sans présence en France
livrent le même trafic aux mêmes FAI français sans payer cette taxe en
pratique. Cela crée une distorsion de concurrence au détriment des acteurs
nationaux et déclasse les entreprises qui embauchent en France. Une taxe
qui produit l'effet inverse serait une meilleure approche.
(a) Facturé au 95e percentile, ce port n'est pas plein en permanence : avec
un profil journalier type (22 % vers 4 h, 90 % vers 21 h), il transporte en
moyenne 57 % de sa capacité, soit 18,6 millions de Go par mois.
All the best,
Frank
Frantisek (Frank) Borsik
In loving memory of Dave Täht: 1965-2025
https://libreqos.io/2025/04/01/in-loving-memory-of-dave/
https://www.linkedin.com/in/frantisekborsik
Signal, Telegram, WhatsApp: +421919416714 <+421%20919%20416%20714>
iMessage, mobile: +420775230885 <775%20230%20885>
Skype: casioa5302ca
frantisek.borsik@gmail.com
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 40+ messages in thread
* [Starlink] Re: [Bloat] The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering)
2026-10-31 12:56 [Starlink] The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering) Frantisek Borsik
@ 2026-10-31 14:51 ` Sophie
2026-10-31 14:58 ` [Starlink] " Inemesit Affia
` (3 subsequent siblings)
4 siblings, 0 replies; 40+ messages in thread
From: Sophie @ 2026-10-31 14:51 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: Frantisek Borsik
Cc: Network Neutrality is back! Let´s make the technical aspects heard this time!,
Dave Taht via Starlink, bloat, Cake List, libreqos,
Jeremy Austin via Rpm
The tax is 5 cents per Gigabyte. This is insane.
It goes against how we agree to use the Internet.
English version:
"France has recently approved a highly controversial "Internet Traffic
Tax" (or Gigabyte Tax) as part of the 2027 budget bill amendments. The
new levy targets digital content providers based on the volume of data
they transmit to French internet users, which is monitored by network
operators and Internet Service Providers (ISPs) heavily utilizing
Internet Exchange Points like France-IX."
Google AI summary:
"Key Metrics & Tax Rates
• €0.055 per gigabyte charged to content providers.
• Capped at 15% of a provider's French revenue.
• Capped at 2% of a provider's global revenue.
• Measured directly by French network operators and ISPs."
On 2026-10-31 13:56, Frantisek Borsik wrote:
> Crossposting, because this garbage idea might "inspire" more countries
> and
> have a horrible impact also on bufferbloat everywhere.
>
> *Original post by Dr. Peering:*
>
> *"The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own
> country
> by taxing Gigabits. Here’s Octave Klaba's excellent analysis [in
> French,
> link below] showing just how insane the finance bill actually is. The
> IXP
> taxation amount is, just for starters, ridiculous!"*
>
> https://x.com/drpeering/status/2116468659392807
> <https://x.com/drpeering/status/2116468659392807381?a=E-elnbppn-MAi-LNIrU&s=46>
>
> *Octave's post:*
>
> https://fr.linkedin.com/posts/octave-klaba-3a0b3632_jai-lu-lamendement-i-1358-au-plf-2027-activity-7522219045576888320-uqkw
>
> *Copy+paste:*
>
> J'ai lu l'amendement I-1358 au PLF 2027, adopté ce vendredi à
> l'Assemblée :
> une taxe de 0,055 € par Go envoyé vers les abonnés des FAI français. Le
> chiffre est abstrait, alors comparons-le. Corrigez-moi si vous voyez
> des
> erreurs.
>
> Deux comparaisons et un cas concret :
>
> 1. Le transit et le peering. Un port 100 Gbps coûte environ 6 300 € par
> mois chez un fournisseur de transit mondial. En interconnexion directe
> avec
> un FAI européen, compter 3 à 5 fois plus, soit 20 à 30 k€ par mois. Sur
> ce
> port (a), la taxe atteint 1,02 M€ par mois, soit environ 3400 % à 16300
> %
> du prix d'une interconnexion vers les FAI français. On change donc
> profondément le modèle économique de la bande passante en France.
>
> 2. Les hyperscalers sont critiqués pour le prix de leur trafic sortant,
> qui
> va d'environ 0,08€ à 0,045€ par Go selon le volume. La taxe, 0,055 €
> par
> Go, représente 68 % à 123 % de ce prix. On parle donc de doubler, pour
> le
> trafic vers la France, un prix déjà jugé trop élevé !
>
> 3. Le cas d'OVHcloud. Nous envoyons de l'ordre de 500 Gbps au 95e
> percentile vers les FAI français, soit environ 324 Gbps en moyenne. Sur
> un
> an, la taxe brute atteindrait 70 M€. Le texte la plafonne à 15 % du CA
> réalisé en France ou à 2 % du CA mondial, soit entre environ 23 et 70
> M€
> par an que nous devrions collecter pour l'État, et donc répercuter sur
> nos
> clients.
>
> Conclusions :
>
> 1. Une taxe porte en général sur une petite fraction de son assiette.
> Celle-ci vaut plus de 3000 % du coût du transit, et environ 100 % du
> prix
> public des hyperscalers. Rappelez-vous la loi SREN, votée pour
> supprimer
> les frais de transfert qui empêchaient les clients de quitter un
> fournisseur cloud. Ici, on parle de doubler le prix du trafic sortant
> vers
> les internautes français, un prix déjà très problématique.
>
> 2. Le garde-fou, un plafond calculé sur le chiffre d'affaires, est
> incohérent. Ce chiffre d'affaires couvre des serveurs, du stockage, des
> datacenters et des équipes sans rapport avec la bande passante. C'est
> comme
> créer une taxe calculée sur la consommation électrique des usines
> automobiles en France, plafonnée à 15 % du chiffre d'affaires des
> constructeurs. Quel rapport entre les deux ?
>
> 3. Une taxe nationale de ce type frappe à coup sûr les entreprises
> établies
> en France, alors que leurs concurrents mondiaux sans présence en France
> livrent le même trafic aux mêmes FAI français sans payer cette taxe en
> pratique. Cela crée une distorsion de concurrence au détriment des
> acteurs
> nationaux et déclasse les entreprises qui embauchent en France. Une
> taxe
> qui produit l'effet inverse serait une meilleure approche.
>
> (a) Facturé au 95e percentile, ce port n'est pas plein en permanence :
> avec
> un profil journalier type (22 % vers 4 h, 90 % vers 21 h), il
> transporte en
> moyenne 57 % de sa capacité, soit 18,6 millions de Go par mois.
>
>
> All the best,
>
> Frank
> Frantisek (Frank) Borsik
>
> In loving memory of Dave Täht: 1965-2025
> https://libreqos.io/2025/04/01/in-loving-memory-of-dave/
>
>
> https://www.linkedin.com/in/frantisekborsik
> Signal, Telegram, WhatsApp: +421919416714 <+421%20919%20416%20714>
> iMessage, mobile: +420775230885 <775%20230%20885>
> Skype: casioa5302ca
> frantisek.borsik@gmail.com
> _______________________________________________
> Bloat mailing list -- bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net
> To unsubscribe send an email to bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 40+ messages in thread
* [Starlink] The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering)
2026-10-31 12:56 [Starlink] The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering) Frantisek Borsik
2026-10-31 14:51 ` [Starlink] Re: [Bloat] " Sophie
@ 2026-10-31 14:58 ` Inemesit Affia
2026-10-31 18:05 ` [Starlink] " Daniel AJ Sokolov
` (2 subsequent siblings)
4 siblings, 0 replies; 40+ messages in thread
From: Inemesit Affia @ 2026-10-31 14:58 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: starlink
*Translated with Deepl*
I read Amendment I-1358 to the 2027 Budget Bill, which was adopted this Friday by the National Assembly:
a tax of €0.055 per GB sent to subscribers of French ISPs. The
figure is abstract, so let’s compare it. Correct me if you spot any
errors.
Two comparisons and a real-world example:
1. Transit and peering. A 100 Gbps port costs approximately €6,300 per
month from a global transit provider. For direct interconnection with
a European ISP, 3 to 5 times as much, or 20 to 30 k€ per month. For this
port (a), the tax amounts to 1.02 M€ per month, or approximately 3,400% to 16,300%
of the price of an interconnection to French ISPs. This therefore
radically changes the economic model for bandwidth in France.
2. Hyperscalers are criticized for the price of their outbound traffic, which
ranges from about €0.08 to €0.045 per GB depending on volume. The tax, at €0.055 per
GB, represents 68% to 123% of that price. This means that, for
traffic to France, the price—which is already considered too high—would effectively double!
3. The OVHcloud case. We send approximately 500 Gbps at the 95th
percentile to French ISPs, or about 324 Gbps on average. Over the course of a
year, the gross tax would amount to €70 million. The bill caps it at 15% of revenue
generated in France or 2% of global revenue, which amounts to between approximately €23 million and €70 million
per year that we would have to collect on behalf of the government and, therefore, pass on to our
customers.
Conclusions:
1. A tax generally applies to a small fraction of its tax base.
This tax base is worth more than 3,000% of the cost of transit, and approximately 100% of the
retail price of hyperscalers.
Remember the SREN law, which was passed to eliminate
the transfer fees that prevented customers from switching from one
cloud provider to another. Here, we’re talking about doubling the price of outbound traffic to
French internet users—a price that’s already very problematic.
2. The cap—a limit calculated based on revenue—is
inconsistent. This revenue figure includes servers, storage,
data centers, and teams that have nothing to do with bandwidth. It’s like
creating a tax based on the electricity consumption of
automobile factories in France, capped at 15% of the
manufacturers’ revenue. What’s the connection between the two?
3. A national tax of this kind would undoubtedly affect companies based
in France, while their global competitors with no presence in France
deliver the same traffic to the same French ISPs without paying this tax in
practice. This creates a distortion of competition to the detriment of domestic
players and puts companies that hire in France at a disadvantage. A tax
that produces the opposite effect would be a better approach.
(a) Based on the 95th percentile, this port is not constantly at full capacity: with
a typical daily profile (22% around 4 a.m., 90% around 9 p.m.), it carries, on
average, 57% of its capacity, or 18.6 million GB per month.
.....
I wonder who's meant to benefit from this law.
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 40+ messages in thread
* [Starlink] Re: The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering)
2026-10-31 12:56 [Starlink] The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering) Frantisek Borsik
2026-10-31 14:51 ` [Starlink] Re: [Bloat] " Sophie
2026-10-31 14:58 ` [Starlink] " Inemesit Affia
@ 2026-10-31 18:05 ` Daniel AJ Sokolov
2026-11-02 7:44 ` [Starlink] [Bloat] " Michael Welzl
2026-11-16 16:11 ` Juliusz Chroboczek
4 siblings, 0 replies; 40+ messages in thread
From: Daniel AJ Sokolov @ 2026-10-31 18:05 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: Frantisek Borsik via Starlink
It is not a final decision.
I understand it was a first reading with just 35 members of Parliament present, of whom 11 voted Oui and 10 voted Non.
BR
Daniel
On October 31, 2026 5:56:18 a.m. MST, Frantisek Borsik via Starlink <starlink@lists.bufferbloat.net> wrote:
>Crossposting, because this garbage idea might "inspire" more countries and
>have a horrible impact also on bufferbloat everywhere.
>
>*Original post by Dr. Peering:*
>
>*"The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country
>by taxing Gigabits. Here’s Octave Klaba's excellent analysis [in French,
>link below] showing just how insane the finance bill actually is. The IXP
>taxation amount is, just for starters, ridiculous!"*
>
>https://x.com/drpeering/status/2116468659392807
><https://x.com/drpeering/status/2116468659392807381?a=E-elnbppn-MAi-LNIrU&s=46>
>
>*Octave's post:*
>
>https://fr.linkedin.com/posts/octave-klaba-3a0b3632_jai-lu-lamendement-i-1358-au-plf-2027-activity-7522219045576888320-uqkw
>
>*Copy+paste:*
>
>J'ai lu l'amendement I-1358 au PLF 2027, adopté ce vendredi à l'Assemblée :
>une taxe de 0,055 € par Go envoyé vers les abonnés des FAI français. Le
>chiffre est abstrait, alors comparons-le. Corrigez-moi si vous voyez des
>erreurs.
>
>Deux comparaisons et un cas concret :
>
>1. Le transit et le peering. Un port 100 Gbps coûte environ 6 300 € par
>mois chez un fournisseur de transit mondial. En interconnexion directe avec
>un FAI européen, compter 3 à 5 fois plus, soit 20 à 30 k€ par mois. Sur ce
>port (a), la taxe atteint 1,02 M€ par mois, soit environ 3400 % à 16300 %
>du prix d'une interconnexion vers les FAI français. On change donc
>profondément le modèle économique de la bande passante en France.
>
>2. Les hyperscalers sont critiqués pour le prix de leur trafic sortant, qui
>va d'environ 0,08€ à 0,045€ par Go selon le volume. La taxe, 0,055 € par
>Go, représente 68 % à 123 % de ce prix. On parle donc de doubler, pour le
>trafic vers la France, un prix déjà jugé trop élevé !
>
>3. Le cas d'OVHcloud. Nous envoyons de l'ordre de 500 Gbps au 95e
>percentile vers les FAI français, soit environ 324 Gbps en moyenne. Sur un
>an, la taxe brute atteindrait 70 M€. Le texte la plafonne à 15 % du CA
>réalisé en France ou à 2 % du CA mondial, soit entre environ 23 et 70 M€
>par an que nous devrions collecter pour l'État, et donc répercuter sur nos
>clients.
>
>Conclusions :
>
>1. Une taxe porte en général sur une petite fraction de son assiette.
>Celle-ci vaut plus de 3000 % du coût du transit, et environ 100 % du prix
>public des hyperscalers. Rappelez-vous la loi SREN, votée pour supprimer
>les frais de transfert qui empêchaient les clients de quitter un
>fournisseur cloud. Ici, on parle de doubler le prix du trafic sortant vers
>les internautes français, un prix déjà très problématique.
>
>2. Le garde-fou, un plafond calculé sur le chiffre d'affaires, est
>incohérent. Ce chiffre d'affaires couvre des serveurs, du stockage, des
>datacenters et des équipes sans rapport avec la bande passante. C'est comme
>créer une taxe calculée sur la consommation électrique des usines
>automobiles en France, plafonnée à 15 % du chiffre d'affaires des
>constructeurs. Quel rapport entre les deux ?
>
>3. Une taxe nationale de ce type frappe à coup sûr les entreprises établies
>en France, alors que leurs concurrents mondiaux sans présence en France
>livrent le même trafic aux mêmes FAI français sans payer cette taxe en
>pratique. Cela crée une distorsion de concurrence au détriment des acteurs
>nationaux et déclasse les entreprises qui embauchent en France. Une taxe
>qui produit l'effet inverse serait une meilleure approche.
>
>(a) Facturé au 95e percentile, ce port n'est pas plein en permanence : avec
>un profil journalier type (22 % vers 4 h, 90 % vers 21 h), il transporte en
>moyenne 57 % de sa capacité, soit 18,6 millions de Go par mois.
>
>
>All the best,
>
>Frank
>Frantisek (Frank) Borsik
>
>In loving memory of Dave Täht: 1965-2025
>https://libreqos.io/2025/04/01/in-loving-memory-of-dave/
>
>
>https://www.linkedin.com/in/frantisekborsik
>Signal, Telegram, WhatsApp: +421919416714 <+421%20919%20416%20714>
>iMessage, mobile: +420775230885 <775%20230%20885>
>Skype: casioa5302ca
>frantisek.borsik@gmail.com
>_______________________________________________
>Starlink mailing list -- starlink@lists.bufferbloat.net
>To unsubscribe send an email to starlink-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 40+ messages in thread
* [Starlink] [Bloat] Re: The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering)
2026-10-31 12:56 [Starlink] The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering) Frantisek Borsik
` (2 preceding siblings ...)
2026-10-31 18:05 ` [Starlink] " Daniel AJ Sokolov
@ 2026-11-02 7:44 ` Michael Welzl
2026-11-02 11:23 ` [Starlink] Re: [Bloat] " Sebastian Moeller
[not found] ` <bf2f7d692a5e42738403850d419c4a94@OS5P279MB0502.NORP279.PROD.OUTLOOK.COM>
2026-11-16 16:11 ` Juliusz Chroboczek
4 siblings, 2 replies; 40+ messages in thread
From: Michael Welzl @ 2026-11-02 7:44 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: Frantisek Borsik
Cc: Network Neutrality is back! Let´s make the technical aspects heard this time!,
Dave Taht via Starlink, bloat, Cake List, libreqos,
Jeremy Austin via Rpm
The tax is 5 cents per Gigabyte. This is insane.
It goes against how we agree to use the Internet.
English version:
"France has recently approved a highly controversial "Internet Traffic
Tax" (or Gigabyte Tax) as part of the 2027 budget bill amendments. The
new levy targets digital content providers based on the volume of data
they transmit to French internet users, which is monitored by network
operators and Internet Service Providers (ISPs) heavily utilizing
Internet Exchange Points like France-IX."
Google AI summary:
"Key Metrics & Tax Rates
• €0.055 per gigabyte charged to content providers.
• Capped at 15% of a provider's French revenue.
• Capped at 2% of a provider's global revenue.
• Measured directly by French network operators and ISPs."
On 2026-10-31 13:56, Frantisek Borsik wrote:
> Crossposting, because this garbage idea might "inspire" more countries
> and
> have a horrible impact also on bufferbloat everywhere.
>
> *Original post by Dr. Peering:*
>
> *"The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own
> country
> by taxing Gigabits. Here’s Octave Klaba's excellent analysis [in
> French,
> link below] showing just how insane the finance bill actually is. The
> IXP
> taxation amount is, just for starters, ridiculous!"*
>
> https://x.com/drpeering/status/2116468659392807
> <https://x.com/drpeering/status/2116468659392807381?a=E-elnbppn-MAi-LNIrU&s=46>
>
> *Octave's post:*
>
> https://fr.linkedin.com/posts/octave-klaba-3a0b3632_jai-lu-lamendement-i-1358-au-plf-2027-activity-7522219045576888320-uqkw
>
> *Copy+paste:*
>
> J'ai lu l'amendement I-1358 au PLF 2027, adopté ce vendredi à
> l'Assemblée :
> une taxe de 0,055 € par Go envoyé vers les abonnés des FAI français. Le
> chiffre est abstrait, alors comparons-le. Corrigez-moi si vous voyez
> des
> erreurs.
>
> Deux comparaisons et un cas concret :
>
> 1. Le transit et le peering. Un port 100 Gbps coûte environ 6 300 € par
> mois chez un fournisseur de transit mondial. En interconnexion directe
> avec
> un FAI européen, compter 3 à 5 fois plus, soit 20 à 30 k€ par mois. Sur
> ce
> port (a), la taxe atteint 1,02 M€ par mois, soit environ 3400 % à 16300
> %
> du prix d'une interconnexion vers les FAI français. On change donc
> profondément le modèle économique de la bande passante en France.
>
> 2. Les hyperscalers sont critiqués pour le prix de leur trafic sortant,
> qui
> va d'environ 0,08€ à 0,045€ par Go selon le volume. La taxe, 0,055 €
> par
> Go, représente 68 % à 123 % de ce prix. On parle donc de doubler, pour
> le
> trafic vers la France, un prix déjà jugé trop élevé !
>
> 3. Le cas d'OVHcloud. Nous envoyons de l'ordre de 500 Gbps au 95e
> percentile vers les FAI français, soit environ 324 Gbps en moyenne. Sur
> un
> an, la taxe brute atteindrait 70 M€. Le texte la plafonne à 15 % du CA
> réalisé en France ou à 2 % du CA mondial, soit entre environ 23 et 70
> M€
> par an que nous devrions collecter pour l'État, et donc répercuter sur
> nos
> clients.
>
> Conclusions :
>
> 1. Une taxe porte en général sur une petite fraction de son assiette.
> Celle-ci vaut plus de 3000 % du coût du transit, et environ 100 % du
> prix
> public des hyperscalers. Rappelez-vous la loi SREN, votée pour
> supprimer
> les frais de transfert qui empêchaient les clients de quitter un
> fournisseur cloud. Ici, on parle de doubler le prix du trafic sortant
> vers
> les internautes français, un prix déjà très problématique.
>
> 2. Le garde-fou, un plafond calculé sur le chiffre d'affaires, est
> incohérent. Ce chiffre d'affaires couvre des serveurs, du stockage, des
> datacenters et des équipes sans rapport avec la bande passante. C'est
> comme
> créer une taxe calculée sur la consommation électrique des usines
> automobiles en France, plafonnée à 15 % du chiffre d'affaires des
> constructeurs. Quel rapport entre les deux ?
>
> 3. Une taxe nationale de ce type frappe à coup sûr les entreprises
> établies
> en France, alors que leurs concurrents mondiaux sans présence en France
> livrent le même trafic aux mêmes FAI français sans payer cette taxe en
> pratique. Cela crée une distorsion de concurrence au détriment des
> acteurs
> nationaux et déclasse les entreprises qui embauchent en France. Une
> taxe
> qui produit l'effet inverse serait une meilleure approche.
>
> (a) Facturé au 95e percentile, ce port n'est pas plein en permanence :
> avec
> un profil journalier type (22 % vers 4 h, 90 % vers 21 h), il
> transporte en
> moyenne 57 % de sa capacité, soit 18,6 millions de Go par mois.
>
>
> All the best,
>
> Frank
> Frantisek (Frank) Borsik
>
> In loving memory of Dave Täht: 1965-2025
> https://libreqos.io/2025/04/01/in-loving-memory-of-dave/
>
>
> https://www.linkedin.com/in/frantisekborsik
> Signal, Telegram, WhatsApp: +421919416714 <+421%20919%20416%20714>
> iMessage, mobile: +420775230885 <775%20230%20885>
> Skype: casioa5302ca
> frantisek.borsik@gmail.com
> _______________________________________________
> Bloat mailing list -- bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net
> To unsubscribe send an email to bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
_______________________________________________
Bloat mailing list -- bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net
To unsubscribe send an email to bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 40+ messages in thread
* [Starlink] Re: [Bloat] The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering)
2026-11-02 7:44 ` [Starlink] [Bloat] " Michael Welzl
@ 2026-11-02 11:23 ` Sebastian Moeller
2026-11-02 14:30 ` [Starlink] Re: [NNagain] " Sascha Meinrath
[not found] ` <bf2f7d692a5e42738403850d419c4a94@OS5P279MB0502.NORP279.PROD.OUTLOOK.COM>
1 sibling, 1 reply; 40+ messages in thread
From: Sebastian Moeller @ 2026-11-02 11:23 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: Michael Welzl
Cc: Frantisek Borsik,
Network Neutrality is back! Letīs make the technical aspects heard this time!,
Dave Taht via Starlink, bloat, Cake List, libreqos,
Jeremy Austin via Rpm
Hi Michael,
> On Nov 2, 2026, at 08:44, Michael Welzl <michawe@ifi.uio.no> wrote:
>
> The tax is 5 cents per Gigabyte. This is insane.
Back of the envelop calculations for video streaming (assuming this to be the one category driving most of the sustained capacity usage):
common use seems to be HD streaming (say on average at 5 Mbps), with say 2 hours per day, 7 days per week:
(5 * 1000^2) * (60 * 60 * 2 * 30) / (8 * 1000^3) = 135 GB
-> 135 * 0.055 = 7.425 Euro/month
typical cost for midrange (ad-free) video streaming in france: 8-15 Euro
depending on the reference contract tier, the tax almost as large as the total revenue, no way this could be priced-in without significant price increases.
The proposed tax indeed seems quite steep, however it is capped at 15% of revenue in france or 2% of world-wide revenue
So that would get this more in like with a 15% tax... on revenue, still nothing to sneeze at, but a far cry from the numbers one gets when simply multiplying...
Regards
Sebastian
P.S.: My take this is half-baked and will not make it through the further legislative process in that form.
> It goes against how we agree to use the Internet.
>
> English version:
> "France has recently approved a highly controversial "Internet Traffic
> Tax" (or Gigabyte Tax) as part of the 2027 budget bill amendments. The
> new levy targets digital content providers based on the volume of data
> they transmit to French internet users, which is monitored by network
> operators and Internet Service Providers (ISPs) heavily utilizing
> Internet Exchange Points like France-IX."
>
> Google AI summary:
> "Key Metrics & Tax Rates
> • €0.055 per gigabyte charged to content providers.
> • Capped at 15% of a provider's French revenue.
> • Capped at 2% of a provider's global revenue.
> • Measured directly by French network operators and ISPs."
>
>
> On 2026-10-31 13:56, Frantisek Borsik wrote:
>> Crossposting, because this garbage idea might "inspire" more countries
>> and
>> have a horrible impact also on bufferbloat everywhere.
>>
>> *Original post by Dr. Peering:*
>>
>> *"The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own
>> country
>> by taxing Gigabits. Here’s Octave Klaba's excellent analysis [in
>> French,
>> link below] showing just how insane the finance bill actually is. The
>> IXP
>> taxation amount is, just for starters, ridiculous!"*
>>
>> https://x.com/drpeering/status/2116468659392807
>> <https://x.com/drpeering/status/2116468659392807381?a=E-elnbppn-MAi-LNIrU&s=46>
>>
>> *Octave's post:*
>>
>> https://fr.linkedin.com/posts/octave-klaba-3a0b3632_jai-lu-lamendement-i-1358-au-plf-2027-activity-7522219045576888320-uqkw
>>
>> *Copy+paste:*
>>
>> J'ai lu l'amendement I-1358 au PLF 2027, adopté ce vendredi à
>> l'Assemblée :
>> une taxe de 0,055 € par Go envoyé vers les abonnés des FAI français. Le
>> chiffre est abstrait, alors comparons-le. Corrigez-moi si vous voyez
>> des
>> erreurs.
>>
>> Deux comparaisons et un cas concret :
>>
>> 1. Le transit et le peering. Un port 100 Gbps coûte environ 6 300 € par
>> mois chez un fournisseur de transit mondial. En interconnexion directe
>> avec
>> un FAI européen, compter 3 à 5 fois plus, soit 20 à 30 k€ par mois. Sur
>> ce
>> port (a), la taxe atteint 1,02 M€ par mois, soit environ 3400 % à 16300
>> %
>> du prix d'une interconnexion vers les FAI français. On change donc
>> profondément le modèle économique de la bande passante en France.
>>
>> 2. Les hyperscalers sont critiqués pour le prix de leur trafic sortant,
>> qui
>> va d'environ 0,08€ à 0,045€ par Go selon le volume. La taxe, 0,055 €
>> par
>> Go, représente 68 % à 123 % de ce prix. On parle donc de doubler, pour
>> le
>> trafic vers la France, un prix déjà jugé trop élevé !
>>
>> 3. Le cas d'OVHcloud. Nous envoyons de l'ordre de 500 Gbps au 95e
>> percentile vers les FAI français, soit environ 324 Gbps en moyenne. Sur
>> un
>> an, la taxe brute atteindrait 70 M€. Le texte la plafonne à 15 % du CA
>> réalisé en France ou à 2 % du CA mondial, soit entre environ 23 et 70
>> M€
>> par an que nous devrions collecter pour l'État, et donc répercuter sur
>> nos
>> clients.
>>
>> Conclusions :
>>
>> 1. Une taxe porte en général sur une petite fraction de son assiette.
>> Celle-ci vaut plus de 3000 % du coût du transit, et environ 100 % du
>> prix
>> public des hyperscalers. Rappelez-vous la loi SREN, votée pour
>> supprimer
>> les frais de transfert qui empêchaient les clients de quitter un
>> fournisseur cloud. Ici, on parle de doubler le prix du trafic sortant
>> vers
>> les internautes français, un prix déjà très problématique.
>>
>> 2. Le garde-fou, un plafond calculé sur le chiffre d'affaires, est
>> incohérent. Ce chiffre d'affaires couvre des serveurs, du stockage, des
>> datacenters et des équipes sans rapport avec la bande passante. C'est
>> comme
>> créer une taxe calculée sur la consommation électrique des usines
>> automobiles en France, plafonnée à 15 % du chiffre d'affaires des
>> constructeurs. Quel rapport entre les deux ?
>>
>> 3. Une taxe nationale de ce type frappe à coup sûr les entreprises
>> établies
>> en France, alors que leurs concurrents mondiaux sans présence en France
>> livrent le même trafic aux mêmes FAI français sans payer cette taxe en
>> pratique. Cela crée une distorsion de concurrence au détriment des
>> acteurs
>> nationaux et déclasse les entreprises qui embauchent en France. Une
>> taxe
>> qui produit l'effet inverse serait une meilleure approche.
>>
>> (a) Facturé au 95e percentile, ce port n'est pas plein en permanence :
>> avec
>> un profil journalier type (22 % vers 4 h, 90 % vers 21 h), il
>> transporte en
>> moyenne 57 % de sa capacité, soit 18,6 millions de Go par mois.
>>
>>
>> All the best,
>>
>> Frank
>> Frantisek (Frank) Borsik
>>
>> In loving memory of Dave Täht: 1965-2025
>> https://libreqos.io/2025/04/01/in-loving-memory-of-dave/
>>
>>
>> https://www.linkedin.com/in/frantisekborsik
>> Signal, Telegram, WhatsApp: +421919416714 <+421%20919%20416%20714>
>> iMessage, mobile: +420775230885 <775%20230%20885>
>> Skype: casioa5302ca
>> frantisek.borsik@gmail.com
>> _______________________________________________
>> Bloat mailing list -- bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net
>> To unsubscribe send an email to bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
> _______________________________________________
> Bloat mailing list -- bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net
> To unsubscribe send an email to bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
> _______________________________________________
> Bloat mailing list -- bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net
> To unsubscribe send an email to bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 40+ messages in thread
* [Starlink] Re: [Bloat] The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering)
[not found] ` <bf2f7d692a5e42738403850d419c4a94@OS5P279MB0502.NORP279.PROD.OUTLOOK.COM>
@ 2026-11-02 11:33 ` Michael Welzl
0 siblings, 0 replies; 40+ messages in thread
From: Michael Welzl @ 2026-11-02 11:33 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: Sebastian Moeller
Cc: Frantisek Borsik,
Network Neutrality is back! Letīs make the technical aspects heard this time!,
Dave Taht via Starlink, bloat, Cake List, libreqos,
Jeremy Austin via Rpm
OMG, it seems I did something terrible. My apologies to everyone who got strange emails from me this morning.
This:
>> On Nov 2, 2026, at 08:44, Michael Welzl <michawe@ifi.uio.no> wrote:
>>
>> The tax is 5 cents per Gigabyte. This is insane.
is a lie that was made up by Outlook. The email was written by someone else; auto-forward from Outlook had failed; “apply the filters again after the failure” has been removed from the Outlook interface; I found a “send again” function which, I thought, sends it again **TO ME** … not to the original recipients **on my behalf** !
I didn’t write the original message and didn’t even plan to get involved in this discussion - because:
> P.S.: My take this is half-baked and will not make it through the further legislative process in that form.
… I think so too.
I’m very, very sorry for any email noise from me today :-(
Cheers,
Michael
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 40+ messages in thread
* [Starlink] Re: [NNagain] Re: [Bloat] The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering)
2026-11-02 11:23 ` [Starlink] Re: [Bloat] " Sebastian Moeller
@ 2026-11-02 14:30 ` Sascha Meinrath
2026-11-04 15:40 ` [Starlink] Re: [NNagain] " Sebastian Moeller
` (2 more replies)
0 siblings, 3 replies; 40+ messages in thread
From: Sascha Meinrath @ 2026-11-02 14:30 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: Network Neutrality is back! Let´s make the technical aspects heard this time!,
Michael Welzl
Cc: Frantisek Borsik, Dave Taht via Starlink, bloat, Cake List,
libreqos, Jeremy Austin via Rpm, Sebastian Moeller
I can't wait until the French Parliament learns about VPNs... It would be
absolutely *wonderful* if all the ISPs passed along the tax to their
customers... and then taught all their customers that VPNed traffic would, for
obvious reasons, be exempted.
I find proposals like this to be absolutely idiotic -- and, they are yet another
step in the global data obfuscation arms race.
#encrypteverything
--Sascha
On 11/2/26 6:23 AM, Sebastian Moeller via Nnagain wrote:
> Hi Michael,
>
>> On Nov 2, 2026, at 08:44, Michael Welzl <michawe@ifi.uio.no> wrote:
>>
>> The tax is 5 cents per Gigabyte. This is insane.
>
> Back of the envelop calculations for video streaming (assuming this to be the one category driving most of the sustained capacity usage):
>
> common use seems to be HD streaming (say on average at 5 Mbps), with say 2 hours per day, 7 days per week:
>
> (5 * 1000^2) * (60 * 60 * 2 * 30) / (8 * 1000^3) = 135 GB
> -> 135 * 0.055 = 7.425 Euro/month
>
> typical cost for midrange (ad-free) video streaming in france: 8-15 Euro
>
> depending on the reference contract tier, the tax almost as large as the total revenue, no way this could be priced-in without significant price increases.
>
> The proposed tax indeed seems quite steep, however it is capped at 15% of revenue in france or 2% of world-wide revenue
>
> So that would get this more in like with a 15% tax... on revenue, still nothing to sneeze at, but a far cry from the numbers one gets when simply multiplying...
>
> Regards
> Sebastian
>
> P.S.: My take this is half-baked and will not make it through the further legislative process in that form.
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>> It goes against how we agree to use the Internet.
>>
>> English version:
>> "France has recently approved a highly controversial "Internet Traffic
>> Tax" (or Gigabyte Tax) as part of the 2027 budget bill amendments. The
>> new levy targets digital content providers based on the volume of data
>> they transmit to French internet users, which is monitored by network
>> operators and Internet Service Providers (ISPs) heavily utilizing
>> Internet Exchange Points like France-IX."
>>
>> Google AI summary:
>> "Key Metrics & Tax Rates
>> • €0.055 per gigabyte charged to content providers.
>> • Capped at 15% of a provider's French revenue.
>> • Capped at 2% of a provider's global revenue.
>> • Measured directly by French network operators and ISPs."
>>
>>
>> On 2026-10-31 13:56, Frantisek Borsik wrote:
>>> Crossposting, because this garbage idea might "inspire" more countries
>>> and
>>> have a horrible impact also on bufferbloat everywhere.
>>>
>>> *Original post by Dr. Peering:*
>>>
>>> *"The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own
>>> country
>>> by taxing Gigabits. Here’s Octave Klaba's excellent analysis [in
>>> French,
>>> link below] showing just how insane the finance bill actually is. The
>>> IXP
>>> taxation amount is, just for starters, ridiculous!"*
>>>
>>> https://x.com/drpeering/status/2116468659392807
>>> <https://x.com/drpeering/status/2116468659392807381?a=E-elnbppn-MAi-LNIrU&s=46>
>>>
>>> *Octave's post:*
>>>
>>> https://fr.linkedin.com/posts/octave-klaba-3a0b3632_jai-lu-lamendement-i-1358-au-plf-2027-activity-7522219045576888320-uqkw
>>>
>>> *Copy+paste:*
>>>
>>> J'ai lu l'amendement I-1358 au PLF 2027, adopté ce vendredi à
>>> l'Assemblée :
>>> une taxe de 0,055 € par Go envoyé vers les abonnés des FAI français. Le
>>> chiffre est abstrait, alors comparons-le. Corrigez-moi si vous voyez
>>> des
>>> erreurs.
>>>
>>> Deux comparaisons et un cas concret :
>>>
>>> 1. Le transit et le peering. Un port 100 Gbps coûte environ 6 300 € par
>>> mois chez un fournisseur de transit mondial. En interconnexion directe
>>> avec
>>> un FAI européen, compter 3 à 5 fois plus, soit 20 à 30 k€ par mois. Sur
>>> ce
>>> port (a), la taxe atteint 1,02 M€ par mois, soit environ 3400 % à 16300
>>> %
>>> du prix d'une interconnexion vers les FAI français. On change donc
>>> profondément le modèle économique de la bande passante en France.
>>>
>>> 2. Les hyperscalers sont critiqués pour le prix de leur trafic sortant,
>>> qui
>>> va d'environ 0,08€ à 0,045€ par Go selon le volume. La taxe, 0,055 €
>>> par
>>> Go, représente 68 % à 123 % de ce prix. On parle donc de doubler, pour
>>> le
>>> trafic vers la France, un prix déjà jugé trop élevé !
>>>
>>> 3. Le cas d'OVHcloud. Nous envoyons de l'ordre de 500 Gbps au 95e
>>> percentile vers les FAI français, soit environ 324 Gbps en moyenne. Sur
>>> un
>>> an, la taxe brute atteindrait 70 M€. Le texte la plafonne à 15 % du CA
>>> réalisé en France ou à 2 % du CA mondial, soit entre environ 23 et 70
>>> M€
>>> par an que nous devrions collecter pour l'État, et donc répercuter sur
>>> nos
>>> clients.
>>>
>>> Conclusions :
>>>
>>> 1. Une taxe porte en général sur une petite fraction de son assiette.
>>> Celle-ci vaut plus de 3000 % du coût du transit, et environ 100 % du
>>> prix
>>> public des hyperscalers. Rappelez-vous la loi SREN, votée pour
>>> supprimer
>>> les frais de transfert qui empêchaient les clients de quitter un
>>> fournisseur cloud. Ici, on parle de doubler le prix du trafic sortant
>>> vers
>>> les internautes français, un prix déjà très problématique.
>>>
>>> 2. Le garde-fou, un plafond calculé sur le chiffre d'affaires, est
>>> incohérent. Ce chiffre d'affaires couvre des serveurs, du stockage, des
>>> datacenters et des équipes sans rapport avec la bande passante. C'est
>>> comme
>>> créer une taxe calculée sur la consommation électrique des usines
>>> automobiles en France, plafonnée à 15 % du chiffre d'affaires des
>>> constructeurs. Quel rapport entre les deux ?
>>>
>>> 3. Une taxe nationale de ce type frappe à coup sûr les entreprises
>>> établies
>>> en France, alors que leurs concurrents mondiaux sans présence en France
>>> livrent le même trafic aux mêmes FAI français sans payer cette taxe en
>>> pratique. Cela crée une distorsion de concurrence au détriment des
>>> acteurs
>>> nationaux et déclasse les entreprises qui embauchent en France. Une
>>> taxe
>>> qui produit l'effet inverse serait une meilleure approche.
>>>
>>> (a) Facturé au 95e percentile, ce port n'est pas plein en permanence :
>>> avec
>>> un profil journalier type (22 % vers 4 h, 90 % vers 21 h), il
>>> transporte en
>>> moyenne 57 % de sa capacité, soit 18,6 millions de Go par mois.
>>>
>>>
>>> All the best,
>>>
>>> Frank
>>> Frantisek (Frank) Borsik
>>>
>>> In loving memory of Dave Täht: 1965-2025
>>> https://libreqos.io/2025/04/01/in-loving-memory-of-dave/
>>>
>>>
>>> https://www.linkedin.com/in/frantisekborsik
>>> Signal, Telegram, WhatsApp: +421919416714 <+421%20919%20416%20714>
>>> iMessage, mobile: +420775230885 <775%20230%20885>
>>> Skype: casioa5302ca
>>> frantisek.borsik@gmail.com
>>> _______________________________________________
>>> Bloat mailing list -- bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net
>>> To unsubscribe send an email to bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
>> _______________________________________________
>> Bloat mailing list -- bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net
>> To unsubscribe send an email to bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
>> _______________________________________________
>> Bloat mailing list -- bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net
>> To unsubscribe send an email to bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> Nnagain mailing list -- nnagain@lists.bufferbloat.net
> To unsubscribe send an email to nnagain-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
--
Sascha Meinrath
Director, X-Lab
Palmer Chair in Telecommunications
Penn State University
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 40+ messages in thread
* [Starlink] Re: [NNagain] [Bloat] The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering)
2026-11-02 14:30 ` [Starlink] Re: [NNagain] " Sascha Meinrath
@ 2026-11-04 15:40 ` Sebastian Moeller
2026-11-04 16:20 ` Sascha Meinrath
2026-11-18 1:48 ` [Starlink] Re: [NNagain] " Raquel Renno Nunes
2026-11-18 7:46 ` Frantisek Borsik
2 siblings, 1 reply; 40+ messages in thread
From: Sebastian Moeller @ 2026-11-04 15:40 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: sascha
Cc: Network Neutrality is back! Let´s make the technical aspects heard this time!,
Michael Welzl, Frantisek Borsik, Dave Taht via Starlink, bloat,
Cake List, libreqos, Jeremy Austin via Rpm
Hi Sascha,
> On Nov 2, 2026, at 15:30, Sascha Meinrath <sascha@thexlab.org> wrote:
>
> I can't wait until the French Parliament learns about VPNs... It would be absolutely *wonderful* if all the ISPs passed along the tax to their customers... and then taught all their customers that VPNed traffic would, for obvious reasons, be exempted.
Not how this is supposed to work: the ISP aggregates its end-customer bound traffic volume by ASN and reports these aggregates quarterly, the tax office sends the ASNs the tax bill. VPN does not really matter, except now it is the VPN provider that is on the hook for the money. The amendment does not address VPNs but for CDNs that are in a similar picckle the idea is that CDN operators either pass on the cost or "eat" it themselves (both half-baked ideas). The only oddity VPNs add is that they typically receive no money from the actual content providers, but the end users.
>
> I find proposals like this to be absolutely idiotic -- and, they are yet another step in the global data obfuscation arms race.
Oh, that proposal is pretty half-baked, no arggument there, but I think we differ in which of its half-baked-ness we consider worst ;)
>
> #encrypteverything
Well, if you look what this is supposed to operate on encryption is not really an option, as this operates on source and destination IP addresses, that are somewhat prickly to encrypt if you want packets delivered...
>
> --Sascha
>
> On 11/2/26 6:23 AM, Sebastian Moeller via Nnagain wrote:
>> Hi Michael,
>>> On Nov 2, 2026, at 08:44, Michael Welzl <michawe@ifi.uio.no> wrote:
>>>
>>> The tax is 5 cents per Gigabyte. This is insane.
>> Back of the envelop calculations for video streaming (assuming this to be the one category driving most of the sustained capacity usage):
>> common use seems to be HD streaming (say on average at 5 Mbps), with say 2 hours per day, 7 days per week:
>> (5 * 1000^2) * (60 * 60 * 2 * 30) / (8 * 1000^3) = 135 GB
>> -> 135 * 0.055 = 7.425 Euro/month
>> typical cost for midrange (ad-free) video streaming in france: 8-15 Euro
>> depending on the reference contract tier, the tax almost as large as the total revenue, no way this could be priced-in without significant price increases.
>> The proposed tax indeed seems quite steep, however it is capped at 15% of revenue in france or 2% of world-wide revenue
>> So that would get this more in like with a 15% tax... on revenue, still nothing to sneeze at, but a far cry from the numbers one gets when simply multiplying...
>> Regards
>> Sebastian
>> P.S.: My take this is half-baked and will not make it through the further legislative process in that form.
>>> It goes against how we agree to use the Internet.
>>>
>>> English version:
>>> "France has recently approved a highly controversial "Internet Traffic
>>> Tax" (or Gigabyte Tax) as part of the 2027 budget bill amendments. The
>>> new levy targets digital content providers based on the volume of data
>>> they transmit to French internet users, which is monitored by network
>>> operators and Internet Service Providers (ISPs) heavily utilizing
>>> Internet Exchange Points like France-IX."
>>>
>>> Google AI summary:
>>> "Key Metrics & Tax Rates
>>> • €0.055 per gigabyte charged to content providers.
>>> • Capped at 15% of a provider's French revenue.
>>> • Capped at 2% of a provider's global revenue.
>>> • Measured directly by French network operators and ISPs."
>>>
>>>
>>> On 2026-10-31 13:56, Frantisek Borsik wrote:
>>>> Crossposting, because this garbage idea might "inspire" more countries
>>>> and
>>>> have a horrible impact also on bufferbloat everywhere.
>>>>
>>>> *Original post by Dr. Peering:*
>>>>
>>>> *"The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own
>>>> country
>>>> by taxing Gigabits. Here’s Octave Klaba's excellent analysis [in
>>>> French,
>>>> link below] showing just how insane the finance bill actually is. The
>>>> IXP
>>>> taxation amount is, just for starters, ridiculous!"*
>>>>
>>>> https://x.com/drpeering/status/2116468659392807
>>>> <https://x.com/drpeering/status/2116468659392807381?a=E-elnbppn-MAi-LNIrU&s=46>
>>>>
>>>> *Octave's post:*
>>>>
>>>> https://fr.linkedin.com/posts/octave-klaba-3a0b3632_jai-lu-lamendement-i-1358-au-plf-2027-activity-7522219045576888320-uqkw
>>>>
>>>> *Copy+paste:*
>>>>
>>>> J'ai lu l'amendement I-1358 au PLF 2027, adopté ce vendredi à
>>>> l'Assemblée :
>>>> une taxe de 0,055 € par Go envoyé vers les abonnés des FAI français. Le
>>>> chiffre est abstrait, alors comparons-le. Corrigez-moi si vous voyez
>>>> des
>>>> erreurs.
>>>>
>>>> Deux comparaisons et un cas concret :
>>>>
>>>> 1. Le transit et le peering. Un port 100 Gbps coûte environ 6 300 € par
>>>> mois chez un fournisseur de transit mondial. En interconnexion directe
>>>> avec
>>>> un FAI européen, compter 3 à 5 fois plus, soit 20 à 30 k€ par mois. Sur
>>>> ce
>>>> port (a), la taxe atteint 1,02 M€ par mois, soit environ 3400 % à 16300
>>>> %
>>>> du prix d'une interconnexion vers les FAI français. On change donc
>>>> profondément le modèle économique de la bande passante en France.
>>>>
>>>> 2. Les hyperscalers sont critiqués pour le prix de leur trafic sortant,
>>>> qui
>>>> va d'environ 0,08€ à 0,045€ par Go selon le volume. La taxe, 0,055 €
>>>> par
>>>> Go, représente 68 % à 123 % de ce prix. On parle donc de doubler, pour
>>>> le
>>>> trafic vers la France, un prix déjà jugé trop élevé !
>>>>
>>>> 3. Le cas d'OVHcloud. Nous envoyons de l'ordre de 500 Gbps au 95e
>>>> percentile vers les FAI français, soit environ 324 Gbps en moyenne. Sur
>>>> un
>>>> an, la taxe brute atteindrait 70 M€. Le texte la plafonne à 15 % du CA
>>>> réalisé en France ou à 2 % du CA mondial, soit entre environ 23 et 70
>>>> M€
>>>> par an que nous devrions collecter pour l'État, et donc répercuter sur
>>>> nos
>>>> clients.
>>>>
>>>> Conclusions :
>>>>
>>>> 1. Une taxe porte en général sur une petite fraction de son assiette.
>>>> Celle-ci vaut plus de 3000 % du coût du transit, et environ 100 % du
>>>> prix
>>>> public des hyperscalers. Rappelez-vous la loi SREN, votée pour
>>>> supprimer
>>>> les frais de transfert qui empêchaient les clients de quitter un
>>>> fournisseur cloud. Ici, on parle de doubler le prix du trafic sortant
>>>> vers
>>>> les internautes français, un prix déjà très problématique.
>>>>
>>>> 2. Le garde-fou, un plafond calculé sur le chiffre d'affaires, est
>>>> incohérent. Ce chiffre d'affaires couvre des serveurs, du stockage, des
>>>> datacenters et des équipes sans rapport avec la bande passante. C'est
>>>> comme
>>>> créer une taxe calculée sur la consommation électrique des usines
>>>> automobiles en France, plafonnée à 15 % du chiffre d'affaires des
>>>> constructeurs. Quel rapport entre les deux ?
>>>>
>>>> 3. Une taxe nationale de ce type frappe à coup sûr les entreprises
>>>> établies
>>>> en France, alors que leurs concurrents mondiaux sans présence en France
>>>> livrent le même trafic aux mêmes FAI français sans payer cette taxe en
>>>> pratique. Cela crée une distorsion de concurrence au détriment des
>>>> acteurs
>>>> nationaux et déclasse les entreprises qui embauchent en France. Une
>>>> taxe
>>>> qui produit l'effet inverse serait une meilleure approche.
>>>>
>>>> (a) Facturé au 95e percentile, ce port n'est pas plein en permanence :
>>>> avec
>>>> un profil journalier type (22 % vers 4 h, 90 % vers 21 h), il
>>>> transporte en
>>>> moyenne 57 % de sa capacité, soit 18,6 millions de Go par mois.
>>>>
>>>>
>>>> All the best,
>>>>
>>>> Frank
>>>> Frantisek (Frank) Borsik
>>>>
>>>> In loving memory of Dave Täht: 1965-2025
>>>> https://libreqos.io/2025/04/01/in-loving-memory-of-dave/
>>>>
>>>>
>>>> https://www.linkedin.com/in/frantisekborsik
>>>> Signal, Telegram, WhatsApp: +421919416714 <+421%20919%20416%20714>
>>>> iMessage, mobile: +420775230885 <775%20230%20885>
>>>> Skype: casioa5302ca
>>>> frantisek.borsik@gmail.com
>>>> _______________________________________________
>>>> Bloat mailing list -- bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net
>>>> To unsubscribe send an email to bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
>>> _______________________________________________
>>> Bloat mailing list -- bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net
>>> To unsubscribe send an email to bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
>>> _______________________________________________
>>> Bloat mailing list -- bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net
>>> To unsubscribe send an email to bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
>> _______________________________________________
>> Nnagain mailing list -- nnagain@lists.bufferbloat.net
>> To unsubscribe send an email to nnagain-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
>
> --
> Sascha Meinrath
> Director, X-Lab
> Palmer Chair in Telecommunications
> Penn State University
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 40+ messages in thread
* [Starlink] Re: [NNagain] [Bloat] The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering)
2026-11-04 15:40 ` [Starlink] Re: [NNagain] " Sebastian Moeller
@ 2026-11-04 16:20 ` Sascha Meinrath
2026-11-04 17:03 ` Sebastian Moeller
0 siblings, 1 reply; 40+ messages in thread
From: Sascha Meinrath @ 2026-11-04 16:20 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: Sebastian Moeller
Cc: Network Neutrality is back! Let´s make the technical aspects heard this time!,
Michael Welzl, Frantisek Borsik, Dave Taht via Starlink, bloat,
Cake List, libreqos, Jeremy Austin via Rpm
Hi Sebastian,
My point is that if I VPNed to a point outside France, then a French ISP would
have no way to know that I've accessed the type of media that should be taxed.
In essence, VPNs (and proxy services) would create extraordinary problems for
even instrumenting the proposed taxing regime.
--Sascha
On 11/4/26 10:40 AM, Sebastian Moeller wrote:
> Hi Sascha,
>
>
>> On Nov 2, 2026, at 15:30, Sascha Meinrath <sascha@thexlab.org> wrote:
>>
>> I can't wait until the French Parliament learns about VPNs... It would be absolutely *wonderful* if all the ISPs passed along the tax to their customers... and then taught all their customers that VPNed traffic would, for obvious reasons, be exempted.
>
> Not how this is supposed to work: the ISP aggregates its end-customer bound traffic volume by ASN and reports these aggregates quarterly, the tax office sends the ASNs the tax bill. VPN does not really matter, except now it is the VPN provider that is on the hook for the money. The amendment does not address VPNs but for CDNs that are in a similar picckle the idea is that CDN operators either pass on the cost or "eat" it themselves (both half-baked ideas). The only oddity VPNs add is that they typically receive no money from the actual content providers, but the end users.
>
>>
>> I find proposals like this to be absolutely idiotic -- and, they are yet another step in the global data obfuscation arms race.
>
> Oh, that proposal is pretty half-baked, no arggument there, but I think we differ in which of its half-baked-ness we consider worst ;)
>
>>
>> #encrypteverything
>
> Well, if you look what this is supposed to operate on encryption is not really an option, as this operates on source and destination IP addresses, that are somewhat prickly to encrypt if you want packets delivered...
>
>>
>> --Sascha
>>
>> On 11/2/26 6:23 AM, Sebastian Moeller via Nnagain wrote:
>>> Hi Michael,
>>>> On Nov 2, 2026, at 08:44, Michael Welzl <michawe@ifi.uio.no> wrote:
>>>>
>>>> The tax is 5 cents per Gigabyte. This is insane.
>>> Back of the envelop calculations for video streaming (assuming this to be the one category driving most of the sustained capacity usage):
>>> common use seems to be HD streaming (say on average at 5 Mbps), with say 2 hours per day, 7 days per week:
>>> (5 * 1000^2) * (60 * 60 * 2 * 30) / (8 * 1000^3) = 135 GB
>>> -> 135 * 0.055 = 7.425 Euro/month
>>> typical cost for midrange (ad-free) video streaming in france: 8-15 Euro
>>> depending on the reference contract tier, the tax almost as large as the total revenue, no way this could be priced-in without significant price increases.
>>> The proposed tax indeed seems quite steep, however it is capped at 15% of revenue in france or 2% of world-wide revenue
>>> So that would get this more in like with a 15% tax... on revenue, still nothing to sneeze at, but a far cry from the numbers one gets when simply multiplying...
>>> Regards
>>> Sebastian
>>> P.S.: My take this is half-baked and will not make it through the further legislative process in that form.
>>>> It goes against how we agree to use the Internet.
>>>>
>>>> English version:
>>>> "France has recently approved a highly controversial "Internet Traffic
>>>> Tax" (or Gigabyte Tax) as part of the 2027 budget bill amendments. The
>>>> new levy targets digital content providers based on the volume of data
>>>> they transmit to French internet users, which is monitored by network
>>>> operators and Internet Service Providers (ISPs) heavily utilizing
>>>> Internet Exchange Points like France-IX."
>>>>
>>>> Google AI summary:
>>>> "Key Metrics & Tax Rates
>>>> • €0.055 per gigabyte charged to content providers.
>>>> • Capped at 15% of a provider's French revenue.
>>>> • Capped at 2% of a provider's global revenue.
>>>> • Measured directly by French network operators and ISPs."
>>>>
>>>>
>>>> On 2026-10-31 13:56, Frantisek Borsik wrote:
>>>>> Crossposting, because this garbage idea might "inspire" more countries
>>>>> and
>>>>> have a horrible impact also on bufferbloat everywhere.
>>>>>
>>>>> *Original post by Dr. Peering:*
>>>>>
>>>>> *"The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own
>>>>> country
>>>>> by taxing Gigabits. Here’s Octave Klaba's excellent analysis [in
>>>>> French,
>>>>> link below] showing just how insane the finance bill actually is. The
>>>>> IXP
>>>>> taxation amount is, just for starters, ridiculous!"*
>>>>>
>>>>> https://x.com/drpeering/status/2116468659392807
>>>>> <https://x.com/drpeering/status/2116468659392807381?a=E-elnbppn-MAi-LNIrU&s=46>
>>>>>
>>>>> *Octave's post:*
>>>>>
>>>>> https://fr.linkedin.com/posts/octave-klaba-3a0b3632_jai-lu-lamendement-i-1358-au-plf-2027-activity-7522219045576888320-uqkw
>>>>>
>>>>> *Copy+paste:*
>>>>>
>>>>> J'ai lu l'amendement I-1358 au PLF 2027, adopté ce vendredi à
>>>>> l'Assemblée :
>>>>> une taxe de 0,055 € par Go envoyé vers les abonnés des FAI français. Le
>>>>> chiffre est abstrait, alors comparons-le. Corrigez-moi si vous voyez
>>>>> des
>>>>> erreurs.
>>>>>
>>>>> Deux comparaisons et un cas concret :
>>>>>
>>>>> 1. Le transit et le peering. Un port 100 Gbps coûte environ 6 300 € par
>>>>> mois chez un fournisseur de transit mondial. En interconnexion directe
>>>>> avec
>>>>> un FAI européen, compter 3 à 5 fois plus, soit 20 à 30 k€ par mois. Sur
>>>>> ce
>>>>> port (a), la taxe atteint 1,02 M€ par mois, soit environ 3400 % à 16300
>>>>> %
>>>>> du prix d'une interconnexion vers les FAI français. On change donc
>>>>> profondément le modèle économique de la bande passante en France.
>>>>>
>>>>> 2. Les hyperscalers sont critiqués pour le prix de leur trafic sortant,
>>>>> qui
>>>>> va d'environ 0,08€ à 0,045€ par Go selon le volume. La taxe, 0,055 €
>>>>> par
>>>>> Go, représente 68 % à 123 % de ce prix. On parle donc de doubler, pour
>>>>> le
>>>>> trafic vers la France, un prix déjà jugé trop élevé !
>>>>>
>>>>> 3. Le cas d'OVHcloud. Nous envoyons de l'ordre de 500 Gbps au 95e
>>>>> percentile vers les FAI français, soit environ 324 Gbps en moyenne. Sur
>>>>> un
>>>>> an, la taxe brute atteindrait 70 M€. Le texte la plafonne à 15 % du CA
>>>>> réalisé en France ou à 2 % du CA mondial, soit entre environ 23 et 70
>>>>> M€
>>>>> par an que nous devrions collecter pour l'État, et donc répercuter sur
>>>>> nos
>>>>> clients.
>>>>>
>>>>> Conclusions :
>>>>>
>>>>> 1. Une taxe porte en général sur une petite fraction de son assiette.
>>>>> Celle-ci vaut plus de 3000 % du coût du transit, et environ 100 % du
>>>>> prix
>>>>> public des hyperscalers. Rappelez-vous la loi SREN, votée pour
>>>>> supprimer
>>>>> les frais de transfert qui empêchaient les clients de quitter un
>>>>> fournisseur cloud. Ici, on parle de doubler le prix du trafic sortant
>>>>> vers
>>>>> les internautes français, un prix déjà très problématique.
>>>>>
>>>>> 2. Le garde-fou, un plafond calculé sur le chiffre d'affaires, est
>>>>> incohérent. Ce chiffre d'affaires couvre des serveurs, du stockage, des
>>>>> datacenters et des équipes sans rapport avec la bande passante. C'est
>>>>> comme
>>>>> créer une taxe calculée sur la consommation électrique des usines
>>>>> automobiles en France, plafonnée à 15 % du chiffre d'affaires des
>>>>> constructeurs. Quel rapport entre les deux ?
>>>>>
>>>>> 3. Une taxe nationale de ce type frappe à coup sûr les entreprises
>>>>> établies
>>>>> en France, alors que leurs concurrents mondiaux sans présence en France
>>>>> livrent le même trafic aux mêmes FAI français sans payer cette taxe en
>>>>> pratique. Cela crée une distorsion de concurrence au détriment des
>>>>> acteurs
>>>>> nationaux et déclasse les entreprises qui embauchent en France. Une
>>>>> taxe
>>>>> qui produit l'effet inverse serait une meilleure approche.
>>>>>
>>>>> (a) Facturé au 95e percentile, ce port n'est pas plein en permanence :
>>>>> avec
>>>>> un profil journalier type (22 % vers 4 h, 90 % vers 21 h), il
>>>>> transporte en
>>>>> moyenne 57 % de sa capacité, soit 18,6 millions de Go par mois.
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>> All the best,
>>>>>
>>>>> Frank
>>>>> Frantisek (Frank) Borsik
>>>>>
>>>>> In loving memory of Dave Täht: 1965-2025
>>>>> https://libreqos.io/2025/04/01/in-loving-memory-of-dave/
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>> https://www.linkedin.com/in/frantisekborsik
>>>>> Signal, Telegram, WhatsApp: +421919416714 <+421%20919%20416%20714>
>>>>> iMessage, mobile: +420775230885 <775%20230%20885>
>>>>> Skype: casioa5302ca
>>>>> frantisek.borsik@gmail.com
>>>>> _______________________________________________
>>>>> Bloat mailing list -- bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net
>>>>> To unsubscribe send an email to bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
>>>> _______________________________________________
>>>> Bloat mailing list -- bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net
>>>> To unsubscribe send an email to bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
>>>> _______________________________________________
>>>> Bloat mailing list -- bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net
>>>> To unsubscribe send an email to bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
>>> _______________________________________________
>>> Nnagain mailing list -- nnagain@lists.bufferbloat.net
>>> To unsubscribe send an email to nnagain-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
>>
>> --
>> Sascha Meinrath
>> Director, X-Lab
>> Palmer Chair in Telecommunications
>> Penn State University
>
>
--
Sascha Meinrath
Director, X-Lab
Palmer Chair in Telecommunications
Penn State University
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 40+ messages in thread
* [Starlink] Re: [NNagain] [Bloat] The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering)
2026-11-04 16:20 ` Sascha Meinrath
@ 2026-11-04 17:03 ` Sebastian Moeller
2026-11-04 17:57 ` [Starlink] Re: [Cake] " David P. Reed
2026-11-04 18:33 ` [Starlink] " Sascha Meinrath
0 siblings, 2 replies; 40+ messages in thread
From: Sebastian Moeller @ 2026-11-04 17:03 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: sascha, Sascha Meinrath
Cc: Network Neutrality is back! Let´s make the technical aspects heard this time!,
Michael Welzl, Frantisek Borsik, Dave Taht via Starlink, bloat,
Cake List, libreqos, Jeremy Austin via Rpm
Hi Sascha,
On November 4, 2026 5:20:01 PM GMT+01:00, Sascha Meinrath <sascha@thexlab.org> wrote:
>Hi Sebastian,
>
>My point is that if I VPNed to a point outside France, then a French ISP would have no way to know that I've accessed the type of media that should be taxed.
A misunderstanding, the amendment prposes to tax every single bit independent of the source... it makes zero exemptions, not for FOSS, not for non commercially ial entities. Sure the motivation is to tax big tech primarily, but the current (half-baked) legal implementation is not differentiating...
> In essence, VPNs (and proxy services) would create extraordinary problems for even instrumenting the proposed taxing regime.
How? Like with a CDN the tax would hit the vpn provider... the ASN of the source IP....
>
>--Sascha
>
>On 11/4/26 10:40 AM, Sebastian Moeller wrote:
>> Hi Sascha,
>>
>>
>>> On Nov 2, 2026, at 15:30, Sascha Meinrath <sascha@thexlab.org> wrote:
>>>
>>> I can't wait until the French Parliament learns about VPNs... It would be absolutely *wonderful* if all the ISPs passed along the tax to their customers... and then taught all their customers that VPNed traffic would, for obvious reasons, be exempted.
>>
>> Not how this is supposed to work: the ISP aggregates its end-customer bound traffic volume by ASN and reports these aggregates quarterly, the tax office sends the ASNs the tax bill. VPN does not really matter, except now it is the VPN provider that is on the hook for the money. The amendment does not address VPNs but for CDNs that are in a similar picckle the idea is that CDN operators either pass on the cost or "eat" it themselves (both half-baked ideas). The only oddity VPNs add is that they typically receive no money from the actual content providers, but the end users.
>>
>>>
>>> I find proposals like this to be absolutely idiotic -- and, they are yet another step in the global data obfuscation arms race.
>>
>> Oh, that proposal is pretty half-baked, no arggument there, but I think we differ in which of its half-baked-ness we consider worst ;)
>>
>>>
>>> #encrypteverything
>>
>> Well, if you look what this is supposed to operate on encryption is not really an option, as this operates on source and destination IP addresses, that are somewhat prickly to encrypt if you want packets delivered...
>>
>>>
>>> --Sascha
>>>
>>> On 11/2/26 6:23 AM, Sebastian Moeller via Nnagain wrote:
>>>> Hi Michael,
>>>>> On Nov 2, 2026, at 08:44, Michael Welzl <michawe@ifi.uio.no> wrote:
>>>>>
>>>>> The tax is 5 cents per Gigabyte. This is insane.
>>>> Back of the envelop calculations for video streaming (assuming this to be the one category driving most of the sustained capacity usage):
>>>> common use seems to be HD streaming (say on average at 5 Mbps), with say 2 hours per day, 7 days per week:
>>>> (5 * 1000^2) * (60 * 60 * 2 * 30) / (8 * 1000^3) = 135 GB
>>>> -> 135 * 0.055 = 7.425 Euro/month
>>>> typical cost for midrange (ad-free) video streaming in france: 8-15 Euro
>>>> depending on the reference contract tier, the tax almost as large as the total revenue, no way this could be priced-in without significant price increases.
>>>> The proposed tax indeed seems quite steep, however it is capped at 15% of revenue in france or 2% of world-wide revenue
>>>> So that would get this more in like with a 15% tax... on revenue, still nothing to sneeze at, but a far cry from the numbers one gets when simply multiplying...
>>>> Regards
>>>> Sebastian
>>>> P.S.: My take this is half-baked and will not make it through the further legislative process in that form.
>>>>> It goes against how we agree to use the Internet.
>>>>>
>>>>> English version:
>>>>> "France has recently approved a highly controversial "Internet Traffic
>>>>> Tax" (or Gigabyte Tax) as part of the 2027 budget bill amendments. The
>>>>> new levy targets digital content providers based on the volume of data
>>>>> they transmit to French internet users, which is monitored by network
>>>>> operators and Internet Service Providers (ISPs) heavily utilizing
>>>>> Internet Exchange Points like France-IX."
>>>>>
>>>>> Google AI summary:
>>>>> "Key Metrics & Tax Rates
>>>>> • €0.055 per gigabyte charged to content providers.
>>>>> • Capped at 15% of a provider's French revenue.
>>>>> • Capped at 2% of a provider's global revenue.
>>>>> • Measured directly by French network operators and ISPs."
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>> On 2026-10-31 13:56, Frantisek Borsik wrote:
>>>>>> Crossposting, because this garbage idea might "inspire" more countries
>>>>>> and
>>>>>> have a horrible impact also on bufferbloat everywhere.
>>>>>>
>>>>>> *Original post by Dr. Peering:*
>>>>>>
>>>>>> *"The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own
>>>>>> country
>>>>>> by taxing Gigabits. Here’s Octave Klaba's excellent analysis [in
>>>>>> French,
>>>>>> link below] showing just how insane the finance bill actually is. The
>>>>>> IXP
>>>>>> taxation amount is, just for starters, ridiculous!"*
>>>>>>
>>>>>> https://x.com/drpeering/status/2116468659392807
>>>>>> <https://x.com/drpeering/status/2116468659392807381?a=E-elnbppn-MAi-LNIrU&s=46>
>>>>>>
>>>>>> *Octave's post:*
>>>>>>
>>>>>> https://fr.linkedin.com/posts/octave-klaba-3a0b3632_jai-lu-lamendement-i-1358-au-plf-2027-activity-7522219045576888320-uqkw
>>>>>>
>>>>>> *Copy+paste:*
>>>>>>
>>>>>> J'ai lu l'amendement I-1358 au PLF 2027, adopté ce vendredi à
>>>>>> l'Assemblée :
>>>>>> une taxe de 0,055 € par Go envoyé vers les abonnés des FAI français. Le
>>>>>> chiffre est abstrait, alors comparons-le. Corrigez-moi si vous voyez
>>>>>> des
>>>>>> erreurs.
>>>>>>
>>>>>> Deux comparaisons et un cas concret :
>>>>>>
>>>>>> 1. Le transit et le peering. Un port 100 Gbps coûte environ 6 300 € par
>>>>>> mois chez un fournisseur de transit mondial. En interconnexion directe
>>>>>> avec
>>>>>> un FAI européen, compter 3 à 5 fois plus, soit 20 à 30 k€ par mois. Sur
>>>>>> ce
>>>>>> port (a), la taxe atteint 1,02 M€ par mois, soit environ 3400 % à 16300
>>>>>> %
>>>>>> du prix d'une interconnexion vers les FAI français. On change donc
>>>>>> profondément le modèle économique de la bande passante en France.
>>>>>>
>>>>>> 2. Les hyperscalers sont critiqués pour le prix de leur trafic sortant,
>>>>>> qui
>>>>>> va d'environ 0,08€ à 0,045€ par Go selon le volume. La taxe, 0,055 €
>>>>>> par
>>>>>> Go, représente 68 % à 123 % de ce prix. On parle donc de doubler, pour
>>>>>> le
>>>>>> trafic vers la France, un prix déjà jugé trop élevé !
>>>>>>
>>>>>> 3. Le cas d'OVHcloud. Nous envoyons de l'ordre de 500 Gbps au 95e
>>>>>> percentile vers les FAI français, soit environ 324 Gbps en moyenne. Sur
>>>>>> un
>>>>>> an, la taxe brute atteindrait 70 M€. Le texte la plafonne à 15 % du CA
>>>>>> réalisé en France ou à 2 % du CA mondial, soit entre environ 23 et 70
>>>>>> M€
>>>>>> par an que nous devrions collecter pour l'État, et donc répercuter sur
>>>>>> nos
>>>>>> clients.
>>>>>>
>>>>>> Conclusions :
>>>>>>
>>>>>> 1. Une taxe porte en général sur une petite fraction de son assiette.
>>>>>> Celle-ci vaut plus de 3000 % du coût du transit, et environ 100 % du
>>>>>> prix
>>>>>> public des hyperscalers. Rappelez-vous la loi SREN, votée pour
>>>>>> supprimer
>>>>>> les frais de transfert qui empêchaient les clients de quitter un
>>>>>> fournisseur cloud. Ici, on parle de doubler le prix du trafic sortant
>>>>>> vers
>>>>>> les internautes français, un prix déjà très problématique.
>>>>>>
>>>>>> 2. Le garde-fou, un plafond calculé sur le chiffre d'affaires, est
>>>>>> incohérent. Ce chiffre d'affaires couvre des serveurs, du stockage, des
>>>>>> datacenters et des équipes sans rapport avec la bande passante. C'est
>>>>>> comme
>>>>>> créer une taxe calculée sur la consommation électrique des usines
>>>>>> automobiles en France, plafonnée à 15 % du chiffre d'affaires des
>>>>>> constructeurs. Quel rapport entre les deux ?
>>>>>>
>>>>>> 3. Une taxe nationale de ce type frappe à coup sûr les entreprises
>>>>>> établies
>>>>>> en France, alors que leurs concurrents mondiaux sans présence en France
>>>>>> livrent le même trafic aux mêmes FAI français sans payer cette taxe en
>>>>>> pratique. Cela crée une distorsion de concurrence au détriment des
>>>>>> acteurs
>>>>>> nationaux et déclasse les entreprises qui embauchent en France. Une
>>>>>> taxe
>>>>>> qui produit l'effet inverse serait une meilleure approche.
>>>>>>
>>>>>> (a) Facturé au 95e percentile, ce port n'est pas plein en permanence :
>>>>>> avec
>>>>>> un profil journalier type (22 % vers 4 h, 90 % vers 21 h), il
>>>>>> transporte en
>>>>>> moyenne 57 % de sa capacité, soit 18,6 millions de Go par mois.
>>>>>>
>>>>>>
>>>>>> All the best,
>>>>>>
>>>>>> Frank
>>>>>> Frantisek (Frank) Borsik
>>>>>>
>>>>>> In loving memory of Dave Täht: 1965-2025
>>>>>> https://libreqos.io/2025/04/01/in-loving-memory-of-dave/
>>>>>>
>>>>>>
>>>>>> https://www.linkedin.com/in/frantisekborsik
>>>>>> Signal, Telegram, WhatsApp: +421919416714 <+421%20919%20416%20714>
>>>>>> iMessage, mobile: +420775230885 <775%20230%20885>
>>>>>> Skype: casioa5302ca
>>>>>> frantisek.borsik@gmail.com
>>>>>> _______________________________________________
>>>>>> Bloat mailing list -- bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net
>>>>>> To unsubscribe send an email to bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
>>>>> _______________________________________________
>>>>> Bloat mailing list -- bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net
>>>>> To unsubscribe send an email to bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
>>>>> _______________________________________________
>>>>> Bloat mailing list -- bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net
>>>>> To unsubscribe send an email to bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
>>>> _______________________________________________
>>>> Nnagain mailing list -- nnagain@lists.bufferbloat.net
>>>> To unsubscribe send an email to nnagain-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
>>>
>>> --
>>> Sascha Meinrath
>>> Director, X-Lab
>>> Palmer Chair in Telecommunications
>>> Penn State University
>>
>>
>
--
Sent from my Android device with K-9 Mail. Please excuse my brevity.
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 40+ messages in thread
* [Starlink] Re: [Cake] Re: [NNagain] [Bloat] The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering)
2026-11-04 17:03 ` Sebastian Moeller
@ 2026-11-04 17:57 ` David P. Reed
2026-11-05 9:05 ` [Starlink] Re: [Cake] " Sebastian Moeller
2026-11-18 7:48 ` [Starlink] Re: [Cake] Re: [NNagain] [Bloat] " Frantisek Borsik
2026-11-04 18:33 ` [Starlink] " Sascha Meinrath
1 sibling, 2 replies; 40+ messages in thread
From: David P. Reed @ 2026-11-04 17:57 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: Sebastian Moeller
Cc: sascha, Sascha Meinrath,
Network Neutrality is back! Let´s make the technical aspects heard this time!,
Michael Welzl, Frantisek Borsik, Dave Taht via Starlink, bloat,
Cake List, libreqos, Jeremy Austin via Rpm
Sascha, et al. -
The law is never about "how will we enforce it", because (sarcasm on) such petty details as enforcement is not germane to Governments' Will to Control (sarcasm off).
When they try to dream up "technical means" for enforcement, rather than just putting the law on the books, they may all of a sudden try to interfere with all kinds of Internet mechanisms. This won't be easy, but we have the history of Thought Control starting with the early Internet deployments where the words "breast" and so forth were supposed to be detected by all Internet routers in all packets. Senator Exon of the US got some "tech pundits" to say that was possible and easy, and I got involved politically to suppress the "Exon Box" idea, which was politically gaining steam, even among "progressives.:
The issue, of course, is that the legislators invent dynamite-scale enforcement mechanisms that interfere with every damn thing in order to solve a pretty narrow problem.
Note that the Post Office in most countries are NOT allowed to inspect all letters and packages. But the fascist instinct exists everywhere, even France. "There oughta be a law" is what voters first turn to, both on the Left and the RIght - which is why just saying "The Rule of Law" is not equivalent to democracy.
If you want to charge a tax on a behavior of a consumer, you basically need to surveill actual consumption by each individual, which is not technically feasible. No more than enforcing a law that says you can't listen to the words of Islam or read Mein Kampf.
I don't get really upset about this until the Tax Policy starts to move to an implementation that destroys our rights to privacy (meaning the right to be left alone, not the right to keep data secret).
On Wednesday, November 4, 2026 12:03, "Sebastian Moeller via Cake" <cake@lists.bufferbloat.net> said:
> Hi Sascha,
>
> On November 4, 2026 5:20:01 PM GMT+01:00, Sascha Meinrath
> <sascha@thexlab.org> wrote:
> >Hi Sebastian,
> >
> >My point is that if I VPNed to a point outside France, then a French ISP would
> have no way to know that I've accessed the type of media that should be taxed.
>
>
> A misunderstanding, the amendment prposes to tax every single bit independent of
> the source... it makes zero exemptions, not for FOSS, not for non commercially ial
> entities. Sure the motivation is to tax big tech primarily, but the current
> (half-baked) legal implementation is not differentiating...
>
>
> > In essence, VPNs (and proxy services) would create extraordinary problems for
> even instrumenting the proposed taxing regime.
>
> How? Like with a CDN the tax would hit the vpn provider... the ASN of the source
> IP....
>
>
>
>
> >
> >--Sascha
> >
> >On 11/4/26 10:40 AM, Sebastian Moeller wrote:
> >> Hi Sascha,
> >>
> >>
> >>> On Nov 2, 2026, at 15:30, Sascha Meinrath <sascha@thexlab.org>
> wrote:
> >>>
> >>> I can't wait until the French Parliament learns about VPNs... It
> would be absolutely *wonderful* if all the ISPs passed along the tax to their
> customers... and then taught all their customers that VPNed traffic would, for
> obvious reasons, be exempted.
> >>
> >> Not how this is supposed to work: the ISP aggregates its end-customer
> bound traffic volume by ASN and reports these aggregates quarterly, the tax office
> sends the ASNs the tax bill. VPN does not really matter, except now it is the VPN
> provider that is on the hook for the money. The amendment does not address VPNs
> but for CDNs that are in a similar picckle the idea is that CDN operators either
> pass on the cost or "eat" it themselves (both half-baked ideas). The only oddity
> VPNs add is that they typically receive no money from the actual content
> providers, but the end users.
> >>
> >>>
> >>> I find proposals like this to be absolutely idiotic -- and, they are
> yet another step in the global data obfuscation arms race.
> >>
> >> Oh, that proposal is pretty half-baked, no arggument there, but I think
> we differ in which of its half-baked-ness we consider worst ;)
> >>
> >>>
> >>> #encrypteverything
> >>
> >> Well, if you look what this is supposed to operate on encryption is not
> really an option, as this operates on source and destination IP addresses, that
> are somewhat prickly to encrypt if you want packets delivered...
> >>
> >>>
> >>> --Sascha
> >>>
> >>> On 11/2/26 6:23 AM, Sebastian Moeller via Nnagain wrote:
> >>>> Hi Michael,
> >>>>> On Nov 2, 2026, at 08:44, Michael Welzl
> <michawe@ifi.uio.no> wrote:
> >>>>>
> >>>>> The tax is 5 cents per Gigabyte. This is insane.
> >>>> Back of the envelop calculations for video streaming (assuming
> this to be the one category driving most of the sustained capacity usage):
> >>>> common use seems to be HD streaming (say on average at 5 Mbps),
> with say 2 hours per day, 7 days per week:
> >>>> (5 * 1000^2) * (60 * 60 * 2 * 30) / (8 * 1000^3) = 135 GB
> >>>> -> 135 * 0.055 = 7.425 Euro/month
> >>>> typical cost for midrange (ad-free) video streaming in france:
> 8-15 Euro
> >>>> depending on the reference contract tier, the tax almost as large
> as the total revenue, no way this could be priced-in without significant price
> increases.
> >>>> The proposed tax indeed seems quite steep, however it is capped
> at 15% of revenue in france or 2% of world-wide revenue
> >>>> So that would get this more in like with a 15% tax... on revenue,
> still nothing to sneeze at, but a far cry from the numbers one gets when simply
> multiplying...
> >>>> Regards
> >>>> Sebastian
> >>>> P.S.: My take this is half-baked and will not make it through the
> further legislative process in that form.
> >>>>> It goes against how we agree to use the Internet.
> >>>>>
> >>>>> English version:
> >>>>> "France has recently approved a highly controversial
> "Internet Traffic
> >>>>> Tax" (or Gigabyte Tax) as part of the 2027 budget bill
> amendments. The
> >>>>> new levy targets digital content providers based on the
> volume of data
> >>>>> they transmit to French internet users, which is monitored by
> network
> >>>>> operators and Internet Service Providers (ISPs) heavily
> utilizing
> >>>>> Internet Exchange Points like France-IX."
> >>>>>
> >>>>> Google AI summary:
> >>>>> "Key Metrics & Tax Rates
> >>>>> • €0.055 per gigabyte charged to content
> providers.
> >>>>> • Capped at 15% of a provider's French revenue.
> >>>>> • Capped at 2% of a provider's global revenue.
> >>>>> • Measured directly by French network operators and
> ISPs."
> >>>>>
> >>>>>
> >>>>> On 2026-10-31 13:56, Frantisek Borsik wrote:
> >>>>>> Crossposting, because this garbage idea might "inspire"
> more countries
> >>>>>> and
> >>>>>> have a horrible impact also on bufferbloat everywhere.
> >>>>>>
> >>>>>> *Original post by Dr. Peering:*
> >>>>>>
> >>>>>> *"The French have decided to destroy the Internet within
> their own
> >>>>>> country
> >>>>>> by taxing Gigabits. Here’s Octave Klaba's excellent
> analysis [in
> >>>>>> French,
> >>>>>> link below] showing just how insane the finance bill
> actually is. The
> >>>>>> IXP
> >>>>>> taxation amount is, just for starters, ridiculous!"*
> >>>>>>
> >>>>>> https://x.com/drpeering/status/2116468659392807
> >>>>>>
> <https://x.com/drpeering/status/2116468659392807381?a=E-elnbppn-MAi-LNIrU&s=46>
> >>>>>>
> >>>>>> *Octave's post:*
> >>>>>>
> >>>>>>
> https://fr.linkedin.com/posts/octave-klaba-3a0b3632_jai-lu-lamendement-i-1358-au-plf-2027-activity-7522219045576888320-uqkw
> >>>>>>
> >>>>>> *Copy+paste:*
> >>>>>>
> >>>>>> J'ai lu l'amendement I-1358 au PLF 2027, adopté ce
> vendredi à
> >>>>>> l'Assemblée :
> >>>>>> une taxe de 0,055 € par Go envoyé vers les
> abonnés des FAI français. Le
> >>>>>> chiffre est abstrait, alors comparons-le. Corrigez-moi si
> vous voyez
> >>>>>> des
> >>>>>> erreurs.
> >>>>>>
> >>>>>> Deux comparaisons et un cas concret :
> >>>>>>
> >>>>>> 1. Le transit et le peering. Un port 100 Gbps coûte
> environ 6 300 € par
> >>>>>> mois chez un fournisseur de transit mondial. En
> interconnexion directe
> >>>>>> avec
> >>>>>> un FAI européen, compter 3 à 5 fois plus,
> soit 20 à 30 k€ par mois. Sur
> >>>>>> ce
> >>>>>> port (a), la taxe atteint 1,02 M€ par mois, soit
> environ 3400 % à 16300
> >>>>>> %
> >>>>>> du prix d'une interconnexion vers les FAI
> français. On change donc
> >>>>>> profondément le modèle économique de
> la bande passante en France.
> >>>>>>
> >>>>>> 2. Les hyperscalers sont critiqués pour le prix de
> leur trafic sortant,
> >>>>>> qui
> >>>>>> va d'environ 0,08€ à 0,045€ par Go selon
> le volume. La taxe, 0,055 €
> >>>>>> par
> >>>>>> Go, représente 68 % à 123 % de ce prix. On
> parle donc de doubler, pour
> >>>>>> le
> >>>>>> trafic vers la France, un prix déjà
> jugé trop élevé !
> >>>>>>
> >>>>>> 3. Le cas d'OVHcloud. Nous envoyons de l'ordre de 500
> Gbps au 95e
> >>>>>> percentile vers les FAI français, soit environ 324
> Gbps en moyenne. Sur
> >>>>>> un
> >>>>>> an, la taxe brute atteindrait 70 M€. Le texte la
> plafonne à 15 % du CA
> >>>>>> réalisé en France ou à 2 % du CA
> mondial, soit entre environ 23 et 70
> >>>>>> M€
> >>>>>> par an que nous devrions collecter pour l'État, et
> donc répercuter sur
> >>>>>> nos
> >>>>>> clients.
> >>>>>>
> >>>>>> Conclusions :
> >>>>>>
> >>>>>> 1. Une taxe porte en général sur une petite
> fraction de son assiette.
> >>>>>> Celle-ci vaut plus de 3000 % du coût du transit, et
> environ 100 % du
> >>>>>> prix
> >>>>>> public des hyperscalers. Rappelez-vous la loi SREN,
> votée pour
> >>>>>> supprimer
> >>>>>> les frais de transfert qui empêchaient les clients
> de quitter un
> >>>>>> fournisseur cloud. Ici, on parle de doubler le prix du
> trafic sortant
> >>>>>> vers
> >>>>>> les internautes français, un prix
> déjà très problématique.
> >>>>>>
> >>>>>> 2. Le garde-fou, un plafond calculé sur le chiffre
> d'affaires, est
> >>>>>> incohérent. Ce chiffre d'affaires couvre des
> serveurs, du stockage, des
> >>>>>> datacenters et des équipes sans rapport avec la
> bande passante. C'est
> >>>>>> comme
> >>>>>> créer une taxe calculée sur la consommation
> électrique des usines
> >>>>>> automobiles en France, plafonnée à 15 % du
> chiffre d'affaires des
> >>>>>> constructeurs. Quel rapport entre les deux ?
> >>>>>>
> >>>>>> 3. Une taxe nationale de ce type frappe à coup
> sûr les entreprises
> >>>>>> établies
> >>>>>> en France, alors que leurs concurrents mondiaux sans
> présence en France
> >>>>>> livrent le même trafic aux mêmes FAI
> français sans payer cette taxe en
> >>>>>> pratique. Cela crée une distorsion de concurrence
> au détriment des
> >>>>>> acteurs
> >>>>>> nationaux et déclasse les entreprises qui
> embauchent en France. Une
> >>>>>> taxe
> >>>>>> qui produit l'effet inverse serait une meilleure
> approche.
> >>>>>>
> >>>>>> (a) Facturé au 95e percentile, ce port n'est pas
> plein en permanence :
> >>>>>> avec
> >>>>>> un profil journalier type (22 % vers 4 h, 90 % vers 21
> h), il
> >>>>>> transporte en
> >>>>>> moyenne 57 % de sa capacité, soit 18,6 millions de
> Go par mois.
> >>>>>>
> >>>>>>
> >>>>>> All the best,
> >>>>>>
> >>>>>> Frank
> >>>>>> Frantisek (Frank) Borsik
> >>>>>>
> >>>>>> In loving memory of Dave Täht: 1965-2025
> >>>>>> https://libreqos.io/2025/04/01/in-loving-memory-of-dave/
> >>>>>>
> >>>>>>
> >>>>>> https://www.linkedin.com/in/frantisekborsik
> >>>>>> Signal, Telegram, WhatsApp: +421919416714
> <+421%20919%20416%20714>
> >>>>>> iMessage, mobile: +420775230885 <775%20230%20885>
> >>>>>> Skype: casioa5302ca
> >>>>>> frantisek.borsik@gmail.com
> >>>>>> _______________________________________________
> >>>>>> Bloat mailing list -- bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net
> >>>>>> To unsubscribe send an email to
> bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
> >>>>> _______________________________________________
> >>>>> Bloat mailing list -- bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net
> >>>>> To unsubscribe send an email to
> bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
> >>>>> _______________________________________________
> >>>>> Bloat mailing list -- bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net
> >>>>> To unsubscribe send an email to
> bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
> >>>> _______________________________________________
> >>>> Nnagain mailing list -- nnagain@lists.bufferbloat.net
> >>>> To unsubscribe send an email to
> nnagain-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
> >>>
> >>> --
> >>> Sascha Meinrath
> >>> Director, X-Lab
> >>> Palmer Chair in Telecommunications
> >>> Penn State University
> >>
> >>
> >
>
> --
> Sent from my Android device with K-9 Mail. Please excuse my brevity.
> _______________________________________________
> Cake mailing list -- cake@lists.bufferbloat.net
> To unsubscribe send an email to cake-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
>
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 40+ messages in thread
* [Starlink] Re: [NNagain] [Bloat] The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering)
2026-11-04 17:03 ` Sebastian Moeller
2026-11-04 17:57 ` [Starlink] Re: [Cake] " David P. Reed
@ 2026-11-04 18:33 ` Sascha Meinrath
2026-11-04 19:09 ` Sebastian Moeller
2026-11-18 7:49 ` [Starlink] Re: [NNagain] " Frantisek Borsik
1 sibling, 2 replies; 40+ messages in thread
From: Sascha Meinrath @ 2026-11-04 18:33 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: Sebastian Moeller
Cc: Network Neutrality is back! Let´s make the technical aspects heard this time!,
Michael Welzl, Frantisek Borsik, Dave Taht via Starlink, bloat,
Cake List, libreqos, Jeremy Austin via Rpm
On 11/4/26 12:03 PM, Sebastian Moeller wrote:> Hi Sascha,
>
> On November 4, 2026 5:20:01 PM GMT+01:00, Sascha Meinrath <sascha@thexlab.org> wrote:
>> Hi Sebastian,
>>
>> My point is that if I VPNed to a point outside France, then a French ISP would have no way to know that I've accessed the type of media that should be taxed.
>
> A misunderstanding, the amendment prposes to tax every single bit independent of the source... it makes zero exemptions, not for FOSS, not for non commercially ial entities. Sure the motivation is to tax big tech primarily, but the current (half-baked) legal implementation is not differentiating...
>
>> In essence, VPNs (and proxy services) would create extraordinary problems for even instrumenting the proposed taxing regime.
>
> How? Like with a CDN the tax would hit the vpn provider... the ASN of the source IP....
A VPN provider (at least any that I would recommend using) would not know the
content being VPNed. In essence, someone in France could VPN to a different
country; neither the ISP or the VPN provider would know the specific content
being accessed (Note: while some VPN's do track their users, none of the privacy
protecting ones would do so); meanwhile, the media company -- even assuming some
sort of extra-territorial leverage of French law outside of France -- may have
no idea that the end destination of the media in question is within France.
Long story short, neither the VPN provider, the French ISP, nor the media
company would necessarily know that a specific piece of media was destined for
consumption within France. This is, of course, exactly the conundrum facing
authoritarian and censorial regimes around the globe -- in this case, one is
dodging tax surveillance, but the technical underpinnings are very much the same.
All in all, a dumb & doomed (proposed) law.
--Sascha
>
>
>
>>
>> --Sascha
>>
>> On 11/4/26 10:40 AM, Sebastian Moeller wrote:
>>> Hi Sascha,
>>>
>>>
>>>> On Nov 2, 2026, at 15:30, Sascha Meinrath <sascha@thexlab.org> wrote:
>>>>
>>>> I can't wait until the French Parliament learns about VPNs... It would be absolutely *wonderful* if all the ISPs passed along the tax to their customers... and then taught all their customers that VPNed traffic would, for obvious reasons, be exempted.
>>>
>>> Not how this is supposed to work: the ISP aggregates its end-customer bound traffic volume by ASN and reports these aggregates quarterly, the tax office sends the ASNs the tax bill. VPN does not really matter, except now it is the VPN provider that is on the hook for the money. The amendment does not address VPNs but for CDNs that are in a similar picckle the idea is that CDN operators either pass on the cost or "eat" it themselves (both half-baked ideas). The only oddity VPNs add is that they typically receive no money from the actual content providers, but the end users.
>>>
>>>>
>>>> I find proposals like this to be absolutely idiotic -- and, they are yet another step in the global data obfuscation arms race.
>>>
>>> Oh, that proposal is pretty half-baked, no arggument there, but I think we differ in which of its half-baked-ness we consider worst ;)
>>>
>>>>
>>>> #encrypteverything
>>>
>>> Well, if you look what this is supposed to operate on encryption is not really an option, as this operates on source and destination IP addresses, that are somewhat prickly to encrypt if you want packets delivered...
>>>
>>>>
>>>> --Sascha
>>>>
>>>> On 11/2/26 6:23 AM, Sebastian Moeller via Nnagain wrote:
>>>>> Hi Michael,
>>>>>> On Nov 2, 2026, at 08:44, Michael Welzl <michawe@ifi.uio.no> wrote:
>>>>>>
>>>>>> The tax is 5 cents per Gigabyte. This is insane.
>>>>> Back of the envelop calculations for video streaming (assuming this to be the one category driving most of the sustained capacity usage):
>>>>> common use seems to be HD streaming (say on average at 5 Mbps), with say 2 hours per day, 7 days per week:
>>>>> (5 * 1000^2) * (60 * 60 * 2 * 30) / (8 * 1000^3) = 135 GB
>>>>> -> 135 * 0.055 = 7.425 Euro/month
>>>>> typical cost for midrange (ad-free) video streaming in france: 8-15 Euro
>>>>> depending on the reference contract tier, the tax almost as large as the total revenue, no way this could be priced-in without significant price increases.
>>>>> The proposed tax indeed seems quite steep, however it is capped at 15% of revenue in france or 2% of world-wide revenue
>>>>> So that would get this more in like with a 15% tax... on revenue, still nothing to sneeze at, but a far cry from the numbers one gets when simply multiplying...
>>>>> Regards
>>>>> Sebastian
>>>>> P.S.: My take this is half-baked and will not make it through the further legislative process in that form.
>>>>>> It goes against how we agree to use the Internet.
>>>>>>
>>>>>> English version:
>>>>>> "France has recently approved a highly controversial "Internet Traffic
>>>>>> Tax" (or Gigabyte Tax) as part of the 2027 budget bill amendments. The
>>>>>> new levy targets digital content providers based on the volume of data
>>>>>> they transmit to French internet users, which is monitored by network
>>>>>> operators and Internet Service Providers (ISPs) heavily utilizing
>>>>>> Internet Exchange Points like France-IX."
>>>>>>
>>>>>> Google AI summary:
>>>>>> "Key Metrics & Tax Rates
>>>>>> • €0.055 per gigabyte charged to content providers.
>>>>>> • Capped at 15% of a provider's French revenue.
>>>>>> • Capped at 2% of a provider's global revenue.
>>>>>> • Measured directly by French network operators and ISPs."
>>>>>>
>>>>>>
>>>>>> On 2026-10-31 13:56, Frantisek Borsik wrote:
>>>>>>> Crossposting, because this garbage idea might "inspire" more countries
>>>>>>> and
>>>>>>> have a horrible impact also on bufferbloat everywhere.
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> *Original post by Dr. Peering:*
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> *"The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own
>>>>>>> country
>>>>>>> by taxing Gigabits. Here’s Octave Klaba's excellent analysis [in
>>>>>>> French,
>>>>>>> link below] showing just how insane the finance bill actually is. The
>>>>>>> IXP
>>>>>>> taxation amount is, just for starters, ridiculous!"*
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> https://x.com/drpeering/status/2116468659392807
>>>>>>> <https://x.com/drpeering/status/2116468659392807381?a=E-elnbppn-MAi-LNIrU&s=46>
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> *Octave's post:*
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> https://fr.linkedin.com/posts/octave-klaba-3a0b3632_jai-lu-lamendement-i-1358-au-plf-2027-activity-7522219045576888320-uqkw
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> *Copy+paste:*
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> J'ai lu l'amendement I-1358 au PLF 2027, adopté ce vendredi à
>>>>>>> l'Assemblée :
>>>>>>> une taxe de 0,055 € par Go envoyé vers les abonnés des FAI français. Le
>>>>>>> chiffre est abstrait, alors comparons-le. Corrigez-moi si vous voyez
>>>>>>> des
>>>>>>> erreurs.
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> Deux comparaisons et un cas concret :
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> 1. Le transit et le peering. Un port 100 Gbps coûte environ 6 300 € par
>>>>>>> mois chez un fournisseur de transit mondial. En interconnexion directe
>>>>>>> avec
>>>>>>> un FAI européen, compter 3 à 5 fois plus, soit 20 à 30 k€ par mois. Sur
>>>>>>> ce
>>>>>>> port (a), la taxe atteint 1,02 M€ par mois, soit environ 3400 % à 16300
>>>>>>> %
>>>>>>> du prix d'une interconnexion vers les FAI français. On change donc
>>>>>>> profondément le modèle économique de la bande passante en France.
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> 2. Les hyperscalers sont critiqués pour le prix de leur trafic sortant,
>>>>>>> qui
>>>>>>> va d'environ 0,08€ à 0,045€ par Go selon le volume. La taxe, 0,055 €
>>>>>>> par
>>>>>>> Go, représente 68 % à 123 % de ce prix. On parle donc de doubler, pour
>>>>>>> le
>>>>>>> trafic vers la France, un prix déjà jugé trop élevé !
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> 3. Le cas d'OVHcloud. Nous envoyons de l'ordre de 500 Gbps au 95e
>>>>>>> percentile vers les FAI français, soit environ 324 Gbps en moyenne. Sur
>>>>>>> un
>>>>>>> an, la taxe brute atteindrait 70 M€. Le texte la plafonne à 15 % du CA
>>>>>>> réalisé en France ou à 2 % du CA mondial, soit entre environ 23 et 70
>>>>>>> M€
>>>>>>> par an que nous devrions collecter pour l'État, et donc répercuter sur
>>>>>>> nos
>>>>>>> clients.
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> Conclusions :
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> 1. Une taxe porte en général sur une petite fraction de son assiette.
>>>>>>> Celle-ci vaut plus de 3000 % du coût du transit, et environ 100 % du
>>>>>>> prix
>>>>>>> public des hyperscalers. Rappelez-vous la loi SREN, votée pour
>>>>>>> supprimer
>>>>>>> les frais de transfert qui empêchaient les clients de quitter un
>>>>>>> fournisseur cloud. Ici, on parle de doubler le prix du trafic sortant
>>>>>>> vers
>>>>>>> les internautes français, un prix déjà très problématique.
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> 2. Le garde-fou, un plafond calculé sur le chiffre d'affaires, est
>>>>>>> incohérent. Ce chiffre d'affaires couvre des serveurs, du stockage, des
>>>>>>> datacenters et des équipes sans rapport avec la bande passante. C'est
>>>>>>> comme
>>>>>>> créer une taxe calculée sur la consommation électrique des usines
>>>>>>> automobiles en France, plafonnée à 15 % du chiffre d'affaires des
>>>>>>> constructeurs. Quel rapport entre les deux ?
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> 3. Une taxe nationale de ce type frappe à coup sûr les entreprises
>>>>>>> établies
>>>>>>> en France, alors que leurs concurrents mondiaux sans présence en France
>>>>>>> livrent le même trafic aux mêmes FAI français sans payer cette taxe en
>>>>>>> pratique. Cela crée une distorsion de concurrence au détriment des
>>>>>>> acteurs
>>>>>>> nationaux et déclasse les entreprises qui embauchent en France. Une
>>>>>>> taxe
>>>>>>> qui produit l'effet inverse serait une meilleure approche.
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> (a) Facturé au 95e percentile, ce port n'est pas plein en permanence :
>>>>>>> avec
>>>>>>> un profil journalier type (22 % vers 4 h, 90 % vers 21 h), il
>>>>>>> transporte en
>>>>>>> moyenne 57 % de sa capacité, soit 18,6 millions de Go par mois.
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> All the best,
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> Frank
>>>>>>> Frantisek (Frank) Borsik
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> In loving memory of Dave Täht: 1965-2025
>>>>>>> https://libreqos.io/2025/04/01/in-loving-memory-of-dave/
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> https://www.linkedin.com/in/frantisekborsik
>>>>>>> Signal, Telegram, WhatsApp: +421919416714 <+421%20919%20416%20714>
>>>>>>> iMessage, mobile: +420775230885 <775%20230%20885>
>>>>>>> Skype: casioa5302ca
>>>>>>> frantisek.borsik@gmail.com
>>>>>>> _______________________________________________
>>>>>>> Bloat mailing list -- bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net
>>>>>>> To unsubscribe send an email to bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
>>>>>> _______________________________________________
>>>>>> Bloat mailing list -- bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net
>>>>>> To unsubscribe send an email to bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
>>>>>> _______________________________________________
>>>>>> Bloat mailing list -- bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net
>>>>>> To unsubscribe send an email to bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
>>>>> _______________________________________________
>>>>> Nnagain mailing list -- nnagain@lists.bufferbloat.net
>>>>> To unsubscribe send an email to nnagain-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
>>>>
>>>> --
>>>> Sascha Meinrath
>>>> Director, X-Lab
>>>> Palmer Chair in Telecommunications
>>>> Penn State University
>>>
>>>
>>
>
--
Sascha Meinrath
Director, X-Lab
Palmer Chair in Telecommunications
Penn State University
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 40+ messages in thread
* [Starlink] Re: [NNagain] [Bloat] The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering)
2026-11-04 18:33 ` [Starlink] " Sascha Meinrath
@ 2026-11-04 19:09 ` Sebastian Moeller
2026-11-04 19:14 ` [Starlink] Re: [Bloat] Re: [NNagain] " David Lang
2026-11-04 19:26 ` [Starlink] Re: [NNagain] Re: [Bloat] " Olivier MJ Crépin-Leblond
2026-11-18 7:49 ` [Starlink] Re: [NNagain] " Frantisek Borsik
1 sibling, 2 replies; 40+ messages in thread
From: Sebastian Moeller @ 2026-11-04 19:09 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: sascha
Cc: Network Neutrality is back! Let´s make the technical aspects heard this time!,
Michael Welzl, Frantisek Borsik, Dave Taht via Starlink, bloat,
Cake List, libreqos, Jeremy Austin via Rpm
Hi Sascha,
> On Nov 4, 2026, at 19:33, Sascha Meinrath <sascha@thexlab.org> wrote:
>
> On 11/4/26 12:03 PM, Sebastian Moeller wrote:> Hi Sascha,
>> On November 4, 2026 5:20:01 PM GMT+01:00, Sascha Meinrath <sascha@thexlab.org> wrote:
>>> Hi Sebastian,
>>>
>>> My point is that if I VPNed to a point outside France, then a French ISP would have no way to know that I've accessed the type of media that should be taxed.
>> A misunderstanding, the amendment prposes to tax every single bit independent of the source... it makes zero exemptions, not for FOSS, not for non commercially ial entities. Sure the motivation is to tax big tech primarily, but the current (half-baked) legal implementation is not differentiating...
>>> In essence, VPNs (and proxy services) would create extraordinary problems for even instrumenting the proposed taxing regime.
>> How? Like with a CDN the tax would hit the vpn provider... the ASN of the source IP....
>
> A VPN provider (at least any that I would recommend using) would not know the content being VPNed.
Indeed, and nor should he... the amendment is quite explicit what is supposed to be measured and taxed...
> In essence, someone in France could VPN to a different country; neither the ISP or the VPN provider would know the specific content being accessed
Indeed, and the law explicitly states that just received bytes for the ISPs customers are to be counted, per ASN and the bill is supposed to be sent to that ASN, independent of whether that ASN is the true source or what kind of data we are talking about... actually the law states that neither destination (the specific enduser) nor content are to be looked at/reported/aggregated.
> (Note: while some VPN's do track their users, none of the privacy protecting ones would do so); meanwhile, the media company -- even assuming some sort of extra-territorial leverage of French law outside of France -- may have no idea that the end destination of the media in question is within France.
Yes, but the party on the hook in this scenario is the VPN provider anyway. The ASN owning the source IP address of the packets an ISP receives, that is what is the aggregation key... not the true source of the packets (whatever that may be).
>
> Long story short, neither the VPN provider, the French ISP, nor the media company would necessarily know that a specific piece of media was destined for consumption within France.
If the VPN provider would not know or would not be able to find out that one of the endpoints use an IP address out of a french ISP's allotment, tough luck, that would be a sign of incompetent traffic monitoring, no?
> This is, of course, exactly the conundrum facing authoritarian and censorial regimes around the globe --
Look, I am no friend of authoritarian and censorial regimes, but this law is neither... it is a ham fisted approach at solving something that is a real issue, on-line business eating bricks-and-mortar's shops lunch and big tech exfiltrating loads of revenue with minimal taxation. Now, you might not consider these issues important, but at least to me they are neither authoritarian or censorial. I also see no slippery slope here into mass survailance...
> in this case, one is dodging tax surveillance, but the technical underpinnings are very much the same.
>
> All in all, a dumb & doomed (proposed) law.
Yes, but I feel that you have not actually read the full amendment (I only read translations as my french is simply to bad for the original). As there is no VPN loophole in the plan (but no argument, the plan is still dumb & doomed).
Regards
Sebastian
>
> --Sascha
>
>>>
>>> --Sascha
>>>
>>> On 11/4/26 10:40 AM, Sebastian Moeller wrote:
>>>> Hi Sascha,
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>> On Nov 2, 2026, at 15:30, Sascha Meinrath <sascha@thexlab.org> wrote:
>>>>>
>>>>> I can't wait until the French Parliament learns about VPNs... It would be absolutely *wonderful* if all the ISPs passed along the tax to their customers... and then taught all their customers that VPNed traffic would, for obvious reasons, be exempted.
>>>>
>>>> Not how this is supposed to work: the ISP aggregates its end-customer bound traffic volume by ASN and reports these aggregates quarterly, the tax office sends the ASNs the tax bill. VPN does not really matter, except now it is the VPN provider that is on the hook for the money. The amendment does not address VPNs but for CDNs that are in a similar picckle the idea is that CDN operators either pass on the cost or "eat" it themselves (both half-baked ideas). The only oddity VPNs add is that they typically receive no money from the actual content providers, but the end users.
>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>> I find proposals like this to be absolutely idiotic -- and, they are yet another step in the global data obfuscation arms race.
>>>>
>>>> Oh, that proposal is pretty half-baked, no arggument there, but I think we differ in which of its half-baked-ness we consider worst ;)
>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>> #encrypteverything
>>>>
>>>> Well, if you look what this is supposed to operate on encryption is not really an option, as this operates on source and destination IP addresses, that are somewhat prickly to encrypt if you want packets delivered...
>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>> --Sascha
>>>>>
>>>>> On 11/2/26 6:23 AM, Sebastian Moeller via Nnagain wrote:
>>>>>> Hi Michael,
>>>>>>> On Nov 2, 2026, at 08:44, Michael Welzl <michawe@ifi.uio.no> wrote:
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> The tax is 5 cents per Gigabyte. This is insane.
>>>>>> Back of the envelop calculations for video streaming (assuming this to be the one category driving most of the sustained capacity usage):
>>>>>> common use seems to be HD streaming (say on average at 5 Mbps), with say 2 hours per day, 7 days per week:
>>>>>> (5 * 1000^2) * (60 * 60 * 2 * 30) / (8 * 1000^3) = 135 GB
>>>>>> -> 135 * 0.055 = 7.425 Euro/month
>>>>>> typical cost for midrange (ad-free) video streaming in france: 8-15 Euro
>>>>>> depending on the reference contract tier, the tax almost as large as the total revenue, no way this could be priced-in without significant price increases.
>>>>>> The proposed tax indeed seems quite steep, however it is capped at 15% of revenue in france or 2% of world-wide revenue
>>>>>> So that would get this more in like with a 15% tax... on revenue, still nothing to sneeze at, but a far cry from the numbers one gets when simply multiplying...
>>>>>> Regards
>>>>>> Sebastian
>>>>>> P.S.: My take this is half-baked and will not make it through the further legislative process in that form.
>>>>>>> It goes against how we agree to use the Internet.
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> English version:
>>>>>>> "France has recently approved a highly controversial "Internet Traffic
>>>>>>> Tax" (or Gigabyte Tax) as part of the 2027 budget bill amendments. The
>>>>>>> new levy targets digital content providers based on the volume of data
>>>>>>> they transmit to French internet users, which is monitored by network
>>>>>>> operators and Internet Service Providers (ISPs) heavily utilizing
>>>>>>> Internet Exchange Points like France-IX."
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> Google AI summary:
>>>>>>> "Key Metrics & Tax Rates
>>>>>>> • €0.055 per gigabyte charged to content providers.
>>>>>>> • Capped at 15% of a provider's French revenue.
>>>>>>> • Capped at 2% of a provider's global revenue.
>>>>>>> • Measured directly by French network operators and ISPs."
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> On 2026-10-31 13:56, Frantisek Borsik wrote:
>>>>>>>> Crossposting, because this garbage idea might "inspire" more countries
>>>>>>>> and
>>>>>>>> have a horrible impact also on bufferbloat everywhere.
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> *Original post by Dr. Peering:*
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> *"The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own
>>>>>>>> country
>>>>>>>> by taxing Gigabits. Here’s Octave Klaba's excellent analysis [in
>>>>>>>> French,
>>>>>>>> link below] showing just how insane the finance bill actually is. The
>>>>>>>> IXP
>>>>>>>> taxation amount is, just for starters, ridiculous!"*
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> https://x.com/drpeering/status/2116468659392807
>>>>>>>> <https://x.com/drpeering/status/2116468659392807381?a=E-elnbppn-MAi-LNIrU&s=46>
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> *Octave's post:*
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> https://fr.linkedin.com/posts/octave-klaba-3a0b3632_jai-lu-lamendement-i-1358-au-plf-2027-activity-7522219045576888320-uqkw
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> *Copy+paste:*
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> J'ai lu l'amendement I-1358 au PLF 2027, adopté ce vendredi à
>>>>>>>> l'Assemblée :
>>>>>>>> une taxe de 0,055 € par Go envoyé vers les abonnés des FAI français. Le
>>>>>>>> chiffre est abstrait, alors comparons-le. Corrigez-moi si vous voyez
>>>>>>>> des
>>>>>>>> erreurs.
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> Deux comparaisons et un cas concret :
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> 1. Le transit et le peering. Un port 100 Gbps coûte environ 6 300 € par
>>>>>>>> mois chez un fournisseur de transit mondial. En interconnexion directe
>>>>>>>> avec
>>>>>>>> un FAI européen, compter 3 à 5 fois plus, soit 20 à 30 k€ par mois. Sur
>>>>>>>> ce
>>>>>>>> port (a), la taxe atteint 1,02 M€ par mois, soit environ 3400 % à 16300
>>>>>>>> %
>>>>>>>> du prix d'une interconnexion vers les FAI français. On change donc
>>>>>>>> profondément le modèle économique de la bande passante en France.
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> 2. Les hyperscalers sont critiqués pour le prix de leur trafic sortant,
>>>>>>>> qui
>>>>>>>> va d'environ 0,08€ à 0,045€ par Go selon le volume. La taxe, 0,055 €
>>>>>>>> par
>>>>>>>> Go, représente 68 % à 123 % de ce prix. On parle donc de doubler, pour
>>>>>>>> le
>>>>>>>> trafic vers la France, un prix déjà jugé trop élevé !
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> 3. Le cas d'OVHcloud. Nous envoyons de l'ordre de 500 Gbps au 95e
>>>>>>>> percentile vers les FAI français, soit environ 324 Gbps en moyenne. Sur
>>>>>>>> un
>>>>>>>> an, la taxe brute atteindrait 70 M€. Le texte la plafonne à 15 % du CA
>>>>>>>> réalisé en France ou à 2 % du CA mondial, soit entre environ 23 et 70
>>>>>>>> M€
>>>>>>>> par an que nous devrions collecter pour l'État, et donc répercuter sur
>>>>>>>> nos
>>>>>>>> clients.
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> Conclusions :
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> 1. Une taxe porte en général sur une petite fraction de son assiette.
>>>>>>>> Celle-ci vaut plus de 3000 % du coût du transit, et environ 100 % du
>>>>>>>> prix
>>>>>>>> public des hyperscalers. Rappelez-vous la loi SREN, votée pour
>>>>>>>> supprimer
>>>>>>>> les frais de transfert qui empêchaient les clients de quitter un
>>>>>>>> fournisseur cloud. Ici, on parle de doubler le prix du trafic sortant
>>>>>>>> vers
>>>>>>>> les internautes français, un prix déjà très problématique.
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> 2. Le garde-fou, un plafond calculé sur le chiffre d'affaires, est
>>>>>>>> incohérent. Ce chiffre d'affaires couvre des serveurs, du stockage, des
>>>>>>>> datacenters et des équipes sans rapport avec la bande passante. C'est
>>>>>>>> comme
>>>>>>>> créer une taxe calculée sur la consommation électrique des usines
>>>>>>>> automobiles en France, plafonnée à 15 % du chiffre d'affaires des
>>>>>>>> constructeurs. Quel rapport entre les deux ?
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> 3. Une taxe nationale de ce type frappe à coup sûr les entreprises
>>>>>>>> établies
>>>>>>>> en France, alors que leurs concurrents mondiaux sans présence en France
>>>>>>>> livrent le même trafic aux mêmes FAI français sans payer cette taxe en
>>>>>>>> pratique. Cela crée une distorsion de concurrence au détriment des
>>>>>>>> acteurs
>>>>>>>> nationaux et déclasse les entreprises qui embauchent en France. Une
>>>>>>>> taxe
>>>>>>>> qui produit l'effet inverse serait une meilleure approche.
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> (a) Facturé au 95e percentile, ce port n'est pas plein en permanence :
>>>>>>>> avec
>>>>>>>> un profil journalier type (22 % vers 4 h, 90 % vers 21 h), il
>>>>>>>> transporte en
>>>>>>>> moyenne 57 % de sa capacité, soit 18,6 millions de Go par mois.
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> All the best,
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> Frank
>>>>>>>> Frantisek (Frank) Borsik
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> In loving memory of Dave Täht: 1965-2025
>>>>>>>> https://libreqos.io/2025/04/01/in-loving-memory-of-dave/
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> https://www.linkedin.com/in/frantisekborsik
>>>>>>>> Signal, Telegram, WhatsApp: +421919416714 <+421%20919%20416%20714>
>>>>>>>> iMessage, mobile: +420775230885 <775%20230%20885>
>>>>>>>> Skype: casioa5302ca
>>>>>>>> frantisek.borsik@gmail.com
>>>>>>>> _______________________________________________
>>>>>>>> Bloat mailing list -- bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net
>>>>>>>> To unsubscribe send an email to bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
>>>>>>> _______________________________________________
>>>>>>> Bloat mailing list -- bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net
>>>>>>> To unsubscribe send an email to bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
>>>>>>> _______________________________________________
>>>>>>> Bloat mailing list -- bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net
>>>>>>> To unsubscribe send an email to bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
>>>>>> _______________________________________________
>>>>>> Nnagain mailing list -- nnagain@lists.bufferbloat.net
>>>>>> To unsubscribe send an email to nnagain-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
>>>>>
>>>>> --
>>>>> Sascha Meinrath
>>>>> Director, X-Lab
>>>>> Palmer Chair in Telecommunications
>>>>> Penn State University
>>>>
>>>>
>>>
>
> --
> Sascha Meinrath
> Director, X-Lab
> Palmer Chair in Telecommunications
> Penn State University
>
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 40+ messages in thread
* [Starlink] Re: [Bloat] Re: [NNagain] The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering)
2026-11-04 19:09 ` Sebastian Moeller
@ 2026-11-04 19:14 ` David Lang
2026-11-04 19:20 ` [Starlink] Re: [Bloat] " Sebastian Moeller
2026-11-04 19:26 ` [Starlink] Re: [NNagain] Re: [Bloat] " Olivier MJ Crépin-Leblond
1 sibling, 1 reply; 40+ messages in thread
From: David Lang @ 2026-11-04 19:14 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: Sebastian Moeller
Cc: sascha,
Network Neutrality is back! Let´s make the technical aspects heard this time!,
Michael Welzl, Frantisek Borsik, Dave Taht via Starlink, bloat,
Cake List, libreqos, Jeremy Austin via Rpm
Sebastian Moeller via Bloat wrote:
>> In essence, someone in France could VPN to a different country; neither the ISP or the VPN provider would know the specific content being accessed
>
> Indeed, and the law explicitly states that just received bytes for the ISPs customers are to be counted, per ASN and the bill is supposed to be sent to that ASN, independent of whether that ASN is the true source or what kind of data we are talking about... actually the law states that neither destination (the specific enduser) nor content are to be looked at/reported/aggregated.
so if a packet transitions multiple ISPs, each one would generate a bill for the
traffic? what a way to entrench large ISPs
(I may be misunderstanding something)
David Lang
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 40+ messages in thread
* [Starlink] Re: [Bloat] [NNagain] The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering)
2026-11-04 19:14 ` [Starlink] Re: [Bloat] Re: [NNagain] " David Lang
@ 2026-11-04 19:20 ` Sebastian Moeller
0 siblings, 0 replies; 40+ messages in thread
From: Sebastian Moeller @ 2026-11-04 19:20 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: David Lang
Cc: sascha,
Network Neutrality is back! Letīs make the technical aspects heard this time!,
Michael Welzl, Frantisek Borsik, Dave Taht via Starlink, bloat,
Cake List, libreqos, Jeremy Austin via Rpm
Hi David,
> On Nov 4, 2026, at 20:14, David Lang <david@lang.hm> wrote:
>
> Sebastian Moeller via Bloat wrote:
>
>>> In essence, someone in France could VPN to a different country; neither the ISP or the VPN provider would know the specific content being accessed
>>
>> Indeed, and the law explicitly states that just received bytes for the ISPs customers are to be counted, per ASN and the bill is supposed to be sent to that ASN, independent of whether that ASN is the true source or what kind of data we are talking about... actually the law states that neither destination (the specific enduser) nor content are to be looked at/reported/aggregated.
>
> so if a packet transitions multiple ISPs, each one would generate a bill for the traffic? what a way to entrench large ISPs
As far as I understand only the final ISP that serves the destination IP address... so if e.g. free would use orange as transit provider orange would not count that data as it does not terminate at end-users. BUT I have only read translations as my french is to bad and I have zero understanding of french legalese, so you might be correct that such a situation is not currently handled*
>
> (I may be misunderstanding something)
I am in the same boat ;)
>
> David Lang
*) Ans anyway, I thing we all agree this thing is half-baked at best and will not pass (at least not in that form).
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 40+ messages in thread
* [Starlink] Re: [NNagain] Re: [Bloat] The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering)
2026-11-04 19:09 ` Sebastian Moeller
2026-11-04 19:14 ` [Starlink] Re: [Bloat] Re: [NNagain] " David Lang
@ 2026-11-04 19:26 ` Olivier MJ Crépin-Leblond
1 sibling, 0 replies; 40+ messages in thread
From: Olivier MJ Crépin-Leblond @ 2026-11-04 19:26 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: Network Neutrality is back! Let´s make the technical aspects heard this time!,
sascha
Cc: Michael Welzl, Frantisek Borsik, Dave Taht via Starlink, bloat,
Cake List, libreqos, Jeremy Austin via Rpm, Sebastian Moeller
On 04/11/2026 20:09, Sebastian Moeller via Nnagain wrote:
>> All in all, a dumb & doomed (proposed) law.
> Yes, but I feel that you have not actually read the full amendment (I only read translations as my french is simply to bad for the original). As there is no VPN loophole in the plan (but no argument, the plan is still dumb & doomed).
Before we all get too upset about this, I spoke to an authoritative
source that (on the condition on anonymity) told me this is a proposed
amendment by a dozen people with no chance of it succeeding. All part of
the political games being played...
Kindest regards,
Olivier
--
Olivier MJ Crépin-Leblond, PhD
http://www.gih.com/ocl.html
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 40+ messages in thread
* [Starlink] Re: [Cake] [NNagain] [Bloat] The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering)
2026-11-04 17:57 ` [Starlink] Re: [Cake] " David P. Reed
@ 2026-11-05 9:05 ` Sebastian Moeller
2026-11-16 23:04 ` [Starlink] Re: [Bloat] Re: [Cake] [NNagain] " Juliusz Chroboczek
2026-11-18 7:48 ` [Starlink] Re: [Cake] Re: [NNagain] [Bloat] " Frantisek Borsik
1 sibling, 1 reply; 40+ messages in thread
From: Sebastian Moeller @ 2026-11-05 9:05 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: David P. Reed
Cc: sascha,
Network Neutrality is back! Let´s make the technical aspects heard this time!,
Michael Welzl, Frantisek Borsik, Dave Taht via Starlink, bloat,
Cake List, libreqos, Jeremy Austin via Rpm
David,
I feel you are barking up the wrong tree here.
> On Nov 4, 2026, at 18:57, David P. Reed <dpreed@deepplum.com> wrote:
>
> Sascha, et al. -
> The law is never about "how will we enforce it", because (sarcasm on) such petty details as enforcement is not germane to Governments' Will to Control (sarcasm off).
> When they try to dream up "technical means" for enforcement, rather than just putting the law on the books, they may all of a sudden try to interfere with all kinds of Internet mechanisms. This won't be easy, but we have the history of Thought Control starting with the early Internet deployments where the words "breast" and so forth were supposed to be detected by all Internet routers in all packets. Senator Exon of the US got some "tech pundits" to say that was possible and easy, and I got involved politically to suppress the "Exon Box" idea, which was politically gaining steam, even among "progressives.:
> The issue, of course, is that the legislators invent dynamite-scale enforcement mechanisms that interfere with every damn thing in order to solve a pretty narrow problem.
>
> Note that the Post Office in most countries are NOT allowed to inspect all letters and packages.
I would be surprised though, if the postal service did not keep track of the number of packets and their weight per each other countries, no?
> But the fascist instinct exists everywhere, even France. "There oughta be a law" is what voters first turn to, both on the Left and the RIght - which is why just saying "The Rule of Law" is not equivalent to democracy.
> If you want to charge a tax on a behavior of a consumer, you basically need to surveill actual consumption by each individual, which is not technically feasible. No more than enforcing a law that says you can't listen to the words of Islam or read Mein Kampf.
That is not what that amendment actually proposes... it is really quite explicit, ingress bytes per ASN aggregated monthly. NOT per individual end-user, as the tax is not per individual but per ASN (at least that is the plan, we all agree that this plan is likely going nowhere).
>
> I don't get really upset about this until the Tax Policy starts to move to an implementation that destroys our rights to privacy (meaning the right to be left alone, not the right to keep data secret).
All they require is for ISPs to monitor what competent ISPs likely already monitor for internal reasons anyway, the aggregate ingress data per ASN... If that would leak, it would be unfortunate for the ISPs as it might reveal interesting data about that ISP to its competitors, but for the ISP's endusers that likely would be no privacy issue as they are not part of the aggregated data
That is not ment to mean all is fine with the amendment (and we all seem to agree it is going nowhere and deservedly so), just that privacy or censorship in my opinion are not really affected.
Regards
Sebastian.
> On Wednesday, November 4, 2026 12:03, "Sebastian Moeller via Cake" <cake@lists.bufferbloat.net> said:
>
> > Hi Sascha,
> >
> > On November 4, 2026 5:20:01 PM GMT+01:00, Sascha Meinrath
> > <sascha@thexlab.org> wrote:
> > >Hi Sebastian,
> > >
> > >My point is that if I VPNed to a point outside France, then a French ISP would
> > have no way to know that I've accessed the type of media that should be taxed.
> >
> >
> > A misunderstanding, the amendment prposes to tax every single bit independent of
> > the source... it makes zero exemptions, not for FOSS, not for non commercially ial
> > entities. Sure the motivation is to tax big tech primarily, but the current
> > (half-baked) legal implementation is not differentiating...
> >
> >
> > > In essence, VPNs (and proxy services) would create extraordinary problems for
> > even instrumenting the proposed taxing regime.
> >
> > How? Like with a CDN the tax would hit the vpn provider... the ASN of the source
> > IP....
> >
> >
> >
> >
> > >
> > >--Sascha
> > >
> > >On 11/4/26 10:40 AM, Sebastian Moeller wrote:
> > >> Hi Sascha,
> > >>
> > >>
> > >>> On Nov 2, 2026, at 15:30, Sascha Meinrath <sascha@thexlab.org>
> > wrote:
> > >>>
> > >>> I can't wait until the French Parliament learns about VPNs... It
> > would be absolutely *wonderful* if all the ISPs passed along the tax to their
> > customers... and then taught all their customers that VPNed traffic would, for
> > obvious reasons, be exempted.
> > >>
> > >> Not how this is supposed to work: the ISP aggregates its end-customer
> > bound traffic volume by ASN and reports these aggregates quarterly, the tax office
> > sends the ASNs the tax bill. VPN does not really matter, except now it is the VPN
> > provider that is on the hook for the money. The amendment does not address VPNs
> > but for CDNs that are in a similar picckle the idea is that CDN operators either
> > pass on the cost or "eat" it themselves (both half-baked ideas). The only oddity
> > VPNs add is that they typically receive no money from the actual content
> > providers, but the end users.
> > >>
> > >>>
> > >>> I find proposals like this to be absolutely idiotic -- and, they are
> > yet another step in the global data obfuscation arms race.
> > >>
> > >> Oh, that proposal is pretty half-baked, no arggument there, but I think
> > we differ in which of its half-baked-ness we consider worst ;)
> > >>
> > >>>
> > >>> #encrypteverything
> > >>
> > >> Well, if you look what this is supposed to operate on encryption is not
> > really an option, as this operates on source and destination IP addresses, that
> > are somewhat prickly to encrypt if you want packets delivered...
> > >>
> > >>>
> > >>> --Sascha
> > >>>
> > >>> On 11/2/26 6:23 AM, Sebastian Moeller via Nnagain wrote:
> > >>>> Hi Michael,
> > >>>>> On Nov 2, 2026, at 08:44, Michael Welzl
> > <michawe@ifi.uio.no> wrote:
> > >>>>>
> > >>>>> The tax is 5 cents per Gigabyte. This is insane.
> > >>>> Back of the envelop calculations for video streaming (assuming
> > this to be the one category driving most of the sustained capacity usage):
> > >>>> common use seems to be HD streaming (say on average at 5 Mbps),
> > with say 2 hours per day, 7 days per week:
> > >>>> (5 * 1000^2) * (60 * 60 * 2 * 30) / (8 * 1000^3) = 135 GB
> > >>>> -> 135 * 0.055 = 7.425 Euro/month
> > >>>> typical cost for midrange (ad-free) video streaming in france:
> > 8-15 Euro
> > >>>> depending on the reference contract tier, the tax almost as large
> > as the total revenue, no way this could be priced-in without significant price
> > increases.
> > >>>> The proposed tax indeed seems quite steep, however it is capped
> > at 15% of revenue in france or 2% of world-wide revenue
> > >>>> So that would get this more in like with a 15% tax... on revenue,
> > still nothing to sneeze at, but a far cry from the numbers one gets when simply
> > multiplying...
> > >>>> Regards
> > >>>> Sebastian
> > >>>> P.S.: My take this is half-baked and will not make it through the
> > further legislative process in that form.
> > >>>>> It goes against how we agree to use the Internet.
> > >>>>>
> > >>>>> English version:
> > >>>>> "France has recently approved a highly controversial
> > "Internet Traffic
> > >>>>> Tax" (or Gigabyte Tax) as part of the 2027 budget bill
> > amendments. The
> > >>>>> new levy targets digital content providers based on the
> > volume of data
> > >>>>> they transmit to French internet users, which is monitored by
> > network
> > >>>>> operators and Internet Service Providers (ISPs) heavily
> > utilizing
> > >>>>> Internet Exchange Points like France-IX."
> > >>>>>
> > >>>>> Google AI summary:
> > >>>>> "Key Metrics & Tax Rates
> > >>>>> • €0.055 per gigabyte charged to content
> > providers.
> > >>>>> • Capped at 15% of a provider's French revenue.
> > >>>>> • Capped at 2% of a provider's global revenue.
> > >>>>> • Measured directly by French network operators and
> > ISPs."
> > >>>>>
> > >>>>>
> > >>>>> On 2026-10-31 13:56, Frantisek Borsik wrote:
> > >>>>>> Crossposting, because this garbage idea might "inspire"
> > more countries
> > >>>>>> and
> > >>>>>> have a horrible impact also on bufferbloat everywhere.
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> *Original post by Dr. Peering:*
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> *"The French have decided to destroy the Internet within
> > their own
> > >>>>>> country
> > >>>>>> by taxing Gigabits. Here’s Octave Klaba's excellent
> > analysis [in
> > >>>>>> French,
> > >>>>>> link below] showing just how insane the finance bill
> > actually is. The
> > >>>>>> IXP
> > >>>>>> taxation amount is, just for starters, ridiculous!"*
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> https://x.com/drpeering/status/2116468659392807
> > >>>>>>
> > <https://x.com/drpeering/status/2116468659392807381?a=E-elnbppn-MAi-LNIrU&s=46>
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> *Octave's post:*
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>>
> > https://fr.linkedin.com/posts/octave-klaba-3a0b3632_jai-lu-lamendement-i-1358-au-plf-2027-activity-7522219045576888320-uqkw
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> *Copy+paste:*
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> J'ai lu l'amendement I-1358 au PLF 2027, adopté ce
> > vendredi à
> > >>>>>> l'Assemblée :
> > >>>>>> une taxe de 0,055 € par Go envoyé vers les
> > abonnés des FAI français. Le
> > >>>>>> chiffre est abstrait, alors comparons-le. Corrigez-moi si
> > vous voyez
> > >>>>>> des
> > >>>>>> erreurs.
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> Deux comparaisons et un cas concret :
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> 1. Le transit et le peering. Un port 100 Gbps coûte
> > environ 6 300 € par
> > >>>>>> mois chez un fournisseur de transit mondial. En
> > interconnexion directe
> > >>>>>> avec
> > >>>>>> un FAI européen, compter 3 à 5 fois plus,
> > soit 20 à 30 k€ par mois. Sur
> > >>>>>> ce
> > >>>>>> port (a), la taxe atteint 1,02 M€ par mois, soit
> > environ 3400 % à 16300
> > >>>>>> %
> > >>>>>> du prix d'une interconnexion vers les FAI
> > français. On change donc
> > >>>>>> profondément le modèle économique de
> > la bande passante en France.
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> 2. Les hyperscalers sont critiqués pour le prix de
> > leur trafic sortant,
> > >>>>>> qui
> > >>>>>> va d'environ 0,08€ à 0,045€ par Go selon
> > le volume. La taxe, 0,055 €
> > >>>>>> par
> > >>>>>> Go, représente 68 % à 123 % de ce prix. On
> > parle donc de doubler, pour
> > >>>>>> le
> > >>>>>> trafic vers la France, un prix déjà
> > jugé trop élevé !
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> 3. Le cas d'OVHcloud. Nous envoyons de l'ordre de 500
> > Gbps au 95e
> > >>>>>> percentile vers les FAI français, soit environ 324
> > Gbps en moyenne. Sur
> > >>>>>> un
> > >>>>>> an, la taxe brute atteindrait 70 M€. Le texte la
> > plafonne à 15 % du CA
> > >>>>>> réalisé en France ou à 2 % du CA
> > mondial, soit entre environ 23 et 70
> > >>>>>> M€
> > >>>>>> par an que nous devrions collecter pour l'État, et
> > donc répercuter sur
> > >>>>>> nos
> > >>>>>> clients.
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> Conclusions :
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> 1. Une taxe porte en général sur une petite
> > fraction de son assiette.
> > >>>>>> Celle-ci vaut plus de 3000 % du coût du transit, et
> > environ 100 % du
> > >>>>>> prix
> > >>>>>> public des hyperscalers. Rappelez-vous la loi SREN,
> > votée pour
> > >>>>>> supprimer
> > >>>>>> les frais de transfert qui empêchaient les clients
> > de quitter un
> > >>>>>> fournisseur cloud. Ici, on parle de doubler le prix du
> > trafic sortant
> > >>>>>> vers
> > >>>>>> les internautes français, un prix
> > déjà très problématique.
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> 2. Le garde-fou, un plafond calculé sur le chiffre
> > d'affaires, est
> > >>>>>> incohérent. Ce chiffre d'affaires couvre des
> > serveurs, du stockage, des
> > >>>>>> datacenters et des équipes sans rapport avec la
> > bande passante. C'est
> > >>>>>> comme
> > >>>>>> créer une taxe calculée sur la consommation
> > électrique des usines
> > >>>>>> automobiles en France, plafonnée à 15 % du
> > chiffre d'affaires des
> > >>>>>> constructeurs. Quel rapport entre les deux ?
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> 3. Une taxe nationale de ce type frappe à coup
> > sûr les entreprises
> > >>>>>> établies
> > >>>>>> en France, alors que leurs concurrents mondiaux sans
> > présence en France
> > >>>>>> livrent le même trafic aux mêmes FAI
> > français sans payer cette taxe en
> > >>>>>> pratique. Cela crée une distorsion de concurrence
> > au détriment des
> > >>>>>> acteurs
> > >>>>>> nationaux et déclasse les entreprises qui
> > embauchent en France. Une
> > >>>>>> taxe
> > >>>>>> qui produit l'effet inverse serait une meilleure
> > approche.
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> (a) Facturé au 95e percentile, ce port n'est pas
> > plein en permanence :
> > >>>>>> avec
> > >>>>>> un profil journalier type (22 % vers 4 h, 90 % vers 21
> > h), il
> > >>>>>> transporte en
> > >>>>>> moyenne 57 % de sa capacité, soit 18,6 millions de
> > Go par mois.
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> All the best,
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> Frank
> > >>>>>> Frantisek (Frank) Borsik
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> In loving memory of Dave Täht: 1965-2025
> > >>>>>> https://libreqos.io/2025/04/01/in-loving-memory-of-dave/
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> https://www.linkedin.com/in/frantisekborsik
> > >>>>>> Signal, Telegram, WhatsApp: +421919416714
> > <+421%20919%20416%20714>
> > >>>>>> iMessage, mobile: +420775230885 <775%20230%20885>
> > >>>>>> Skype: casioa5302ca
> > >>>>>> frantisek.borsik@gmail.com
> > >>>>>> _______________________________________________
> > >>>>>> Bloat mailing list -- bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net
> > >>>>>> To unsubscribe send an email to
> > bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
> > >>>>> _______________________________________________
> > >>>>> Bloat mailing list -- bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net
> > >>>>> To unsubscribe send an email to
> > bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
> > >>>>> _______________________________________________
> > >>>>> Bloat mailing list -- bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net
> > >>>>> To unsubscribe send an email to
> > bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
> > >>>> _______________________________________________
> > >>>> Nnagain mailing list -- nnagain@lists.bufferbloat.net
> > >>>> To unsubscribe send an email to
> > nnagain-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
> > >>>
> > >>> --
> > >>> Sascha Meinrath
> > >>> Director, X-Lab
> > >>> Palmer Chair in Telecommunications
> > >>> Penn State University
> > >>
> > >>
> > >
> >
> > --
> > Sent from my Android device with K-9 Mail. Please excuse my brevity.
> > _______________________________________________
> > Cake mailing list -- cake@lists.bufferbloat.net
> > To unsubscribe send an email to cake-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
> >
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 40+ messages in thread
* [Starlink] Re: [Bloat] The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering)
2026-10-31 12:56 [Starlink] The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering) Frantisek Borsik
` (3 preceding siblings ...)
2026-11-02 7:44 ` [Starlink] [Bloat] " Michael Welzl
@ 2026-11-16 16:11 ` Juliusz Chroboczek
2026-11-16 16:31 ` [Starlink] Re: [LibreQoS] " Frantisek (Frank) Borsik
4 siblings, 1 reply; 40+ messages in thread
From: Juliusz Chroboczek @ 2026-11-16 16:11 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: Frantisek Borsik
Cc: Network Neutrality is back! Let´s make the technical aspects heard this time!,
Dave Taht via Starlink, bloat, Cake List, libreqos,
Jeremy Austin via Rpm
> *Original post by Dr. Peering:*
>
> *"The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country
> by taxing Gigabits.
The whole set of amendments has been voted against, so the text will reach
the Senate without them. There's still a number of steps before the text
becomes law, but it seems unlikely that this particular amendment will be
ressucitated.
https://www.franceinfo.fr/economie/budget/budget-2026-que-va-t-il-se-passer-apres-le-rejet-de-la-partie-recettes-du-projet-de-loi-de-finances-par-les-deputes_7631201.html
-- Juliusz
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 40+ messages in thread
* [Starlink] Re: [LibreQoS] Re: [Bloat] The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering)
2026-11-16 16:11 ` Juliusz Chroboczek
@ 2026-11-16 16:31 ` Frantisek (Frank) Borsik
2026-11-16 20:41 ` [Starlink] Re: [Bloat] Re: [LibreQoS] " Linus Lüssing
2026-11-17 6:36 ` [Starlink] Re: [LibreQoS] Re: [Bloat] " Sebastian Moeller
0 siblings, 2 replies; 40+ messages in thread
From: Frantisek (Frank) Borsik @ 2026-11-16 16:31 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: Juliusz Chroboczek
Cc: Frantisek Borsik,
Network Neutrality is back! Let´s make the technical aspects heard this time!,
Dave Taht via Starlink, bloat, Cake List, libreqos,
Jeremy Austin via Rpm
Well, thank god, but even the very inception of this demented idea is
troublesome and there will be more of this garbage coming soon.
We are in for a ride..
All my best,
Frank
Frantisek (Frank) Borsik
Gofer at LibreQoS
*In loving memory of Dave Täht: *1965-2025
https://libreqos.io/2025/04/01/in-loving-memory-of-dave/
On Mon, Nov 16, 2026 at 8:12 AM Juliusz Chroboczek via LibreQoS <
libreqos@lists.bufferbloat.net> wrote:
> > *Original post by Dr. Peering:*
> >
> > *"The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own
> country
> > by taxing Gigabits.
>
> The whole set of amendments has been voted against, so the text will reach
> the Senate without them. There's still a number of steps before the text
> becomes law, but it seems unlikely that this particular amendment will be
> ressucitated.
>
>
> https://www.franceinfo.fr/economie/budget/budget-2026-que-va-t-il-se-passer-apres-le-rejet-de-la-partie-recettes-du-projet-de-loi-de-finances-par-les-deputes_7631201.html
>
> -- Juliusz
>
> _______________________________________________
> LibreQoS mailing list -- libreqos@lists.bufferbloat.net
> To unsubscribe send an email to libreqos-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
>
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 40+ messages in thread
* [Starlink] Re: [Bloat] Re: [LibreQoS] Re: The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering)
2026-11-16 16:31 ` [Starlink] Re: [LibreQoS] " Frantisek (Frank) Borsik
@ 2026-11-16 20:41 ` Linus Lüssing
2026-11-16 22:53 ` Juliusz Chroboczek
2026-11-17 6:36 ` [Starlink] Re: [LibreQoS] Re: [Bloat] " Sebastian Moeller
1 sibling, 1 reply; 40+ messages in thread
From: Linus Lüssing @ 2026-11-16 20:41 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: Frantisek (Frank) Borsik
Cc: Frantisek Borsik,
Network Neutrality is back! Let´s make the technical aspects heard this time!,
Dave Taht via Starlink, bloat, Cake List, libreqos,
Jeremy Austin via Rpm
Hi,
Actually, from a Freifunk / Community Network perspective, I found
the idea quite interesting :D.
Like, if it could incentivise running services locally. Maybe even boosting
the use of technologies like IPv6, Bittorrent or multicast? So overall
strengthening the autonomy of a local community network, keeping
most traffic local.
But I don't know how/if peer-to-peer / platform-less services would
be metered by that proposal. How would a direct videocall using
WebRTC or RTP between two people be metered/taxed? What about a
Linux distro live image shared via Bittorrent?
Does the proposal only meter/tax WAN/internet traffic, is
LAN/MANET/intranet/regional traffic excempt?
I also read that the tax would have gone into the overall French state
budget, instead of back into the telecom infrastructure providers.
Would have been nice, if a community network could get a share from that
to build a reliable, independent infrastructure and capacity locally. And
by that reducing the taxed traffic. While subsidizing local infrastructure.
So that maybe overall longterm you'd even get a lower cost?
(especially when factoring in the cost of geopolitical dependencies these days?)
But other than that, yes, I fully agree that any non-profit platform/service
should simply clearly be excempt.
Regards, Linus
On Mon, Nov 16, 2026 at 08:31:27AM -0800, Frantisek (Frank) Borsik wrote:
> Well, thank god, but even the very inception of this demented idea is
> troublesome and there will be more of this garbage coming soon.
>
> We are in for a ride..
>
> All my best,
>
> Frank
>
>
> Frantisek (Frank) Borsik
>
> Gofer at LibreQoS
>
>
> *In loving memory of Dave Täht: *1965-2025
>
> https://libreqos.io/2025/04/01/in-loving-memory-of-dave/
>
>
>
>
> On Mon, Nov 16, 2026 at 8:12 AM Juliusz Chroboczek via LibreQoS <
> libreqos@lists.bufferbloat.net> wrote:
>
> > > *Original post by Dr. Peering:*
> > >
> > > *"The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own
> > country
> > > by taxing Gigabits.
> >
> > The whole set of amendments has been voted against, so the text will reach
> > the Senate without them. There's still a number of steps before the text
> > becomes law, but it seems unlikely that this particular amendment will be
> > ressucitated.
> >
> >
> > https://www.franceinfo.fr/economie/budget/budget-2026-que-va-t-il-se-passer-apres-le-rejet-de-la-partie-recettes-du-projet-de-loi-de-finances-par-les-deputes_7631201.html
> >
> > -- Juliusz
> >
> > _______________________________________________
> > LibreQoS mailing list -- libreqos@lists.bufferbloat.net
> > To unsubscribe send an email to libreqos-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
> >
> _______________________________________________
> Bloat mailing list -- bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net
> To unsubscribe send an email to bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 40+ messages in thread
* [Starlink] Re: [Bloat] Re: [LibreQoS] Re: The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering)
2026-11-16 20:41 ` [Starlink] Re: [Bloat] Re: [LibreQoS] " Linus Lüssing
@ 2026-11-16 22:53 ` Juliusz Chroboczek
2026-11-17 15:59 ` Michael Richardson
0 siblings, 1 reply; 40+ messages in thread
From: Juliusz Chroboczek @ 2026-11-16 22:53 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: Linus Lüssing
Cc: Frantisek (Frank) Borsik, Frantisek Borsik,
Network Neutrality is back! Let´s make the technical aspects heard this time!,
Dave Taht via Starlink, bloat, Cake List, libreqos,
Jeremy Austin via Rpm
František said:
>> Well, thank god, but even the very inception of this demented idea is
>> troublesome and there will be more of this garbage coming soon.
You'd need to ask somebody more familiar with French parliamentary
procedure, but my understanding is that this is normal democratic debate
working as intended.
Linus said :
> But I don't know how/if peer-to-peer / platform-less services would
> be metered by that proposal. How would a direct videocall using
> WebRTC or RTP between two people be metered/taxed? What about a
> Linux distro live image shared via Bittorrent?
My understanding is that the ISP of the receiver would measure the
aggregate amount of data sent to its users from each ASN. It would
communicate this aggregate data (with no information about the
destination) to the French finance administration, the DGFP. The DGFP
would then tax the holder of the sender ASN. In effect, the ISP of the
sender would be taxed.
The smart bit about the proposal is that it bases the tax on something
that cannot be moved offshore, the amount of traffic received by the
French user. (If the French user uses a VPN, then the holder of the ASN
of the VPN provider would be taxed.)
> Does the proposal only meter/tax WAN/internet traffic, is
> LAN/MANET/intranet/regional traffic excempt?
The proposed amendment does not explicitly say what happens when the
sender's and receiver's ASNs are equal. I guess the exact implementation
would be defined by an application decree.
> But other than that, yes, I fully agree that any non-profit platform/service
> should simply clearly be excempt.
What about a for-profit entity that hosts a freely available Debian mirror?
What about a non-profit entity that provides commercial hosting?
Many problems with the proposal, as you point out, but the general idea is
interesting.
-- Juliusz
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 40+ messages in thread
* [Starlink] Re: [Bloat] Re: [Cake] [NNagain] The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering)
2026-11-05 9:05 ` [Starlink] Re: [Cake] " Sebastian Moeller
@ 2026-11-16 23:04 ` Juliusz Chroboczek
2026-11-17 1:43 ` David P. Reed
0 siblings, 1 reply; 40+ messages in thread
From: Juliusz Chroboczek @ 2026-11-16 23:04 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: Sebastian Moeller
Cc: David P. Reed, sascha,
Network Neutrality is back! Let´s make the technical aspects heard this time!,
Michael Welzl, Frantisek Borsik, Dave Taht via Starlink, bloat,
Cake List, libreqos, Jeremy Austin via Rpm
> That is not ment to mean all is fine with the amendment (and we all seem
> to agree it is going nowhere and deservedly so), just that privacy or
> censorship in my opinion are not really affected.
Fully agreed, on all counts.
What is interesting, the rationale (``Exposé Sommaire'') explicitly
explains how user privacy is being protected:
« This model does not raise issues related to privacy: the data are never
consulted. The tax does not involve any deep inspection of data
packets, no subscriber's personal data is audited, and it respects the
confidentiality of correspondence just like the GDPR: one counts bytes
by operator, not individual uses. Transit providers and CDNs are not
required to name their customers. They pass on the tax to them or not,
depending on their terms of service, while respecting trade secrets. »
I'm not claiming the envisioned scenario is realistic, merely that the
authors did take user privacy into account.
-- Juliusz
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 40+ messages in thread
* [Starlink] Re: [Bloat] Re: [Cake] [NNagain] The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering)
2026-11-16 23:04 ` [Starlink] Re: [Bloat] Re: [Cake] [NNagain] " Juliusz Chroboczek
@ 2026-11-17 1:43 ` David P. Reed
2026-11-17 12:33 ` Juliusz Chroboczek
` (2 more replies)
0 siblings, 3 replies; 40+ messages in thread
From: David P. Reed @ 2026-11-17 1:43 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: Juliusz Chroboczek
Cc: Sebastian Moeller, sascha,
Network Neutrality is back! Let´s make the technical aspects heard this time!,
Michael Welzl, Frantisek Borsik, Dave Taht via Starlink, bloat,
Cake List, libreqos, Jeremy Austin via Rpm
There is a presumption that "providers" will just pay based on byte counts on their wires or wireless.
But I don't get it. Why not just tax the physical assets, and not bother with byte counting at all?
Do they tax theaters based on the number of words spoken by actors in the theater?
My colleague at the Media Lab, Andy Lippman once talked about how Xerox might charge the users of its leased copiers based on end-user value - a copy of your kids homework might cost a nickel per page, but copying a corporate merger agreement for a billion dollar acquistion might be charged a few million dollars just for that one copy made.
This attempts to tax the "value" of the bits copied or transmitted, as companies like airlines try to do with First Class vs. Coach prices, or other "value" pricing. In the case of bits on a wire, the actual cost of operations is not due to the bits, but the cost of installing and maintaining the wire.
And of course, most of the value of a "network" isn't due to usage, but due to the optionality introduced by the ability to (at any time) reach any of the endpoints. That's been explained in Metcalfe's Law and Reed's Law - both of which try to value the option to send a message, which is usually worth more than the actual messages sent.
Really, the EU technocracy should learn something about the communications business and communications economics.
Otherwise their whole concept is just whacko.
On Monday, November 16, 2026 18:04, "Juliusz Chroboczek" <jch@irif.fr> said:
> > That is not ment to mean all is fine with the amendment (and we all seem
> > to agree it is going nowhere and deservedly so), just that privacy or
> > censorship in my opinion are not really affected.
>
> Fully agreed, on all counts.
>
> What is interesting, the rationale (``Exposé Sommaire'') explicitly
> explains how user privacy is being protected:
>
> « This model does not raise issues related to privacy: the data are never
> consulted. The tax does not involve any deep inspection of data
> packets, no subscriber's personal data is audited, and it respects the
> confidentiality of correspondence just like the GDPR: one counts bytes
> by operator, not individual uses. Transit providers and CDNs are not
> required to name their customers. They pass on the tax to them or not,
> depending on their terms of service, while respecting trade secrets. »
>
> I'm not claiming the envisioned scenario is realistic, merely that the
> authors did take user privacy into account.
>
> -- Juliusz
>
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 40+ messages in thread
* [Starlink] Re: [LibreQoS] Re: [Bloat] The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering)
2026-11-16 16:31 ` [Starlink] Re: [LibreQoS] " Frantisek (Frank) Borsik
2026-11-16 20:41 ` [Starlink] Re: [Bloat] Re: [LibreQoS] " Linus Lüssing
@ 2026-11-17 6:36 ` Sebastian Moeller
1 sibling, 0 replies; 40+ messages in thread
From: Sebastian Moeller @ 2026-11-17 6:36 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: Frantisek (Frank) Borsik, Frantisek (Frank) Borsik via Starlink,
Juliusz Chroboczek
Cc: Frantisek Borsik,
Network Neutrality is back! Let´s make the technical aspects heard this time!,
Dave Taht via Starlink, bloat, Cake List, libreqos,
Jeremy Austin via Rpm
Hi Frank,
On November 16, 2026 5:31:27 PM GMT+01:00, "Frantisek (Frank) Borsik via Starlink" <starlink@lists.bufferbloat.net> wrote:
>Well, thank god, but even the very inception of this demented idea is
>troublesome and there will be more of this garbage coming soon.
While we agree that that amendmend was half-baked and deservedly got pruned, it is different from the attempts of european ex-monopoly telcos to extract payments not only from their paying custumers but also from content providers. Herd the goal was a good old bog standard tax on the economic activities of big tech in France, that is immune to the revenue shifting shennanigans big tech plays in Europe.
Side note, I had naively read the parliament's position on interconnects as a remedy against conscious under-peering games big eyeball ISPs play to strong arm additional payments from content providers... in reality that section likely would actually help such ISPs...
>
>We are in for a ride..
Are we ever not?
>
>All my best,
>
>Frank
>
>
>Frantisek (Frank) Borsik
>
>Gofer at LibreQoS
>
>
>*In loving memory of Dave Täht: *1965-2025
>
>https://libreqos.io/2025/04/01/in-loving-memory-of-dave/
>
>
>
>
>On Mon, Nov 16, 2026 at 8:12 AM Juliusz Chroboczek via LibreQoS <
>libreqos@lists.bufferbloat.net> wrote:
>
>> > *Original post by Dr. Peering:*
>> >
>> > *"The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own
>> country
>> > by taxing Gigabits.
>>
>> The whole set of amendments has been voted against, so the text will reach
>> the Senate without them. There's still a number of steps before the text
>> becomes law, but it seems unlikely that this particular amendment will be
>> ressucitated.
>>
>>
>> https://www.franceinfo.fr/economie/budget/budget-2026-que-va-t-il-se-passer-apres-le-rejet-de-la-partie-recettes-du-projet-de-loi-de-finances-par-les-deputes_7631201.html
>>
>> -- Juliusz
>>
>> _______________________________________________
>> LibreQoS mailing list -- libreqos@lists.bufferbloat.net
>> To unsubscribe send an email to libreqos-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
>>
>_______________________________________________
>Starlink mailing list -- starlink@lists.bufferbloat.net
>To unsubscribe send an email to starlink-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
--
Sent from my Android device with K-9 Mail. Please excuse my brevity.
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 40+ messages in thread
* [Starlink] Re: [Bloat] Re: [Cake] [NNagain] The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering)
2026-11-17 1:43 ` David P. Reed
@ 2026-11-17 12:33 ` Juliusz Chroboczek
2026-11-18 7:53 ` Frantisek Borsik
2026-11-18 9:25 ` David Lang
2 siblings, 0 replies; 40+ messages in thread
From: Juliusz Chroboczek @ 2026-11-17 12:33 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: David P. Reed
Cc: Sebastian Moeller, sascha,
Network Neutrality is back! Let´s make the technical aspects heard this time!,
Michael Welzl, Frantisek Borsik, Dave Taht via Starlink, bloat,
Cake List, libreqos, Jeremy Austin via Rpm
> But I don't get it. Why not just tax the physical assets, and not bother with
> byte counting at all?
Because the physical assets are not in France, so the content providers
are barely paying any French tax. If I'm reading the numbers correctly,
Google paid just 30.4M€ corporate tax in France in 2025 [1].
[1] https://entreprises.lefigaro.fr/google-france-75/entreprise-443061841
-- Juliusz
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 40+ messages in thread
* [Starlink] Re: [Bloat] Re: [LibreQoS] Re: The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering)
2026-11-16 22:53 ` Juliusz Chroboczek
@ 2026-11-17 15:59 ` Michael Richardson
2026-11-18 0:13 ` David Lang
0 siblings, 1 reply; 40+ messages in thread
From: Michael Richardson @ 2026-11-17 15:59 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: Network Neutrality is back! =?ISO-8859-1?Q?Let=B4s?= make the technical aspects heard this time!,
Dave Taht via Starlink, bloat, Cake List, libreqos,
Jeremy Austin via Rpm
{I would edit this down to one list, but I don't know which one}
Juliusz Chroboczek via Bloat <bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net> wrote:
> František said:
>>> Well, thank god, but even the very inception of this demented idea is
>>> troublesome and there will be more of this garbage coming soon.
> You'd need to ask somebody more familiar with French parliamentary
> procedure, but my understanding is that this is normal democratic debate
> working as intended.
Yes, I think that you are right: things reasonably worked as intended.
Many of us are just not used to that.
Maybe France has some proceedures that prevent "omnibus" bills.
We don't in Canada, and the US is even worse, of course.
Still: at least 10 of the representatives might need to learn more.
(Don't be too impressed with our PM public eloquence. He's shoving Bill C-39
through, after several other very harmful bills in 2025)
> The smart bit about the proposal is that it bases the tax on something
> that cannot be moved offshore, the amount of traffic received by the
> French user. (If the French user uses a VPN, then the holder of the ASN
> of the VPN provider would be taxed.)
To me, the idea of a tax on a bulk amount of data does seem smart.
I would have thought it better if it was all counted on the customer facing
port. Then it matters not at all if there is a VPN or not!!
It does suddenly matter if there are DDoS, and things like IETF DOTS,
or 25-year old "Diffedge" [where the CPE device tells the ISP about traffic
priorities, and also potentially about traffic which should be QoS'ed down to
1byte/week...] might suddenly be relevant.
TVs that sent Gb/s of data "home" would also be better noticed.
Under such a situation, a community mesh network, that has no outside
connectivity, but connects a person to the hair-dresser down the street's
appointment calendar, also running locally, takes on more value.
And that is something that also drivers better local resiliency!
(sorry, Juliusz, to preach to the choir...)
>> But other than that, yes, I fully agree that any non-profit platform/service
>> should simply clearly be excempt.
> What about a for-profit entity that hosts a freely available Debian mirror?
> What about a non-profit entity that provides commercial hosting?
> Many problems with the proposal, as you point out, but the general idea is
> interesting.
I agree: I think that the rates imagined where just 2-3 orders of magnitude
too big. If the rates are low enough, then trying to count smarter is dumb.
Better off to provide a refundable tax credit to lower income entities.
Canada's (retail) _carbon tax_ [among things Carney gutten for his CPC members],
was a net *CREDIT* to Canadians up to the upper-middle-income band.
Economists (including, historically, Carney...) said that the presence of the
tax on consumables would change buying patterns, even though the buyer would
get every cent of tax, plus some, back.
--
] Never tell me the odds! | ipv6 mesh networks [
] Michael Richardson, Sandelman Software Works | IoT architect [
] mcr@sandelman.ca http://www.sandelman.ca/ | ruby on rails [
] My working hours and your working hours may be different. [
] Please do not feel obligated to reply outside your normal working hours [
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 40+ messages in thread
* [Starlink] Re: [Bloat] Re: [LibreQoS] Re: The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering)
2026-11-17 15:59 ` Michael Richardson
@ 2026-11-18 0:13 ` David Lang
2026-11-18 0:36 ` [Starlink] Re: [NNagain] " Richard Roy
2026-11-18 1:16 ` [Starlink] " Michael Richardson
0 siblings, 2 replies; 40+ messages in thread
From: David Lang @ 2026-11-18 0:13 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: Michael Richardson
Cc: Network Neutrality is back! Let´s make the technical aspects heard this time!,
Dave Taht via Starlink, bloat, Cake List, libreqos,
Jeremy Austin via Rpm
Michael Richardson wrote:
> > The smart bit about the proposal is that it bases the tax on something
> > that cannot be moved offshore, the amount of traffic received by the
> > French user. (If the French user uses a VPN, then the holder of the ASN
> > of the VPN provider would be taxed.)
>
> To me, the idea of a tax on a bulk amount of data does seem smart.
Why? why should information transfer be taxed?
to give a silly example to make a point. taxing the information going to a
school to teach kids is going to discourage (even a tiny bit) learning.
How is this a good thing?
who exactly is this tax on information transfer supposed to help?
> TVs that sent Gb/s of data "home" would also be better noticed.
first off, who has Gb/s of upload capacity? and if it was all used by one tv,
they will notice no matter what.
But at more realistic rates, it will be lost in the amount of data downloaded
for streaming, uploaded from security cameras, etc.
David Lang
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 40+ messages in thread
* [Starlink] Re: [NNagain] Re: [Bloat] Re: [LibreQoS] Re: The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering)
2026-11-18 0:13 ` David Lang
@ 2026-11-18 0:36 ` Richard Roy
2026-11-18 1:16 ` [Starlink] " Michael Richardson
1 sibling, 0 replies; 40+ messages in thread
From: Richard Roy @ 2026-11-18 0:36 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: Network Neutrality is back! Let´s make the technical aspects heard this time!,
Michael Richardson
Cc: Dave Taht via Starlink, bloat, Cake List, libreqos,
Jeremy Austin via Rpm, David Lang
I think David has it right. Taxes (imposed by governments of, by and for the people) are supposed to "influence people's behavior" presumably for the "common good". Who is to be the beneficiary of taxing of information dissemination/flow?
RR
-----Original Message-----
From: David Lang via Nnagain <nnagain@lists.bufferbloat.net>
Sent: Tuesday, November 17, 2026 4:14 PM
To: Michael Richardson <mcr@sandelman.ca>
Cc: Network Neutrality is back! Let´s make the technical aspects heard this time! <nnagain@lists.bufferbloat.net>; Dave Taht via Starlink <starlink@lists.bufferbloat.net>; bloat <bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net>; Cake List <cake@lists.bufferbloat.net>; libreqos <libreqos@lists.bufferbloat.net>; Jeremy Austin via Rpm <rpm@lists.bufferbloat.net>; David Lang <david@lang.hm>
Subject: [NNagain] Re: [Bloat] Re: [LibreQoS] Re: The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering)
Michael Richardson wrote:
> > The smart bit about the proposal is that it bases the tax on something
> > that cannot be moved offshore, the amount of traffic received by the
> > French user. (If the French user uses a VPN, then the holder of the ASN
> > of the VPN provider would be taxed.)
>
> To me, the idea of a tax on a bulk amount of data does seem smart.
Why? why should information transfer be taxed?
to give a silly example to make a point. taxing the information going to a school to teach kids is going to discourage (even a tiny bit) learning.
How is this a good thing?
who exactly is this tax on information transfer supposed to help?
> TVs that sent Gb/s of data "home" would also be better noticed.
first off, who has Gb/s of upload capacity? and if it was all used by one tv, they will notice no matter what.
But at more realistic rates, it will be lost in the amount of data downloaded for streaming, uploaded from security cameras, etc.
David Lang
_______________________________________________
Nnagain mailing list -- nnagain@lists.bufferbloat.net To unsubscribe send an email to nnagain-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 40+ messages in thread
* [Starlink] Re: [Bloat] Re: [LibreQoS] Re: The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering)
2026-11-18 0:13 ` David Lang
2026-11-18 0:36 ` [Starlink] Re: [NNagain] " Richard Roy
@ 2026-11-18 1:16 ` Michael Richardson
2026-11-18 9:17 ` David Lang
1 sibling, 1 reply; 40+ messages in thread
From: Michael Richardson @ 2026-11-18 1:16 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: David Lang
Cc: Network Neutrality is back! Let´s make the technical aspects heard this time!,
Dave Taht via Starlink, bloat, Cake List, libreqos,
Jeremy Austin via Rpm
--------
David Lang <david@lang.hm> wrote:
>> > The smart bit about the proposal is that it bases the tax on something
>> > that cannot be moved offshore, the amount of traffic received by the
>> > French user. (If the French user uses a VPN, then the holder of the ASN
>> > of the VPN provider would be taxed.)
>>
>> To me, the idea of a tax on a bulk amount of data does seem smart.
> Why? why should information transfer be taxed?
Because governments need revenue in order to fund teachers in said school.
France in particular.
>> TVs that sent Gb/s of data "home" would also be better noticed.
> first off, who has Gb/s of upload capacity? and if it was all used by one tv,
> they will notice no matter what.
Numbers are approximate.
https://www.reddit.com/r/LGOLED/comments/1k7x96o/lg_g3_70gb_of_upload_data_this_week/
_LG G3 70GB of upload data this week_
> But at more realistic rates, it will be lost in the amount of data downloaded
> for streaming, uploaded from security cameras, etc.
--
] Never tell me the odds! | ipv6 mesh networks [
] Michael Richardson, Sandelman Software Works | IoT architect [
] mcr@sandelman.ca http://www.sandelman.ca/ | ruby on rails [
] My working hours and your working hours may be different. [
] Please do not feel obligated to reply outside your normal working hours [
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 40+ messages in thread
* [Starlink] Re: [NNagain] Re: [Bloat] The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering)
2026-11-02 14:30 ` [Starlink] Re: [NNagain] " Sascha Meinrath
2026-11-04 15:40 ` [Starlink] Re: [NNagain] " Sebastian Moeller
@ 2026-11-18 1:48 ` Raquel Renno Nunes
2026-11-18 7:46 ` Frantisek Borsik
2 siblings, 0 replies; 40+ messages in thread
From: Raquel Renno Nunes @ 2026-11-18 1:48 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: Network Neutrality is back! Let´s make the technical aspects heard this time!,
Michael Welzl, sascha@thexlab.org
Cc: Frantisek Borsik, Dave Taht via Starlink, bloat, Cake List,
libreqos, Jeremy Austin via Rpm, Sebastian Moeller
INTERNAL
Hi everyone,
Thanks for sharing this. Some civil society organisations have been following the attempts of taxing content providers on an EU and national levels for some years now, especially from the freedom of expression point of view. Our main concern is what the French proposal could mean for the quality and reliability of the services people use, and for the smaller ISPs and content providers they rely on.
The French amendment shares the sender-pays logic of the original European “fair share” proposal, but it works differently. Fair share would involve direct payments from large content providers to ISPs. Under the French amendment, the state would tax traffic delivered to French subscribers, and ISPs would have to identify senders and report traffic volumes. The amendment was adopted on 30 October, but as it was already mentioned in this thread, the Assembly rejected the budget bill at first reading on 4 November, so the vote did not bring the tax into force. But similar ideas were popping here and there in Europe, with a strong lobbing from legacy telcos.
South Korea shows<https://www.internetsociety.org/resources/internet-fragmentation/south-korea-sender-pays/> <https://www.internetsociety.org/resources/internet-fragmentation/south-korea-sender-pays/> how changing the rules around traffic delivery can affect the quality users experience. In France, I would be more concerned about services reducing video quality or dropping features, and about what that would mean for the range of content people can access.
That matters especially for local and independent providers. The amendment sets no minimum size or traffic threshold. A small broadcaster might respond by streaming fewer local events, leaving viewers with less coverage they may not be able to get elsewhere. Small ISPs would also face quarterly reporting requirements, with no express exemption. For a regional or community ISP that relies on wholesale connectivity, even identifying who sent the traffic may require help from its upstream provider. The details were left to a decree.
If this comes back in the budget debate, I’d like to see it assessed from the user’s side. Will people still have reliable access to the same range of services? And what would it take for small ISPs and independent providers to keep serving them?
A couple of references for the thread:
*
epicenter.works on net neutrality, including its submission to BEREC on IP interconnection<https://epicenter.works/thema/netzneutralitaet/page-3>
*
https://www.article19.org/resources/digital-networks-act-manufactured-crisis-that-could-break-europes-internet/
*
https://www.komaitis.org/write-share-ignite/the-fair-share-debate-a-tale-of-lobbying-capture-and-hypocrisy
Best,
Raquel
Raquel Renno Nunes (she/her/hers)
Senior Program Officer (Connectivity)
[cid:logo_1c766458-35ee-431a-9a22-e00b47cd2091.png]<https://www.article19.org> Defending freedom of expression
and information
www.article19.org<https://www.article19.org> Subscribe to our Newsletter<https://www.article19.org/ie-sign-up/> [cid:newsletter_02744340-c607-4374-8a37-11b8b216096d.png] <https://www.article19.org/ie-sign-up>
Notes:
- Please update your records with my new email address.
- We work half day Fridays (AM).
Follow us
[cid:bluesky1x_864ef831-9476-4116-88b8-2a3410741630.png]<https://bsky.app/profile/article19.bsky.social> [cid:facebook_2853baa0-f060-42e6-b448-6a8788c1b5dd.png] <https://www.facebook.com/article19org/> [cid:youtube_ffe95af1-d962-4acd-ab59-4eb4ea07466e.png] <https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCDB6E_x0xRSfF62b872n9YQ> [cid:linkedin_199dc89c-14aa-41cd-b2a7-37b8ae8d667d.png] <https://www.linkedin.com/company/article19> [cid:instagram_05fbcc72-6df2-442b-8c34-146d0e9d8c41.png] <https://www.instagram.com/article19org/> [cid:x_d21e0607-da5a-44a7-80c7-e2d86bc18a92.png] <https://twitter.com/intent/follow?screen_name=article19org>
[cid:big_give_signature_415x110_256_a0ec55fa-e9ee-4d20-be97-ed5b9cde8a22.png]<https://www.article19.org/donate/?mtm_campaign=SIgnature%20banner%20Big%20Give&mtm_source=email%20banner&mtm_medium=email>
________________________________
From: Sascha Meinrath via Starlink <starlink@lists.bufferbloat.net>
Sent: Monday, November 2, 2026 6:30 AM
To: Network Neutrality is back! Let´s make the technical aspects heard this time! <nnagain@lists.bufferbloat.net>; Michael Welzl <michawe@ifi.uio.no>
Cc: Frantisek Borsik <frantisek.borsik@gmail.com>; Dave Taht via Starlink <starlink@lists.bufferbloat.net>; bloat <bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net>; Cake List <cake@lists.bufferbloat.net>; libreqos <libreqos@lists.bufferbloat.net>; Jeremy Austin via Rpm <rpm@lists.bufferbloat.net>; Sebastian Moeller <moeller0@gmx.de>
Subject: [Starlink] Re: [NNagain] Re: [Bloat] The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering)
I can't wait until the French Parliament learns about VPNs... It would be
absolutely *wonderful* if all the ISPs passed along the tax to their
customers... and then taught all their customers that VPNed traffic would, for
obvious reasons, be exempted.
I find proposals like this to be absolutely idiotic -- and, they are yet another
step in the global data obfuscation arms race.
#encrypteverything
--Sascha
On 11/2/26 6:23 AM, Sebastian Moeller via Nnagain wrote:
> Hi Michael,
>
>> On Nov 2, 2026, at 08:44, Michael Welzl <michawe@ifi.uio.no> wrote:
>>
>> The tax is 5 cents per Gigabyte. This is insane.
>
> Back of the envelop calculations for video streaming (assuming this to be the one category driving most of the sustained capacity usage):
>
> common use seems to be HD streaming (say on average at 5 Mbps), with say 2 hours per day, 7 days per week:
>
> (5 * 1000^2) * (60 * 60 * 2 * 30) / (8 * 1000^3) = 135 GB
> -> 135 * 0.055 = 7.425 Euro/month
>
> typical cost for midrange (ad-free) video streaming in france: 8-15 Euro
>
> depending on the reference contract tier, the tax almost as large as the total revenue, no way this could be priced-in without significant price increases.
>
> The proposed tax indeed seems quite steep, however it is capped at 15% of revenue in france or 2% of world-wide revenue
>
> So that would get this more in like with a 15% tax... on revenue, still nothing to sneeze at, but a far cry from the numbers one gets when simply multiplying...
>
> Regards
> Sebastian
>
> P.S.: My take this is half-baked and will not make it through the further legislative process in that form.
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>> It goes against how we agree to use the Internet.
>>
>> English version:
>> "France has recently approved a highly controversial "Internet Traffic
>> Tax" (or Gigabyte Tax) as part of the 2027 budget bill amendments. The
>> new levy targets digital content providers based on the volume of data
>> they transmit to French internet users, which is monitored by network
>> operators and Internet Service Providers (ISPs) heavily utilizing
>> Internet Exchange Points like France-IX."
>>
>> Google AI summary:
>> "Key Metrics & Tax Rates
>> • €0.055 per gigabyte charged to content providers.
>> • Capped at 15% of a provider's French revenue.
>> • Capped at 2% of a provider's global revenue.
>> • Measured directly by French network operators and ISPs."
>>
>>
>> On 2026-10-31 13:56, Frantisek Borsik wrote:
>>> Crossposting, because this garbage idea might "inspire" more countries
>>> and
>>> have a horrible impact also on bufferbloat everywhere.
>>>
>>> *Original post by Dr. Peering:*
>>>
>>> *"The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own
>>> country
>>> by taxing Gigabits. Here’s Octave Klaba's excellent analysis [in
>>> French,
>>> link below] showing just how insane the finance bill actually is. The
>>> IXP
>>> taxation amount is, just for starters, ridiculous!"*
>>>
>>> https://x.com/drpeering/status/2116468659392807
>>> <https://x.com/drpeering/status/2116468659392807381?a=E-elnbppn-MAi-LNIrU&s=46>
>>>
>>> *Octave's post:*
>>>
>>> https://fr.linkedin.com/posts/octave-klaba-3a0b3632_jai-lu-lamendement-i-1358-au-plf-2027-activity-7522219045576888320-uqkw
>>>
>>> *Copy+paste:*
>>>
>>> J'ai lu l'amendement I-1358 au PLF 2027, adopté ce vendredi à
>>> l'Assemblée :
>>> une taxe de 0,055 € par Go envoyé vers les abonnés des FAI français. Le
>>> chiffre est abstrait, alors comparons-le. Corrigez-moi si vous voyez
>>> des
>>> erreurs.
>>>
>>> Deux comparaisons et un cas concret :
>>>
>>> 1. Le transit et le peering. Un port 100 Gbps coûte environ 6 300 € par
>>> mois chez un fournisseur de transit mondial. En interconnexion directe
>>> avec
>>> un FAI européen, compter 3 à 5 fois plus, soit 20 à 30 k€ par mois. Sur
>>> ce
>>> port (a), la taxe atteint 1,02 M€ par mois, soit environ 3400 % à 16300
>>> %
>>> du prix d'une interconnexion vers les FAI français. On change donc
>>> profondément le modèle économique de la bande passante en France.
>>>
>>> 2. Les hyperscalers sont critiqués pour le prix de leur trafic sortant,
>>> qui
>>> va d'environ 0,08€ à 0,045€ par Go selon le volume. La taxe, 0,055 €
>>> par
>>> Go, représente 68 % à 123 % de ce prix. On parle donc de doubler, pour
>>> le
>>> trafic vers la France, un prix déjà jugé trop élevé !
>>>
>>> 3. Le cas d'OVHcloud. Nous envoyons de l'ordre de 500 Gbps au 95e
>>> percentile vers les FAI français, soit environ 324 Gbps en moyenne. Sur
>>> un
>>> an, la taxe brute atteindrait 70 M€. Le texte la plafonne à 15 % du CA
>>> réalisé en France ou à 2 % du CA mondial, soit entre environ 23 et 70
>>> M€
>>> par an que nous devrions collecter pour l'État, et donc répercuter sur
>>> nos
>>> clients.
>>>
>>> Conclusions :
>>>
>>> 1. Une taxe porte en général sur une petite fraction de son assiette.
>>> Celle-ci vaut plus de 3000 % du coût du transit, et environ 100 % du
>>> prix
>>> public des hyperscalers. Rappelez-vous la loi SREN, votée pour
>>> supprimer
>>> les frais de transfert qui empêchaient les clients de quitter un
>>> fournisseur cloud. Ici, on parle de doubler le prix du trafic sortant
>>> vers
>>> les internautes français, un prix déjà très problématique.
>>>
>>> 2. Le garde-fou, un plafond calculé sur le chiffre d'affaires, est
>>> incohérent. Ce chiffre d'affaires couvre des serveurs, du stockage, des
>>> datacenters et des équipes sans rapport avec la bande passante. C'est
>>> comme
>>> créer une taxe calculée sur la consommation électrique des usines
>>> automobiles en France, plafonnée à 15 % du chiffre d'affaires des
>>> constructeurs. Quel rapport entre les deux ?
>>>
>>> 3. Une taxe nationale de ce type frappe à coup sûr les entreprises
>>> établies
>>> en France, alors que leurs concurrents mondiaux sans présence en France
>>> livrent le même trafic aux mêmes FAI français sans payer cette taxe en
>>> pratique. Cela crée une distorsion de concurrence au détriment des
>>> acteurs
>>> nationaux et déclasse les entreprises qui embauchent en France. Une
>>> taxe
>>> qui produit l'effet inverse serait une meilleure approche.
>>>
>>> (a) Facturé au 95e percentile, ce port n'est pas plein en permanence :
>>> avec
>>> un profil journalier type (22 % vers 4 h, 90 % vers 21 h), il
>>> transporte en
>>> moyenne 57 % de sa capacité, soit 18,6 millions de Go par mois.
>>>
>>>
>>> All the best,
>>>
>>> Frank
>>> Frantisek (Frank) Borsik
>>>
>>> In loving memory of Dave Täht: 1965-2025
>>> https://libreqos.io/2025/04/01/in-loving-memory-of-dave/
>>>
>>>
>>> https://www.linkedin.com/in/frantisekborsik
>>> Signal, Telegram, WhatsApp: +421919416714 <+421%20919%20416%20714>
>>> iMessage, mobile: +420775230885 <775%20230%20885>
>>> Skype: casioa5302ca
>>> frantisek.borsik@gmail.com
>>> _______________________________________________
>>> Bloat mailing list -- bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net
>>> To unsubscribe send an email to bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
>> _______________________________________________
>> Bloat mailing list -- bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net
>> To unsubscribe send an email to bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
>> _______________________________________________
>> Bloat mailing list -- bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net
>> To unsubscribe send an email to bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> Nnagain mailing list -- nnagain@lists.bufferbloat.net
> To unsubscribe send an email to nnagain-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
--
Sascha Meinrath
Director, X-Lab
Palmer Chair in Telecommunications
Penn State University
_______________________________________________
Starlink mailing list -- starlink@lists.bufferbloat.net
To unsubscribe send an email to starlink-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 40+ messages in thread
* [Starlink] Re: [NNagain] Re: [Bloat] The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering)
2026-11-02 14:30 ` [Starlink] Re: [NNagain] " Sascha Meinrath
2026-11-04 15:40 ` [Starlink] Re: [NNagain] " Sebastian Moeller
2026-11-18 1:48 ` [Starlink] Re: [NNagain] " Raquel Renno Nunes
@ 2026-11-18 7:46 ` Frantisek Borsik
2 siblings, 0 replies; 40+ messages in thread
From: Frantisek Borsik @ 2026-11-18 7:46 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: sascha
Cc: Network Neutrality is back! Let´s make the technical aspects heard this time!,
Michael Welzl, Dave Taht via Starlink, bloat, Cake List, libreqos,
Jeremy Austin via Rpm, Sebastian Moeller
🍻
Frantisek Borsik reacted via Gmail
<https://www.google.com/gmail/about/?utm_source=gmail-in-product&utm_medium=et&utm_campaign=emojireactionemail#app>
On Mon, Nov 2, 2026 at 6:30 AM Sascha Meinrath <sascha@thexlab.org> wrote:
> I can't wait until the French Parliament learns about VPNs... It would be
> absolutely *wonderful* if all the ISPs passed along the tax to their
> customers... and then taught all their customers that VPNed traffic would,
> for
> obvious reasons, be exempted.
>
> I find proposals like this to be absolutely idiotic -- and, they are yet
> another
> step in the global data obfuscation arms race.
>
> #encrypteverything
>
> --Sascha
>
> On 11/2/26 6:23 AM, Sebastian Moeller via Nnagain wrote:
> > Hi Michael,
> >
> >> On Nov 2, 2026, at 08:44, Michael Welzl <michawe@ifi.uio.no> wrote:
> >>
> >> The tax is 5 cents per Gigabyte. This is insane.
> >
> > Back of the envelop calculations for video streaming (assuming this to
> be the one category driving most of the sustained capacity usage):
> >
> > common use seems to be HD streaming (say on average at 5 Mbps), with say
> 2 hours per day, 7 days per week:
> >
> > (5 * 1000^2) * (60 * 60 * 2 * 30) / (8 * 1000^3) = 135 GB
> > -> 135 * 0.055 = 7.425 Euro/month
> >
> > typical cost for midrange (ad-free) video streaming in france: 8-15 Euro
> >
> > depending on the reference contract tier, the tax almost as large as the
> total revenue, no way this could be priced-in without significant price
> increases.
> >
> > The proposed tax indeed seems quite steep, however it is capped at 15%
> of revenue in france or 2% of world-wide revenue
> >
> > So that would get this more in like with a 15% tax... on revenue, still
> nothing to sneeze at, but a far cry from the numbers one gets when simply
> multiplying...
> >
> > Regards
> > Sebastian
> >
> > P.S.: My take this is half-baked and will not make it through the
> further legislative process in that form.
> >
> >
> >
> >
> >
> >
> >
> >> It goes against how we agree to use the Internet.
> >>
> >> English version:
> >> "France has recently approved a highly controversial "Internet Traffic
> >> Tax" (or Gigabyte Tax) as part of the 2027 budget bill amendments. The
> >> new levy targets digital content providers based on the volume of data
> >> they transmit to French internet users, which is monitored by network
> >> operators and Internet Service Providers (ISPs) heavily utilizing
> >> Internet Exchange Points like France-IX."
> >>
> >> Google AI summary:
> >> "Key Metrics & Tax Rates
> >> • €0.055 per gigabyte charged to content providers.
> >> • Capped at 15% of a provider's French revenue.
> >> • Capped at 2% of a provider's global revenue.
> >> • Measured directly by French network operators and ISPs."
> >>
> >>
> >> On 2026-10-31 13:56, Frantisek Borsik wrote:
> >>> Crossposting, because this garbage idea might "inspire" more countries
> >>> and
> >>> have a horrible impact also on bufferbloat everywhere.
> >>>
> >>> *Original post by Dr. Peering:*
> >>>
> >>> *"The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own
> >>> country
> >>> by taxing Gigabits. Here’s Octave Klaba's excellent analysis [in
> >>> French,
> >>> link below] showing just how insane the finance bill actually is. The
> >>> IXP
> >>> taxation amount is, just for starters, ridiculous!"*
> >>>
> >>> https://x.com/drpeering/status/2116468659392807
> >>> <
> https://x.com/drpeering/status/2116468659392807381?a=E-elnbppn-MAi-LNIrU&s=46
> >
> >>>
> >>> *Octave's post:*
> >>>
> >>>
> https://fr.linkedin.com/posts/octave-klaba-3a0b3632_jai-lu-lamendement-i-1358-au-plf-2027-activity-7522219045576888320-uqkw
> >>>
> >>> *Copy+paste:*
> >>>
> >>> J'ai lu l'amendement I-1358 au PLF 2027, adopté ce vendredi à
> >>> l'Assemblée :
> >>> une taxe de 0,055 € par Go envoyé vers les abonnés des FAI français. Le
> >>> chiffre est abstrait, alors comparons-le. Corrigez-moi si vous voyez
> >>> des
> >>> erreurs.
> >>>
> >>> Deux comparaisons et un cas concret :
> >>>
> >>> 1. Le transit et le peering. Un port 100 Gbps coûte environ 6 300 € par
> >>> mois chez un fournisseur de transit mondial. En interconnexion directe
> >>> avec
> >>> un FAI européen, compter 3 à 5 fois plus, soit 20 à 30 k€ par mois. Sur
> >>> ce
> >>> port (a), la taxe atteint 1,02 M€ par mois, soit environ 3400 % à 16300
> >>> %
> >>> du prix d'une interconnexion vers les FAI français. On change donc
> >>> profondément le modèle économique de la bande passante en France.
> >>>
> >>> 2. Les hyperscalers sont critiqués pour le prix de leur trafic sortant,
> >>> qui
> >>> va d'environ 0,08€ à 0,045€ par Go selon le volume. La taxe, 0,055 €
> >>> par
> >>> Go, représente 68 % à 123 % de ce prix. On parle donc de doubler, pour
> >>> le
> >>> trafic vers la France, un prix déjà jugé trop élevé !
> >>>
> >>> 3. Le cas d'OVHcloud. Nous envoyons de l'ordre de 500 Gbps au 95e
> >>> percentile vers les FAI français, soit environ 324 Gbps en moyenne. Sur
> >>> un
> >>> an, la taxe brute atteindrait 70 M€. Le texte la plafonne à 15 % du CA
> >>> réalisé en France ou à 2 % du CA mondial, soit entre environ 23 et 70
> >>> M€
> >>> par an que nous devrions collecter pour l'État, et donc répercuter sur
> >>> nos
> >>> clients.
> >>>
> >>> Conclusions :
> >>>
> >>> 1. Une taxe porte en général sur une petite fraction de son assiette.
> >>> Celle-ci vaut plus de 3000 % du coût du transit, et environ 100 % du
> >>> prix
> >>> public des hyperscalers. Rappelez-vous la loi SREN, votée pour
> >>> supprimer
> >>> les frais de transfert qui empêchaient les clients de quitter un
> >>> fournisseur cloud. Ici, on parle de doubler le prix du trafic sortant
> >>> vers
> >>> les internautes français, un prix déjà très problématique.
> >>>
> >>> 2. Le garde-fou, un plafond calculé sur le chiffre d'affaires, est
> >>> incohérent. Ce chiffre d'affaires couvre des serveurs, du stockage, des
> >>> datacenters et des équipes sans rapport avec la bande passante. C'est
> >>> comme
> >>> créer une taxe calculée sur la consommation électrique des usines
> >>> automobiles en France, plafonnée à 15 % du chiffre d'affaires des
> >>> constructeurs. Quel rapport entre les deux ?
> >>>
> >>> 3. Une taxe nationale de ce type frappe à coup sûr les entreprises
> >>> établies
> >>> en France, alors que leurs concurrents mondiaux sans présence en France
> >>> livrent le même trafic aux mêmes FAI français sans payer cette taxe en
> >>> pratique. Cela crée une distorsion de concurrence au détriment des
> >>> acteurs
> >>> nationaux et déclasse les entreprises qui embauchent en France. Une
> >>> taxe
> >>> qui produit l'effet inverse serait une meilleure approche.
> >>>
> >>> (a) Facturé au 95e percentile, ce port n'est pas plein en permanence :
> >>> avec
> >>> un profil journalier type (22 % vers 4 h, 90 % vers 21 h), il
> >>> transporte en
> >>> moyenne 57 % de sa capacité, soit 18,6 millions de Go par mois.
> >>>
> >>>
> >>> All the best,
> >>>
> >>> Frank
> >>> Frantisek (Frank) Borsik
> >>>
> >>> In loving memory of Dave Täht: 1965-2025
> >>> https://libreqos.io/2025/04/01/in-loving-memory-of-dave/
> >>>
> >>>
> >>> https://www.linkedin.com/in/frantisekborsik
> >>> Signal, Telegram, WhatsApp: +421919416714 <+421%20919%20416%20714>
> <+421%20919%20416%20714>
> >>> iMessage, mobile: +420775230885 <775%20230%20885> <775%20230%20885>
> >>> Skype: casioa5302ca
> >>> frantisek.borsik@gmail.com
> >>> _______________________________________________
> >>> Bloat mailing list -- bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net
> >>> To unsubscribe send an email to bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
> >> _______________________________________________
> >> Bloat mailing list -- bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net
> >> To unsubscribe send an email to bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
> >> _______________________________________________
> >> Bloat mailing list -- bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net
> >> To unsubscribe send an email to bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
> >
> >
> > _______________________________________________
> > Nnagain mailing list -- nnagain@lists.bufferbloat.net
> > To unsubscribe send an email to nnagain-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
>
> --
> Sascha Meinrath
> Director, X-Lab
> Palmer Chair in Telecommunications
> Penn State University
>
>
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 40+ messages in thread
* [Starlink] Re: [Cake] Re: [NNagain] [Bloat] The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering)
2026-11-04 17:57 ` [Starlink] Re: [Cake] " David P. Reed
2026-11-05 9:05 ` [Starlink] Re: [Cake] " Sebastian Moeller
@ 2026-11-18 7:48 ` Frantisek Borsik
2026-11-18 12:12 ` Sascha Meinrath
1 sibling, 1 reply; 40+ messages in thread
From: Frantisek Borsik @ 2026-11-18 7:48 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: David P. Reed
Cc: Sebastian Moeller, Sascha Meinrath,
Network Neutrality is back! Let´s make the technical aspects heard this time!,
Michael Welzl, Dave Taht via Starlink, bloat, Cake List, libreqos,
Jeremy Austin via Rpm
🙏
Frantisek Borsik reacted via Gmail
<https://www.google.com/gmail/about/?utm_source=gmail-in-product&utm_medium=et&utm_campaign=emojireactionemail#app>
On Wed, Nov 4, 2026 at 9:57 AM David P. Reed <dpreed@deepplum.com> wrote:
> Sascha, et al. -
>
>
>
> The law is never about "how will we enforce it", because (sarcasm on) such
> petty details as enforcement is not germane to Governments' Will to Control
> (sarcasm off).
>
>
>
> When they try to dream up "technical means" for enforcement, rather than
> just putting the law on the books, they may all of a sudden try to
> interfere with all kinds of Internet mechanisms. This won't be easy, but we
> have the history of Thought Control starting with the early Internet
> deployments where the words "breast" and so forth were supposed to be
> detected by all Internet routers in all packets. Senator Exon of the US got
> some "tech pundits" to say that was possible and easy, and I got involved
> politically to suppress the "Exon Box" idea, which was politically gaining
> steam, even among "progressives.:
>
>
>
> The issue, of course, is that the legislators invent dynamite-scale
> enforcement mechanisms that interfere with every damn thing in order to
> solve a pretty narrow problem.
>
> Note that the Post Office in most countries are NOT allowed to inspect all
> letters and packages. But the fascist instinct exists everywhere, even
> France. "There oughta be a law" is what voters first turn to, both on the
> Left and the RIght - which is why just saying "The Rule of Law" is not
> equivalent to democracy.
>
>
>
> If you want to charge a tax on a behavior of a consumer, you basically
> need to surveill actual consumption by each individual, which is not
> technically feasible. No more than enforcing a law that says you can't
> listen to the words of Islam or read Mein Kampf.
>
> I don't get really upset about this until the Tax Policy starts to move to
> an implementation that destroys our rights to privacy (meaning the right to
> be left alone, not the right to keep data secret).
>
>
>
> On Wednesday, November 4, 2026 12:03, "Sebastian Moeller via Cake" <
> cake@lists.bufferbloat.net> said:
>
> > Hi Sascha,
> >
> > On November 4, 2026 5:20:01 PM GMT+01:00, Sascha Meinrath
> > <sascha@thexlab.org> wrote:
> > >Hi Sebastian,
> > >
> > >My point is that if I VPNed to a point outside France, then a French
> ISP would
> > have no way to know that I've accessed the type of media that should be
> taxed.
> >
> >
> > A misunderstanding, the amendment prposes to tax every single bit
> independent of
> > the source... it makes zero exemptions, not for FOSS, not for non
> commercially ial
> > entities. Sure the motivation is to tax big tech primarily, but the
> current
> > (half-baked) legal implementation is not differentiating...
> >
> >
> > > In essence, VPNs (and proxy services) would create extraordinary
> problems for
> > even instrumenting the proposed taxing regime.
> >
> > How? Like with a CDN the tax would hit the vpn provider... the ASN of
> the source
> > IP....
> >
> >
> >
> >
> > >
> > >--Sascha
> > >
> > >On 11/4/26 10:40 AM, Sebastian Moeller wrote:
> > >> Hi Sascha,
> > >>
> > >>
> > >>> On Nov 2, 2026, at 15:30, Sascha Meinrath <sascha@thexlab.org>
> > wrote:
> > >>>
> > >>> I can't wait until the French Parliament learns about VPNs... It
> > would be absolutely *wonderful* if all the ISPs passed along the tax to
> their
> > customers... and then taught all their customers that VPNed traffic
> would, for
> > obvious reasons, be exempted.
> > >>
> > >> Not how this is supposed to work: the ISP aggregates its end-customer
> > bound traffic volume by ASN and reports these aggregates quarterly, the
> tax office
> > sends the ASNs the tax bill. VPN does not really matter, except now it
> is the VPN
> > provider that is on the hook for the money. The amendment does not
> address VPNs
> > but for CDNs that are in a similar picckle the idea is that CDN
> operators either
> > pass on the cost or "eat" it themselves (both half-baked ideas). The
> only oddity
> > VPNs add is that they typically receive no money from the actual content
> > providers, but the end users.
> > >>
> > >>>
> > >>> I find proposals like this to be absolutely idiotic -- and, they are
> > yet another step in the global data obfuscation arms race.
> > >>
> > >> Oh, that proposal is pretty half-baked, no arggument there, but I
> think
> > we differ in which of its half-baked-ness we consider worst ;)
> > >>
> > >>>
> > >>> #encrypteverything
> > >>
> > >> Well, if you look what this is supposed to operate on encryption is
> not
> > really an option, as this operates on source and destination IP
> addresses, that
> > are somewhat prickly to encrypt if you want packets delivered...
> > >>
> > >>>
> > >>> --Sascha
> > >>>
> > >>> On 11/2/26 6:23 AM, Sebastian Moeller via Nnagain wrote:
> > >>>> Hi Michael,
> > >>>>> On Nov 2, 2026, at 08:44, Michael Welzl
> > <michawe@ifi.uio.no> wrote:
> > >>>>>
> > >>>>> The tax is 5 cents per Gigabyte. This is insane.
> > >>>> Back of the envelop calculations for video streaming (assuming
> > this to be the one category driving most of the sustained capacity
> usage):
> > >>>> common use seems to be HD streaming (say on average at 5 Mbps),
> > with say 2 hours per day, 7 days per week:
> > >>>> (5 * 1000^2) * (60 * 60 * 2 * 30) / (8 * 1000^3) = 135 GB
> > >>>> -> 135 * 0.055 = 7.425 Euro/month
> > >>>> typical cost for midrange (ad-free) video streaming in france:
> > 8-15 Euro
> > >>>> depending on the reference contract tier, the tax almost as large
> > as the total revenue, no way this could be priced-in without significant
> price
> > increases.
> > >>>> The proposed tax indeed seems quite steep, however it is capped
> > at 15% of revenue in france or 2% of world-wide revenue
> > >>>> So that would get this more in like with a 15% tax... on revenue,
> > still nothing to sneeze at, but a far cry from the numbers one gets when
> simply
> > multiplying...
> > >>>> Regards
> > >>>> Sebastian
> > >>>> P.S.: My take this is half-baked and will not make it through the
> > further legislative process in that form.
> > >>>>> It goes against how we agree to use the Internet.
> > >>>>>
> > >>>>> English version:
> > >>>>> "France has recently approved a highly controversial
> > "Internet Traffic
> > >>>>> Tax" (or Gigabyte Tax) as part of the 2027 budget bill
> > amendments. The
> > >>>>> new levy targets digital content providers based on the
> > volume of data
> > >>>>> they transmit to French internet users, which is monitored by
> > network
> > >>>>> operators and Internet Service Providers (ISPs) heavily
> > utilizing
> > >>>>> Internet Exchange Points like France-IX."
> > >>>>>
> > >>>>> Google AI summary:
> > >>>>> "Key Metrics & Tax Rates
> > >>>>> • €0.055 per gigabyte charged to content
> > providers.
> > >>>>> • Capped at 15% of a provider's French revenue.
> > >>>>> • Capped at 2% of a provider's global revenue.
> > >>>>> • Measured directly by French network operators and
> > ISPs."
> > >>>>>
> > >>>>>
> > >>>>> On 2026-10-31 13:56, Frantisek Borsik wrote:
> > >>>>>> Crossposting, because this garbage idea might "inspire"
> > more countries
> > >>>>>> and
> > >>>>>> have a horrible impact also on bufferbloat everywhere.
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> *Original post by Dr. Peering:*
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> *"The French have decided to destroy the Internet within
> > their own
> > >>>>>> country
> > >>>>>> by taxing Gigabits. Here’s Octave Klaba's excellent
> > analysis [in
> > >>>>>> French,
> > >>>>>> link below] showing just how insane the finance bill
> > actually is. The
> > >>>>>> IXP
> > >>>>>> taxation amount is, just for starters, ridiculous!"*
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> https://x.com/drpeering/status/2116468659392807
> > >>>>>>
> > <
> https://x.com/drpeering/status/2116468659392807381?a=E-elnbppn-MAi-LNIrU&s=46
> >
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> *Octave's post:*
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>>
> >
> https://fr.linkedin.com/posts/octave-klaba-3a0b3632_jai-lu-lamendement-i-1358-au-plf-2027-activity-7522219045576888320-uqkw
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> *Copy+paste:*
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> J'ai lu l'amendement I-1358 au PLF 2027, adopté ce
> > vendredi à
> > >>>>>> l'Assemblée :
> > >>>>>> une taxe de 0,055 € par Go envoyé vers les
> > abonnés des FAI français. Le
> > >>>>>> chiffre est abstrait, alors comparons-le. Corrigez-moi si
> > vous voyez
> > >>>>>> des
> > >>>>>> erreurs.
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> Deux comparaisons et un cas concret :
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> 1. Le transit et le peering. Un port 100 Gbps coûte
> > environ 6 300 € par
> > >>>>>> mois chez un fournisseur de transit mondial. En
> > interconnexion directe
> > >>>>>> avec
> > >>>>>> un FAI européen, compter 3 à 5 fois plus,
> > soit 20 à 30 k€ par mois. Sur
> > >>>>>> ce
> > >>>>>> port (a), la taxe atteint 1,02 M€ par mois, soit
> > environ 3400 % à 16300
> > >>>>>> %
> > >>>>>> du prix d'une interconnexion vers les FAI
> > français. On change donc
> > >>>>>> profondément le modèle économique de
> > la bande passante en France.
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> 2. Les hyperscalers sont critiqués pour le prix de
> > leur trafic sortant,
> > >>>>>> qui
> > >>>>>> va d'environ 0,08€ à 0,045€ par Go selon
> > le volume. La taxe, 0,055 €
> > >>>>>> par
> > >>>>>> Go, représente 68 % à 123 % de ce prix. On
> > parle donc de doubler, pour
> > >>>>>> le
> > >>>>>> trafic vers la France, un prix déjà
> > jugé trop élevé !
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> 3. Le cas d'OVHcloud. Nous envoyons de l'ordre de 500
> > Gbps au 95e
> > >>>>>> percentile vers les FAI français, soit environ 324
> > Gbps en moyenne. Sur
> > >>>>>> un
> > >>>>>> an, la taxe brute atteindrait 70 M€. Le texte la
> > plafonne à 15 % du CA
> > >>>>>> réalisé en France ou à 2 % du CA
> > mondial, soit entre environ 23 et 70
> > >>>>>> M€
> > >>>>>> par an que nous devrions collecter pour l'État, et
> > donc répercuter sur
> > >>>>>> nos
> > >>>>>> clients.
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> Conclusions :
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> 1. Une taxe porte en général sur une petite
> > fraction de son assiette.
> > >>>>>> Celle-ci vaut plus de 3000 % du coût du transit, et
> > environ 100 % du
> > >>>>>> prix
> > >>>>>> public des hyperscalers. Rappelez-vous la loi SREN,
> > votée pour
> > >>>>>> supprimer
> > >>>>>> les frais de transfert qui empêchaient les clients
> > de quitter un
> > >>>>>> fournisseur cloud. Ici, on parle de doubler le prix du
> > trafic sortant
> > >>>>>> vers
> > >>>>>> les internautes français, un prix
> > déjà très problématique.
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> 2. Le garde-fou, un plafond calculé sur le chiffre
> > d'affaires, est
> > >>>>>> incohérent. Ce chiffre d'affaires couvre des
> > serveurs, du stockage, des
> > >>>>>> datacenters et des équipes sans rapport avec la
> > bande passante. C'est
> > >>>>>> comme
> > >>>>>> créer une taxe calculée sur la consommation
> > électrique des usines
> > >>>>>> automobiles en France, plafonnée à 15 % du
> > chiffre d'affaires des
> > >>>>>> constructeurs. Quel rapport entre les deux ?
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> 3. Une taxe nationale de ce type frappe à coup
> > sûr les entreprises
> > >>>>>> établies
> > >>>>>> en France, alors que leurs concurrents mondiaux sans
> > présence en France
> > >>>>>> livrent le même trafic aux mêmes FAI
> > français sans payer cette taxe en
> > >>>>>> pratique. Cela crée une distorsion de concurrence
> > au détriment des
> > >>>>>> acteurs
> > >>>>>> nationaux et déclasse les entreprises qui
> > embauchent en France. Une
> > >>>>>> taxe
> > >>>>>> qui produit l'effet inverse serait une meilleure
> > approche.
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> (a) Facturé au 95e percentile, ce port n'est pas
> > plein en permanence :
> > >>>>>> avec
> > >>>>>> un profil journalier type (22 % vers 4 h, 90 % vers 21
> > h), il
> > >>>>>> transporte en
> > >>>>>> moyenne 57 % de sa capacité, soit 18,6 millions de
> > Go par mois.
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> All the best,
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> Frank
> > >>>>>> Frantisek (Frank) Borsik
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> In loving memory of Dave Täht: 1965-2025
> > >>>>>> https://libreqos.io/2025/04/01/in-loving-memory-of-dave/
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> https://www.linkedin.com/in/frantisekborsik
> > >>>>>> Signal, Telegram, WhatsApp: +421919416714
> <+421%20919%20416%20714>
> > <+421%20919%20416%20714>
> > >>>>>> iMessage, mobile: +420775230885 <775%20230%20885>
> <775%20230%20885>
> > >>>>>> Skype: casioa5302ca
> > >>>>>> frantisek.borsik@gmail.com
> > >>>>>> _______________________________________________
> > >>>>>> Bloat mailing list -- bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net
> > >>>>>> To unsubscribe send an email to
> > bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
> > >>>>> _______________________________________________
> > >>>>> Bloat mailing list -- bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net
> > >>>>> To unsubscribe send an email to
> > bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
> > >>>>> _______________________________________________
> > >>>>> Bloat mailing list -- bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net
> > >>>>> To unsubscribe send an email to
> > bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
> > >>>> _______________________________________________
> > >>>> Nnagain mailing list -- nnagain@lists.bufferbloat.net
> > >>>> To unsubscribe send an email to
> > nnagain-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
> > >>>
> > >>> --
> > >>> Sascha Meinrath
> > >>> Director, X-Lab
> > >>> Palmer Chair in Telecommunications
> > >>> Penn State University
> > >>
> > >>
> > >
> >
> > --
> > Sent from my Android device with K-9 Mail. Please excuse my brevity.
> > _______________________________________________
> > Cake mailing list -- cake@lists.bufferbloat.net
> > To unsubscribe send an email to cake-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
> >
>
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 40+ messages in thread
* [Starlink] Re: [NNagain] [Bloat] The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering)
2026-11-04 18:33 ` [Starlink] " Sascha Meinrath
2026-11-04 19:09 ` Sebastian Moeller
@ 2026-11-18 7:49 ` Frantisek Borsik
1 sibling, 0 replies; 40+ messages in thread
From: Frantisek Borsik @ 2026-11-18 7:49 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: sascha
Cc: Sebastian Moeller,
Network Neutrality is back! Let´s make the technical aspects heard this time!,
Michael Welzl, Dave Taht via Starlink, bloat, Cake List, libreqos,
Jeremy Austin via Rpm
🙏
Frantisek Borsik reacted via Gmail
<https://www.google.com/gmail/about/?utm_source=gmail-in-product&utm_medium=et&utm_campaign=emojireactionemail#app>
On Wed, Nov 4, 2026 at 10:33 AM Sascha Meinrath <sascha@thexlab.org> wrote:
> On 11/4/26 12:03 PM, Sebastian Moeller wrote:> Hi Sascha,
> >
> > On November 4, 2026 5:20:01 PM GMT+01:00, Sascha Meinrath <
> sascha@thexlab.org> wrote:
> >> Hi Sebastian,
> >>
> >> My point is that if I VPNed to a point outside France, then a French
> ISP would have no way to know that I've accessed the type of media that
> should be taxed.
> >
> > A misunderstanding, the amendment prposes to tax every single bit
> independent of the source... it makes zero exemptions, not for FOSS, not
> for non commercially ial entities. Sure the motivation is to tax big tech
> primarily, but the current (half-baked) legal implementation is not
> differentiating...
> >
> >> In essence, VPNs (and proxy services) would create extraordinary
> problems for even instrumenting the proposed taxing regime.
> >
> > How? Like with a CDN the tax would hit the vpn provider... the ASN of
> the source IP....
>
> A VPN provider (at least any that I would recommend using) would not know
> the
> content being VPNed. In essence, someone in France could VPN to a
> different
> country; neither the ISP or the VPN provider would know the specific
> content
> being accessed (Note: while some VPN's do track their users, none of the
> privacy
> protecting ones would do so); meanwhile, the media company -- even
> assuming some
> sort of extra-territorial leverage of French law outside of France -- may
> have
> no idea that the end destination of the media in question is within France.
>
> Long story short, neither the VPN provider, the French ISP, nor the media
> company would necessarily know that a specific piece of media was destined
> for
> consumption within France. This is, of course, exactly the conundrum
> facing
> authoritarian and censorial regimes around the globe -- in this case, one
> is
> dodging tax surveillance, but the technical underpinnings are very much
> the same.
>
> All in all, a dumb & doomed (proposed) law.
>
> --Sascha
>
> >
> >
> >
> >>
> >> --Sascha
> >>
> >> On 11/4/26 10:40 AM, Sebastian Moeller wrote:
> >>> Hi Sascha,
> >>>
> >>>
> >>>> On Nov 2, 2026, at 15:30, Sascha Meinrath <sascha@thexlab.org> wrote:
> >>>>
> >>>> I can't wait until the French Parliament learns about VPNs... It
> would be absolutely *wonderful* if all the ISPs passed along the tax to
> their customers... and then taught all their customers that VPNed traffic
> would, for obvious reasons, be exempted.
> >>>
> >>> Not how this is supposed to work: the ISP aggregates its end-customer
> bound traffic volume by ASN and reports these aggregates quarterly, the tax
> office sends the ASNs the tax bill. VPN does not really matter, except now
> it is the VPN provider that is on the hook for the money. The amendment
> does not address VPNs but for CDNs that are in a similar picckle the idea
> is that CDN operators either pass on the cost or "eat" it themselves (both
> half-baked ideas). The only oddity VPNs add is that they typically receive
> no money from the actual content providers, but the end users.
> >>>
> >>>>
> >>>> I find proposals like this to be absolutely idiotic -- and, they are
> yet another step in the global data obfuscation arms race.
> >>>
> >>> Oh, that proposal is pretty half-baked, no arggument there, but I
> think we differ in which of its half-baked-ness we consider worst ;)
> >>>
> >>>>
> >>>> #encrypteverything
> >>>
> >>> Well, if you look what this is supposed to operate on encryption is
> not really an option, as this operates on source and destination IP
> addresses, that are somewhat prickly to encrypt if you want packets
> delivered...
> >>>
> >>>>
> >>>> --Sascha
> >>>>
> >>>> On 11/2/26 6:23 AM, Sebastian Moeller via Nnagain wrote:
> >>>>> Hi Michael,
> >>>>>> On Nov 2, 2026, at 08:44, Michael Welzl <michawe@ifi.uio.no> wrote:
> >>>>>>
> >>>>>> The tax is 5 cents per Gigabyte. This is insane.
> >>>>> Back of the envelop calculations for video streaming (assuming this
> to be the one category driving most of the sustained capacity usage):
> >>>>> common use seems to be HD streaming (say on average at 5 Mbps), with
> say 2 hours per day, 7 days per week:
> >>>>> (5 * 1000^2) * (60 * 60 * 2 * 30) / (8 * 1000^3) = 135 GB
> >>>>> -> 135 * 0.055 = 7.425 Euro/month
> >>>>> typical cost for midrange (ad-free) video streaming in france: 8-15
> Euro
> >>>>> depending on the reference contract tier, the tax almost as large as
> the total revenue, no way this could be priced-in without significant price
> increases.
> >>>>> The proposed tax indeed seems quite steep, however it is capped at
> 15% of revenue in france or 2% of world-wide revenue
> >>>>> So that would get this more in like with a 15% tax... on revenue,
> still nothing to sneeze at, but a far cry from the numbers one gets when
> simply multiplying...
> >>>>> Regards
> >>>>> Sebastian
> >>>>> P.S.: My take this is half-baked and will not make it through the
> further legislative process in that form.
> >>>>>> It goes against how we agree to use the Internet.
> >>>>>>
> >>>>>> English version:
> >>>>>> "France has recently approved a highly controversial "Internet
> Traffic
> >>>>>> Tax" (or Gigabyte Tax) as part of the 2027 budget bill amendments.
> The
> >>>>>> new levy targets digital content providers based on the volume of
> data
> >>>>>> they transmit to French internet users, which is monitored by
> network
> >>>>>> operators and Internet Service Providers (ISPs) heavily utilizing
> >>>>>> Internet Exchange Points like France-IX."
> >>>>>>
> >>>>>> Google AI summary:
> >>>>>> "Key Metrics & Tax Rates
> >>>>>> • €0.055 per gigabyte charged to content providers.
> >>>>>> • Capped at 15% of a provider's French revenue.
> >>>>>> • Capped at 2% of a provider's global revenue.
> >>>>>> • Measured directly by French network operators and ISPs."
> >>>>>>
> >>>>>>
> >>>>>> On 2026-10-31 13:56, Frantisek Borsik wrote:
> >>>>>>> Crossposting, because this garbage idea might "inspire" more
> countries
> >>>>>>> and
> >>>>>>> have a horrible impact also on bufferbloat everywhere.
> >>>>>>>
> >>>>>>> *Original post by Dr. Peering:*
> >>>>>>>
> >>>>>>> *"The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own
> >>>>>>> country
> >>>>>>> by taxing Gigabits. Here’s Octave Klaba's excellent analysis [in
> >>>>>>> French,
> >>>>>>> link below] showing just how insane the finance bill actually is.
> The
> >>>>>>> IXP
> >>>>>>> taxation amount is, just for starters, ridiculous!"*
> >>>>>>>
> >>>>>>> https://x.com/drpeering/status/2116468659392807
> >>>>>>> <
> https://x.com/drpeering/status/2116468659392807381?a=E-elnbppn-MAi-LNIrU&s=46
> >
> >>>>>>>
> >>>>>>> *Octave's post:*
> >>>>>>>
> >>>>>>>
> https://fr.linkedin.com/posts/octave-klaba-3a0b3632_jai-lu-lamendement-i-1358-au-plf-2027-activity-7522219045576888320-uqkw
> >>>>>>>
> >>>>>>> *Copy+paste:*
> >>>>>>>
> >>>>>>> J'ai lu l'amendement I-1358 au PLF 2027, adopté ce vendredi à
> >>>>>>> l'Assemblée :
> >>>>>>> une taxe de 0,055 € par Go envoyé vers les abonnés des FAI
> français. Le
> >>>>>>> chiffre est abstrait, alors comparons-le. Corrigez-moi si vous
> voyez
> >>>>>>> des
> >>>>>>> erreurs.
> >>>>>>>
> >>>>>>> Deux comparaisons et un cas concret :
> >>>>>>>
> >>>>>>> 1. Le transit et le peering. Un port 100 Gbps coûte environ 6 300
> € par
> >>>>>>> mois chez un fournisseur de transit mondial. En interconnexion
> directe
> >>>>>>> avec
> >>>>>>> un FAI européen, compter 3 à 5 fois plus, soit 20 à 30 k€ par
> mois. Sur
> >>>>>>> ce
> >>>>>>> port (a), la taxe atteint 1,02 M€ par mois, soit environ 3400 % à
> 16300
> >>>>>>> %
> >>>>>>> du prix d'une interconnexion vers les FAI français. On change donc
> >>>>>>> profondément le modèle économique de la bande passante en France.
> >>>>>>>
> >>>>>>> 2. Les hyperscalers sont critiqués pour le prix de leur trafic
> sortant,
> >>>>>>> qui
> >>>>>>> va d'environ 0,08€ à 0,045€ par Go selon le volume. La taxe, 0,055
> €
> >>>>>>> par
> >>>>>>> Go, représente 68 % à 123 % de ce prix. On parle donc de doubler,
> pour
> >>>>>>> le
> >>>>>>> trafic vers la France, un prix déjà jugé trop élevé !
> >>>>>>>
> >>>>>>> 3. Le cas d'OVHcloud. Nous envoyons de l'ordre de 500 Gbps au 95e
> >>>>>>> percentile vers les FAI français, soit environ 324 Gbps en
> moyenne. Sur
> >>>>>>> un
> >>>>>>> an, la taxe brute atteindrait 70 M€. Le texte la plafonne à 15 %
> du CA
> >>>>>>> réalisé en France ou à 2 % du CA mondial, soit entre environ 23 et
> 70
> >>>>>>> M€
> >>>>>>> par an que nous devrions collecter pour l'État, et donc répercuter
> sur
> >>>>>>> nos
> >>>>>>> clients.
> >>>>>>>
> >>>>>>> Conclusions :
> >>>>>>>
> >>>>>>> 1. Une taxe porte en général sur une petite fraction de son
> assiette.
> >>>>>>> Celle-ci vaut plus de 3000 % du coût du transit, et environ 100 %
> du
> >>>>>>> prix
> >>>>>>> public des hyperscalers. Rappelez-vous la loi SREN, votée pour
> >>>>>>> supprimer
> >>>>>>> les frais de transfert qui empêchaient les clients de quitter un
> >>>>>>> fournisseur cloud. Ici, on parle de doubler le prix du trafic
> sortant
> >>>>>>> vers
> >>>>>>> les internautes français, un prix déjà très problématique.
> >>>>>>>
> >>>>>>> 2. Le garde-fou, un plafond calculé sur le chiffre d'affaires, est
> >>>>>>> incohérent. Ce chiffre d'affaires couvre des serveurs, du
> stockage, des
> >>>>>>> datacenters et des équipes sans rapport avec la bande passante.
> C'est
> >>>>>>> comme
> >>>>>>> créer une taxe calculée sur la consommation électrique des usines
> >>>>>>> automobiles en France, plafonnée à 15 % du chiffre d'affaires des
> >>>>>>> constructeurs. Quel rapport entre les deux ?
> >>>>>>>
> >>>>>>> 3. Une taxe nationale de ce type frappe à coup sûr les entreprises
> >>>>>>> établies
> >>>>>>> en France, alors que leurs concurrents mondiaux sans présence en
> France
> >>>>>>> livrent le même trafic aux mêmes FAI français sans payer cette
> taxe en
> >>>>>>> pratique. Cela crée une distorsion de concurrence au détriment des
> >>>>>>> acteurs
> >>>>>>> nationaux et déclasse les entreprises qui embauchent en France. Une
> >>>>>>> taxe
> >>>>>>> qui produit l'effet inverse serait une meilleure approche.
> >>>>>>>
> >>>>>>> (a) Facturé au 95e percentile, ce port n'est pas plein en
> permanence :
> >>>>>>> avec
> >>>>>>> un profil journalier type (22 % vers 4 h, 90 % vers 21 h), il
> >>>>>>> transporte en
> >>>>>>> moyenne 57 % de sa capacité, soit 18,6 millions de Go par mois.
> >>>>>>>
> >>>>>>>
> >>>>>>> All the best,
> >>>>>>>
> >>>>>>> Frank
> >>>>>>> Frantisek (Frank) Borsik
> >>>>>>>
> >>>>>>> In loving memory of Dave Täht: 1965-2025
> >>>>>>> https://libreqos.io/2025/04/01/in-loving-memory-of-dave/
> >>>>>>>
> >>>>>>>
> >>>>>>> https://www.linkedin.com/in/frantisekborsik
> >>>>>>> Signal, Telegram, WhatsApp: +421919416714 <+421%20919%20416%20714>
> <+421%20919%20416%20714>
> >>>>>>> iMessage, mobile: +420775230885 <775%20230%20885>
> <775%20230%20885>
> >>>>>>> Skype: casioa5302ca
> >>>>>>> frantisek.borsik@gmail.com
> >>>>>>> _______________________________________________
> >>>>>>> Bloat mailing list -- bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net
> >>>>>>> To unsubscribe send an email to bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
> >>>>>> _______________________________________________
> >>>>>> Bloat mailing list -- bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net
> >>>>>> To unsubscribe send an email to bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
> >>>>>> _______________________________________________
> >>>>>> Bloat mailing list -- bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net
> >>>>>> To unsubscribe send an email to bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
> >>>>> _______________________________________________
> >>>>> Nnagain mailing list -- nnagain@lists.bufferbloat.net
> >>>>> To unsubscribe send an email to nnagain-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
> >>>>
> >>>> --
> >>>> Sascha Meinrath
> >>>> Director, X-Lab
> >>>> Palmer Chair in Telecommunications
> >>>> Penn State University
> >>>
> >>>
> >>
> >
>
> --
> Sascha Meinrath
> Director, X-Lab
> Palmer Chair in Telecommunications
> Penn State University
>
>
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 40+ messages in thread
* [Starlink] Re: [Bloat] Re: [Cake] [NNagain] The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering)
2026-11-17 1:43 ` David P. Reed
2026-11-17 12:33 ` Juliusz Chroboczek
@ 2026-11-18 7:53 ` Frantisek Borsik
2026-11-18 9:25 ` David Lang
2 siblings, 0 replies; 40+ messages in thread
From: Frantisek Borsik @ 2026-11-18 7:53 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: David P. Reed
Cc: Juliusz Chroboczek, Sebastian Moeller, sascha,
Network Neutrality is back! Let´s make the technical aspects heard this time!,
Michael Welzl, Dave Taht via Starlink, bloat, Cake List, libreqos,
Jeremy Austin via Rpm
🙏
Frantisek Borsik reacted via Gmail
<https://www.google.com/gmail/about/?utm_source=gmail-in-product&utm_medium=et&utm_campaign=emojireactionemail#app>
On Mon, Nov 16, 2026 at 5:43 PM David P. Reed <dpreed@deepplum.com> wrote:
> There is a presumption that "providers" will just pay based on byte counts
> on their wires or wireless.
>
>
>
> But I don't get it. Why not just tax the physical assets, and not bother
> with byte counting at all?
>
>
>
> Do they tax theaters based on the number of words spoken by actors in the
> theater?
>
>
>
> My colleague at the Media Lab, Andy Lippman once talked about how Xerox
> might charge the users of its leased copiers based on end-user value - a
> copy of your kids homework might cost a nickel per page, but copying a
> corporate merger agreement for a billion dollar acquistion might be charged
> a few million dollars just for that one copy made.
>
>
>
> This attempts to tax the "value" of the bits copied or transmitted, as
> companies like airlines try to do with First Class vs. Coach prices, or
> other "value" pricing. In the case of bits on a wire, the actual cost of
> operations is not due to the bits, but the cost of installing and
> maintaining the wire.
>
>
>
> And of course, most of the value of a "network" isn't due to usage, but
> due to the optionality introduced by the ability to (at any time) reach any
> of the endpoints. That's been explained in Metcalfe's Law and Reed's Law -
> both of which try to value the option to send a message, which is usually
> worth more than the actual messages sent.
>
>
>
> Really, the EU technocracy should learn something about the communications
> business and communications economics.
>
>
>
> Otherwise their whole concept is just whacko.
>
>
>
> On Monday, November 16, 2026 18:04, "Juliusz Chroboczek" <jch@irif.fr>
> said:
>
> > > That is not ment to mean all is fine with the amendment (and we all
> seem
> > > to agree it is going nowhere and deservedly so), just that privacy or
> > > censorship in my opinion are not really affected.
> >
> > Fully agreed, on all counts.
> >
> > What is interesting, the rationale (``Exposé Sommaire'') explicitly
> > explains how user privacy is being protected:
> >
> > « This model does not raise issues related to privacy: the data are never
> > consulted. The tax does not involve any deep inspection of data
> > packets, no subscriber's personal data is audited, and it respects the
> > confidentiality of correspondence just like the GDPR: one counts bytes
> > by operator, not individual uses. Transit providers and CDNs are not
> > required to name their customers. They pass on the tax to them or not,
> > depending on their terms of service, while respecting trade secrets. »
> >
> > I'm not claiming the envisioned scenario is realistic, merely that the
> > authors did take user privacy into account.
> >
> > -- Juliusz
> >
>
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 40+ messages in thread
* [Starlink] Re: [Bloat] Re: [LibreQoS] Re: The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering)
2026-11-18 1:16 ` [Starlink] " Michael Richardson
@ 2026-11-18 9:17 ` David Lang
2026-11-18 13:37 ` Juliusz Chroboczek
0 siblings, 1 reply; 40+ messages in thread
From: David Lang @ 2026-11-18 9:17 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: Michael Richardson
Cc: David Lang,
Network Neutrality is back! Let´s make the technical aspects heard this time!,
Dave Taht via Starlink, bloat, Cake List, libreqos,
Jeremy Austin via Rpm
Michael Richardson wrote:
> David Lang <david@lang.hm> wrote:
> >> > The smart bit about the proposal is that it bases the tax on something
> >> > that cannot be moved offshore, the amount of traffic received by the
> >> > French user. (If the French user uses a VPN, then the holder of the ASN
> >> > of the VPN provider would be taxed.)
> >>
> >> To me, the idea of a tax on a bulk amount of data does seem smart.
>
> > Why? why should information transfer be taxed?
>
> Because governments need revenue in order to fund teachers in said school.
> France in particular.
making it more expensive for people to learn on their own in order to fund
teachers seems like a very teachers union way to do things
> >> TVs that sent Gb/s of data "home" would also be better noticed.
>
> > first off, who has Gb/s of upload capacity? and if it was all used by one tv,
> > they will notice no matter what.
>
> Numbers are approximate.
> https://www.reddit.com/r/LGOLED/comments/1k7x96o/lg_g3_70gb_of_upload_data_this_week/
> _LG G3 70GB of upload data this week_
70G of data uploaded in a week is 10G/day, so 250Mb of data per hour, or 71Kb/s
of data
that is not going to be noticed, even with a tax like this.
David Lang
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 40+ messages in thread
* [Starlink] Re: [Bloat] Re: [Cake] [NNagain] The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering)
2026-11-17 1:43 ` David P. Reed
2026-11-17 12:33 ` Juliusz Chroboczek
2026-11-18 7:53 ` Frantisek Borsik
@ 2026-11-18 9:25 ` David Lang
2 siblings, 0 replies; 40+ messages in thread
From: David Lang @ 2026-11-18 9:25 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: David P. Reed
Cc: Juliusz Chroboczek, Sebastian Moeller, sascha,
Network Neutrality is back! Let´s make the technical aspects heard this time!,
Michael Welzl, Frantisek Borsik, Dave Taht via Starlink, bloat,
Cake List, libreqos, Jeremy Austin via Rpm
David P. Reed wrote:
> There is a presumption that "providers" will just pay based on byte counts on their wires or wireless.
>
> But I don't get it. Why not just tax the physical assets, and not bother with byte counting at all?
They are targeting US content providers, they don't have the ability to tax them
directoy or their assets.
> This attempts to tax the "value" of the bits copied or transmitted, as
> companies like airlines try to do with First Class vs. Coach prices, or other
> "value" pricing. In the case of bits on a wire, the actual cost of operations
> is not due to the bits, but the cost of installing and maintaining the wire.
but that would require that they dig into the details of what those bits are,
which would be such a huge invasion of privacy that even they can't get away
with it
David Lang
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 40+ messages in thread
* [Starlink] Re: [Cake] Re: [NNagain] [Bloat] The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering)
2026-11-18 7:48 ` [Starlink] Re: [Cake] Re: [NNagain] [Bloat] " Frantisek Borsik
@ 2026-11-18 12:12 ` Sascha Meinrath
0 siblings, 0 replies; 40+ messages in thread
From: Sascha Meinrath @ 2026-11-18 12:12 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: Frantisek Borsik, David P. Reed
Cc: Sebastian Moeller,
Network Neutrality is back! Let´s make the technical aspects heard this time!,
Michael Welzl, Dave Taht via Starlink, bloat, Cake List, libreqos,
Jeremy Austin via Rpm
An apropos (Americentric) take on the importance of governments *subsidizing*
information access and media flow is Richard John's "Spreading the News":
https://www.hup.harvard.edu/books/978067483342
I would highly recommend -- in essence, John's historical analysis is that the
U.S. "experiment in Democracy" was, in large part, about the creation of its
postal service (one that both protected the integrity of communications and
subsidized newsprint, in particular).
And thus, when Frenchman, Alexis de Tocqueville, is writing "Democracy in
America" in the 1830s -- he's really encapsulating the impacts stemming from the
U.S. investment in information flow (which supports egalitarianism, innovation,
etc.). de Tocqueville explicitly calls out newsprint as one of the key hallmarks
of American Democracy -- and, of course, newsprint originally received *free*
transit in the U.S. postal system (a legacy still present in the various tiering
structures of today's postal service).
Maybe the French should learn from [checks notes]... the French.
--Sascha
On 11/18/26 2:48 AM, Frantisek Borsik wrote:
> 🙏
>
> Frantisek Borsik reacted via Gmail <https://www.google.com/gmail/about/?
> utm_source=gmail-in-product&utm_medium=et&utm_campaign=emojireactionemail#app>
>
>
> On Wed, Nov 4, 2026 at 9:57 AM David P. Reed <dpreed@deepplum.com
> <mailto:dpreed@deepplum.com>> wrote:
>
> Sascha, et al. -
>
> The law is never about "how will we enforce it", because (sarcasm on) such
> petty details as enforcement is not germane to Governments' Will to Control
> (sarcasm off).
>
> When they try to dream up "technical means" for enforcement, rather than
> just putting the law on the books, they may all of a sudden try to interfere
> with all kinds of Internet mechanisms. This won't be easy, but we have the
> history of Thought Control starting with the early Internet deployments
> where the words "breast" and so forth were supposed to be detected by all
> Internet routers in all packets. Senator Exon of the US got some "tech
> pundits" to say that was possible and easy, and I got involved politically
> to suppress the "Exon Box" idea, which was politically gaining steam, even
> among "progressives.:
>
> The issue, of course, is that the legislators invent dynamite-scale
> enforcement mechanisms that interfere with every damn thing in order to
> solve a pretty narrow problem.
>
> Note that the Post Office in most countries are NOT allowed to inspect all
> letters and packages. But the fascist instinct exists everywhere, even
> France. "There oughta be a law" is what voters first turn to, both on the
> Left and the RIght - which is why just saying "The Rule of Law" is not
> equivalent to democracy.
>
> If you want to charge a tax on a behavior of a consumer, you basically need
> to surveill actual consumption by each individual, which is not technically
> feasible. No more than enforcing a law that says you can't listen to the
> words of Islam or read Mein Kampf.
>
> I don't get really upset about this until the Tax Policy starts to move to
> an implementation that destroys our rights to privacy (meaning the right to
> be left alone, not the right to keep data secret).
>
> On Wednesday, November 4, 2026 12:03, "Sebastian Moeller via Cake"
> <cake@lists.bufferbloat.net <mailto:cake@lists.bufferbloat.net>> said:
>
> > Hi Sascha,
> >
> > On November 4, 2026 5:20:01 PM GMT+01:00, Sascha Meinrath
> > <sascha@thexlab.org <mailto:sascha@thexlab.org>> wrote:
> > >Hi Sebastian,
> > >
> > >My point is that if I VPNed to a point outside France, then a French ISP
> would
> > have no way to know that I've accessed the type of media that should be
> taxed.
> >
> >
> > A misunderstanding, the amendment prposes to tax every single bit
> independent of
> > the source... it makes zero exemptions, not for FOSS, not for non
> commercially ial
> > entities. Sure the motivation is to tax big tech primarily, but the current
> > (half-baked) legal implementation is not differentiating...
> >
> >
> > > In essence, VPNs (and proxy services) would create extraordinary
> problems for
> > even instrumenting the proposed taxing regime.
> >
> > How? Like with a CDN the tax would hit the vpn provider... the ASN of the
> source
> > IP....
> >
> >
> >
> >
> > >
> > >--Sascha
> > >
> > >On 11/4/26 10:40 AM, Sebastian Moeller wrote:
> > >> Hi Sascha,
> > >>
> > >>
> > >>> On Nov 2, 2026, at 15:30, Sascha Meinrath <sascha@thexlab.org
> <mailto:sascha@thexlab.org>>
> > wrote:
> > >>>
> > >>> I can't wait until the French Parliament learns about VPNs... It
> > would be absolutely *wonderful* if all the ISPs passed along the tax to their
> > customers... and then taught all their customers that VPNed traffic
> would, for
> > obvious reasons, be exempted.
> > >>
> > >> Not how this is supposed to work: the ISP aggregates its end-customer
> > bound traffic volume by ASN and reports these aggregates quarterly, the
> tax office
> > sends the ASNs the tax bill. VPN does not really matter, except now it is
> the VPN
> > provider that is on the hook for the money. The amendment does not
> address VPNs
> > but for CDNs that are in a similar picckle the idea is that CDN operators
> either
> > pass on the cost or "eat" it themselves (both half-baked ideas). The only
> oddity
> > VPNs add is that they typically receive no money from the actual content
> > providers, but the end users.
> > >>
> > >>>
> > >>> I find proposals like this to be absolutely idiotic -- and, they are
> > yet another step in the global data obfuscation arms race.
> > >>
> > >> Oh, that proposal is pretty half-baked, no arggument there, but I think
> > we differ in which of its half-baked-ness we consider worst ;)
> > >>
> > >>>
> > >>> #encrypteverything
> > >>
> > >> Well, if you look what this is supposed to operate on encryption is not
> > really an option, as this operates on source and destination IP
> addresses, that
> > are somewhat prickly to encrypt if you want packets delivered...
> > >>
> > >>>
> > >>> --Sascha
> > >>>
> > >>> On 11/2/26 6:23 AM, Sebastian Moeller via Nnagain wrote:
> > >>>> Hi Michael,
> > >>>>> On Nov 2, 2026, at 08:44, Michael Welzl
> > <michawe@ifi.uio.no <mailto:michawe@ifi.uio.no>> wrote:
> > >>>>>
> > >>>>> The tax is 5 cents per Gigabyte. This is insane.
> > >>>> Back of the envelop calculations for video streaming (assuming
> > this to be the one category driving most of the sustained capacity usage):
> > >>>> common use seems to be HD streaming (say on average at 5 Mbps),
> > with say 2 hours per day, 7 days per week:
> > >>>> (5 * 1000^2) * (60 * 60 * 2 * 30) / (8 * 1000^3) = 135 GB
> > >>>> -> 135 * 0.055 = 7.425 Euro/month
> > >>>> typical cost for midrange (ad-free) video streaming in france:
> > 8-15 Euro
> > >>>> depending on the reference contract tier, the tax almost as large
> > as the total revenue, no way this could be priced-in without significant
> price
> > increases.
> > >>>> The proposed tax indeed seems quite steep, however it is capped
> > at 15% of revenue in france or 2% of world-wide revenue
> > >>>> So that would get this more in like with a 15% tax... on revenue,
> > still nothing to sneeze at, but a far cry from the numbers one gets when
> simply
> > multiplying...
> > >>>> Regards
> > >>>> Sebastian
> > >>>> P.S.: My take this is half-baked and will not make it through the
> > further legislative process in that form.
> > >>>>> It goes against how we agree to use the Internet.
> > >>>>>
> > >>>>> English version:
> > >>>>> "France has recently approved a highly controversial
> > "Internet Traffic
> > >>>>> Tax" (or Gigabyte Tax) as part of the 2027 budget bill
> > amendments. The
> > >>>>> new levy targets digital content providers based on the
> > volume of data
> > >>>>> they transmit to French internet users, which is monitored by
> > network
> > >>>>> operators and Internet Service Providers (ISPs) heavily
> > utilizing
> > >>>>> Internet Exchange Points like France-IX."
> > >>>>>
> > >>>>> Google AI summary:
> > >>>>> "Key Metrics & Tax Rates
> > >>>>> • €0.055 per gigabyte charged to content
> > providers.
> > >>>>> • Capped at 15% of a provider's French revenue.
> > >>>>> • Capped at 2% of a provider's global revenue.
> > >>>>> • Measured directly by French network operators and
> > ISPs."
> > >>>>>
> > >>>>>
> > >>>>> On 2026-10-31 13:56, Frantisek Borsik wrote:
> > >>>>>> Crossposting, because this garbage idea might "inspire"
> > more countries
> > >>>>>> and
> > >>>>>> have a horrible impact also on bufferbloat everywhere.
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> *Original post by Dr. Peering:*
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> *"The French have decided to destroy the Internet within
> > their own
> > >>>>>> country
> > >>>>>> by taxing Gigabits. Here’s Octave Klaba's excellent
> > analysis [in
> > >>>>>> French,
> > >>>>>> link below] showing just how insane the finance bill
> > actually is. The
> > >>>>>> IXP
> > >>>>>> taxation amount is, just for starters, ridiculous!"*
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> https://x.com/drpeering/status/2116468659392807 <https://x.com/
> drpeering/status/2116468659392807>
> > >>>>>>
> > <https://x.com/drpeering/status/2116468659392807381?a=E-elnbppn-MAi-
> LNIrU&s=46 <https://x.com/drpeering/status/2116468659392807381?a=E-elnbppn-
> MAi-LNIrU&s=46>>
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> *Octave's post:*
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>>
> > https://fr.linkedin.com/posts/octave-klaba-3a0b3632_jai-lu-lamendement-
> i-1358-au-plf-2027-activity-7522219045576888320-uqkw <https://
> fr.linkedin.com/posts/octave-klaba-3a0b3632_jai-lu-lamendement-i-1358-au-
> plf-2027-activity-7522219045576888320-uqkw>
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> *Copy+paste:*
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> J'ai lu l'amendement I-1358 au PLF 2027, adopté ce
> > vendredi à
> > >>>>>> l'Assemblée :
> > >>>>>> une taxe de 0,055 € par Go envoyé vers les
> > abonnés des FAI français. Le
> > >>>>>> chiffre est abstrait, alors comparons-le. Corrigez-moi si
> > vous voyez
> > >>>>>> des
> > >>>>>> erreurs.
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> Deux comparaisons et un cas concret :
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> 1. Le transit et le peering. Un port 100 Gbps coûte
> > environ 6 300 € par
> > >>>>>> mois chez un fournisseur de transit mondial. En
> > interconnexion directe
> > >>>>>> avec
> > >>>>>> un FAI européen, compter 3 à 5 fois plus,
> > soit 20 à 30 k€ par mois. Sur
> > >>>>>> ce
> > >>>>>> port (a), la taxe atteint 1,02 M€ par mois, soit
> > environ 3400 % à 16300
> > >>>>>> %
> > >>>>>> du prix d'une interconnexion vers les FAI
> > français. On change donc
> > >>>>>> profondément le modèle économique de
> > la bande passante en France.
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> 2. Les hyperscalers sont critiqués pour le prix de
> > leur trafic sortant,
> > >>>>>> qui
> > >>>>>> va d'environ 0,08€ à 0,045€ par Go selon
> > le volume. La taxe, 0,055 €
> > >>>>>> par
> > >>>>>> Go, représente 68 % à 123 % de ce prix. On
> > parle donc de doubler, pour
> > >>>>>> le
> > >>>>>> trafic vers la France, un prix déjà
> > jugé trop élevé !
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> 3. Le cas d'OVHcloud. Nous envoyons de l'ordre de 500
> > Gbps au 95e
> > >>>>>> percentile vers les FAI français, soit environ 324
> > Gbps en moyenne. Sur
> > >>>>>> un
> > >>>>>> an, la taxe brute atteindrait 70 M€. Le texte la
> > plafonne à 15 % du CA
> > >>>>>> réalisé en France ou à 2 % du CA
> > mondial, soit entre environ 23 et 70
> > >>>>>> M€
> > >>>>>> par an que nous devrions collecter pour l'État, et
> > donc répercuter sur
> > >>>>>> nos
> > >>>>>> clients.
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> Conclusions :
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> 1. Une taxe porte en général sur une petite
> > fraction de son assiette.
> > >>>>>> Celle-ci vaut plus de 3000 % du coût du transit, et
> > environ 100 % du
> > >>>>>> prix
> > >>>>>> public des hyperscalers. Rappelez-vous la loi SREN,
> > votée pour
> > >>>>>> supprimer
> > >>>>>> les frais de transfert qui empêchaient les clients
> > de quitter un
> > >>>>>> fournisseur cloud. Ici, on parle de doubler le prix du
> > trafic sortant
> > >>>>>> vers
> > >>>>>> les internautes français, un prix
> > déjà très problématique.
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> 2. Le garde-fou, un plafond calculé sur le chiffre
> > d'affaires, est
> > >>>>>> incohérent. Ce chiffre d'affaires couvre des
> > serveurs, du stockage, des
> > >>>>>> datacenters et des équipes sans rapport avec la
> > bande passante. C'est
> > >>>>>> comme
> > >>>>>> créer une taxe calculée sur la consommation
> > électrique des usines
> > >>>>>> automobiles en France, plafonnée à 15 % du
> > chiffre d'affaires des
> > >>>>>> constructeurs. Quel rapport entre les deux ?
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> 3. Une taxe nationale de ce type frappe à coup
> > sûr les entreprises
> > >>>>>> établies
> > >>>>>> en France, alors que leurs concurrents mondiaux sans
> > présence en France
> > >>>>>> livrent le même trafic aux mêmes FAI
> > français sans payer cette taxe en
> > >>>>>> pratique. Cela crée une distorsion de concurrence
> > au détriment des
> > >>>>>> acteurs
> > >>>>>> nationaux et déclasse les entreprises qui
> > embauchent en France. Une
> > >>>>>> taxe
> > >>>>>> qui produit l'effet inverse serait une meilleure
> > approche.
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> (a) Facturé au 95e percentile, ce port n'est pas
> > plein en permanence :
> > >>>>>> avec
> > >>>>>> un profil journalier type (22 % vers 4 h, 90 % vers 21
> > h), il
> > >>>>>> transporte en
> > >>>>>> moyenne 57 % de sa capacité, soit 18,6 millions de
> > Go par mois.
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> All the best,
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> Frank
> > >>>>>> Frantisek (Frank) Borsik
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> In loving memory of Dave Täht: 1965-2025
> > >>>>>> https://libreqos.io/2025/04/01/in-loving-memory-of-dave/ <https://
> libreqos.io/2025/04/01/in-loving-memory-of-dave/>
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>>
> > >>>>>> https://www.linkedin.com/in/frantisekborsik <https://
> www.linkedin.com/in/frantisekborsik>
> > >>>>>> Signal, Telegram, WhatsApp: +421919416714 <tel:+421%20919%20416%20714>
> > <+421%20919%20416%20714>
> > >>>>>> iMessage, mobile: +420775230885 <tel:775%20230%20885>
> <775%20230%20885>
> > >>>>>> Skype: casioa5302ca
> > >>>>>> frantisek.borsik@gmail.com <mailto:frantisek.borsik@gmail.com>
> > >>>>>> _______________________________________________
> > >>>>>> Bloat mailing list -- bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net
> <mailto:bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net>
> > >>>>>> To unsubscribe send an email to
> > bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net <mailto:bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net>
> > >>>>> _______________________________________________
> > >>>>> Bloat mailing list -- bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net
> <mailto:bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net>
> > >>>>> To unsubscribe send an email to
> > bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net <mailto:bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net>
> > >>>>> _______________________________________________
> > >>>>> Bloat mailing list -- bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net
> <mailto:bloat@lists.bufferbloat.net>
> > >>>>> To unsubscribe send an email to
> > bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net <mailto:bloat-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net>
> > >>>> _______________________________________________
> > >>>> Nnagain mailing list -- nnagain@lists.bufferbloat.net
> <mailto:nnagain@lists.bufferbloat.net>
> > >>>> To unsubscribe send an email to
> > nnagain-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net <mailto:nnagain-
> leave@lists.bufferbloat.net>
> > >>>
> > >>> --
> > >>> Sascha Meinrath
> > >>> Director, X-Lab
> > >>> Palmer Chair in Telecommunications
> > >>> Penn State University
> > >>
> > >>
> > >
> >
> > --
> > Sent from my Android device with K-9 Mail. Please excuse my brevity.
> > _______________________________________________
> > Cake mailing list -- cake@lists.bufferbloat.net
> <mailto:cake@lists.bufferbloat.net>
> > To unsubscribe send an email to cake-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net
> <mailto:cake-leave@lists.bufferbloat.net>
> >
>
--
Sascha Meinrath
Director, X-Lab
Palmer Chair in Telecommunications
Penn State University
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 40+ messages in thread
* [Starlink] Re: [Bloat] Re: [LibreQoS] Re: The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering)
2026-11-18 9:17 ` David Lang
@ 2026-11-18 13:37 ` Juliusz Chroboczek
2026-11-18 23:22 ` David Lang
0 siblings, 1 reply; 40+ messages in thread
From: Juliusz Chroboczek @ 2026-11-18 13:37 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: David Lang
Cc: Michael Richardson,
Network Neutrality is back! Let´s make the technical aspects heard this time!,
Dave Taht via Starlink, bloat, Cake List, libreqos,
Jeremy Austin via Rpm
>> Because governments need revenue in order to fund teachers in said school.
>> France in particular.
> making it more expensive for people to learn on their own in order to fund
> teachers seems like a very teachers union way to do things
Please try to think about it as an engineering problem, not an ideological
issue.
Problem statement: France is dependent on USAian online services (Gmail,
Google docs, Zoom, Netflix, Amazon, etc.). The USAian service providers
are barely paying any corporate tax in France. The ultimate goal is to
have 10 G€ per year go into the French taxpayer's pocket instead of the
USAian shareholder's.
Conflict of Interest: as a French taxpayer, I have a personal financial
interest in the problem being solved. Those of you who are in the USA
have a personal financial interest in it being not. This has nothing to
do with ideology.
Additional constraints: respect user privacy, do not filter parts of the
Internet, make love, not war.
Proposed solutions:
- invade California and force Google et al. to pay French corporate tax;
this violates the "not war" constraint;
- create native services and gently encourage users to switch; this has
been tried for 20 years now, and empirical data shows it doesn't work,
people continue using Zoom and Gmail even when free alternatives exist;
- create native services and order users to switch; this is only
implementable in the public sector, but works reasonably well when it
is done right (e.g. in the French Gendarmerie Nationale);
- create a proxy tax that Google at al. will be forced to pay, for
example by taxing incoming traffic (what this discussion is about).
None of these solutions are satisfactory, a new idea is needed. But the
problem is real, and not specific to France.
-- Juliusz
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 40+ messages in thread
* [Starlink] Re: [Bloat] Re: [LibreQoS] Re: The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering)
2026-11-18 13:37 ` Juliusz Chroboczek
@ 2026-11-18 23:22 ` David Lang
0 siblings, 0 replies; 40+ messages in thread
From: David Lang @ 2026-11-18 23:22 UTC (permalink / raw)
To: Juliusz Chroboczek
Cc: David Lang, Michael Richardson,
Network Neutrality is back! Let´s make the technical aspects heard this time!,
Dave Taht via Starlink, bloat, Cake List, libreqos,
Jeremy Austin via Rpm
Juliusz Chroboczek wrote:
> Problem statement: France is dependent on USAian online services (Gmail,
> Google docs, Zoom, Netflix, Amazon, etc.). The USAian service providers
> are barely paying any corporate tax in France. The ultimate goal is to
> have 10 G€ per year go into the French taxpayer's pocket instead of the
> USAian shareholder's.
> - create native services and gently encourage users to switch; this has
> been tried for 20 years now, and empirical data shows it doesn't work,
> people continue using Zoom and Gmail even when free alternatives exist;
mostly people are using the free tiers of Zoom and Gmail, so why should they
switch?
> - create a proxy tax that Google at al. will be forced to pay, for
> example by taxing incoming traffic (what this discussion is about).
ahh, but it doesn't only affect the monster companies that could afford to pay
it, it will affect everyone, no matter how small.
and email (gmail) is not going to be a significant amount of traffic/revenue
compared to streaming video, so it won't be affected.
The logical things is for the big streaming companies to pass this tax
along to the people who are making the content that you are taxing. Having
someone hit with a big bill because their content became popular in
france is a great way to get people to make their content unavailable in france.
> None of these solutions are satisfactory, a new idea is needed. But the
> problem is real, and not specific to France.
I think it's worth looking at why local people aren't making more of your
content/tools?
If you want more locally generated content and tools, then you need to change
the conditions/culture that are slowing/blocking such use, not reduce the access
to useful content.
David Lang
^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 40+ messages in thread
end of thread, other threads:[~2026-11-18 23:22 UTC | newest]
Thread overview: 40+ messages (download: mbox.gz follow: Atom feed
-- links below jump to the message on this page --
2026-10-31 12:56 [Starlink] The French have decided to destroy the Internet within their own country by taxing Gigabits (Dr. Peering) Frantisek Borsik
2026-10-31 14:51 ` [Starlink] Re: [Bloat] " Sophie
2026-10-31 14:58 ` [Starlink] " Inemesit Affia
2026-10-31 18:05 ` [Starlink] " Daniel AJ Sokolov
2026-11-02 7:44 ` [Starlink] [Bloat] " Michael Welzl
2026-11-02 11:23 ` [Starlink] Re: [Bloat] " Sebastian Moeller
2026-11-02 14:30 ` [Starlink] Re: [NNagain] " Sascha Meinrath
2026-11-04 15:40 ` [Starlink] Re: [NNagain] " Sebastian Moeller
2026-11-04 16:20 ` Sascha Meinrath
2026-11-04 17:03 ` Sebastian Moeller
2026-11-04 17:57 ` [Starlink] Re: [Cake] " David P. Reed
2026-11-05 9:05 ` [Starlink] Re: [Cake] " Sebastian Moeller
2026-11-16 23:04 ` [Starlink] Re: [Bloat] Re: [Cake] [NNagain] " Juliusz Chroboczek
2026-11-17 1:43 ` David P. Reed
2026-11-17 12:33 ` Juliusz Chroboczek
2026-11-18 7:53 ` Frantisek Borsik
2026-11-18 9:25 ` David Lang
2026-11-18 7:48 ` [Starlink] Re: [Cake] Re: [NNagain] [Bloat] " Frantisek Borsik
2026-11-18 12:12 ` Sascha Meinrath
2026-11-04 18:33 ` [Starlink] " Sascha Meinrath
2026-11-04 19:09 ` Sebastian Moeller
2026-11-04 19:14 ` [Starlink] Re: [Bloat] Re: [NNagain] " David Lang
2026-11-04 19:20 ` [Starlink] Re: [Bloat] " Sebastian Moeller
2026-11-04 19:26 ` [Starlink] Re: [NNagain] Re: [Bloat] " Olivier MJ Crépin-Leblond
2026-11-18 7:49 ` [Starlink] Re: [NNagain] " Frantisek Borsik
2026-11-18 1:48 ` [Starlink] Re: [NNagain] " Raquel Renno Nunes
2026-11-18 7:46 ` Frantisek Borsik
[not found] ` <bf2f7d692a5e42738403850d419c4a94@OS5P279MB0502.NORP279.PROD.OUTLOOK.COM>
2026-11-02 11:33 ` [Starlink] " Michael Welzl
2026-11-16 16:11 ` Juliusz Chroboczek
2026-11-16 16:31 ` [Starlink] Re: [LibreQoS] " Frantisek (Frank) Borsik
2026-11-16 20:41 ` [Starlink] Re: [Bloat] Re: [LibreQoS] " Linus Lüssing
2026-11-16 22:53 ` Juliusz Chroboczek
2026-11-17 15:59 ` Michael Richardson
2026-11-18 0:13 ` David Lang
2026-11-18 0:36 ` [Starlink] Re: [NNagain] " Richard Roy
2026-11-18 1:16 ` [Starlink] " Michael Richardson
2026-11-18 9:17 ` David Lang
2026-11-18 13:37 ` Juliusz Chroboczek
2026-11-18 23:22 ` David Lang
2026-11-17 6:36 ` [Starlink] Re: [LibreQoS] Re: [Bloat] " Sebastian Moeller
This is a public inbox, see mirroring instructions
for how to clone and mirror all data and code used for this inbox